Looking for the best lake house rentals in New York? After visiting the state’s top lakes and exploring its beautiful regions, I’ve stayed in some incredible vacation homes on both Airbnb and Vrbo. From charming cottages on the shores of Lake George to luxury retreats overlooking Lake Champlain, these rentals provide the perfect base for exploring New York’s scenic lakes and natural beauty. Let me share my top recommendations for unforgettable stays in New York’s most stunning lakefront destinations!
The 13 Coolest Lakefront New York Rentals
Here are the best lake house Airbnbs and VRBOs in New York by category, including amenities, trip types, and budgets. The subsequent sections will cover each listing in more detail.
- Top Overall: Pine Cone Point
- Best Luxury Lake Cabin: Top Lake House for Rent Near NYC
- Most Romantic: Catskills Cabin in the Wilderness
- Best for Large Groups: Spacious Waterfront Rental in the Heart of NY
- Top Cheap VRBO Lake House: Cozy Lakeside Getaway in NY
- Best Lakeside Cabin: Lazy Loon Cottage Rental by the Lake in NY
- Best Lake House Views: Waterfront Lake House near Lake George NY
- Most Unique: Lakefront Sunset Cottage to Rent in NY on Lake Ontario
If romantic lakefront cottages, tiny cabins, and luxury lake houses are what you’re looking for, prepare to be amazed! Below are some of the most unique lake stays in NY:
Before you book anything, don’t miss these deals 👇
- ✈️ Find cheap flights you won't see on Google - Going.com saves me $200+ per ticket
- 🏨 Book your stay – The best 2025 deals on boutique hotels and vacation homes
1. Best of Both Lakefront Cottage
- 📍 Location: Sodus Point, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $300/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 10 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Lakefront porch, jetted tub, dog-friendly, large yard, board games
- 🌟 Perfect For: Sunset watchers 🌅, families with kids 👨👩👧👦, beach lovers 🏖️
Welcome to the “Best of Both” Lakefront Cottage, a beautifully updated 100-year-old home with views of Lake Ontario right from the front porch. Nestled in a quiet neighborhood, this spacious retreat offers five bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a full kitchen, and two sitting areas—ideal for large families or groups of friends.
The big yard provides plenty of space for kids to run and play while the adults relax, fire up the grill, or unwind on the porch. On rainy days, gather inside for family fun with puzzles and board games already stocked and ready.
You’re just a short walk from Sodus Point Beach Park, the charming Sodus Bay Lighthouse Museum (only 3 minutes away), and the area’s live music, bars, and restaurants. Enjoy boating or kayaking in Sodus Bay, or simply savor the peaceful sunsets. This cottage truly offers the best of both worlds.
2. Charming Mid-Century Lakefront Home
- 📍 Location: Mongaup Valley, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $620/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 11 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Lakefront, private dock, hot tub, kayaks, paddleboards, arcade game room
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family vacations 👨👩👧👦, lake lovers 🚣, entertainment-filled stays 🎮
Welcome to this private lakefront retreat on Swinging Bridge Lake. This spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sleeps 11 and has everything you need for a relaxing, fun-filled getaway.
The Great Room features a wood-burning fireplace and floor-to-ceiling views of the lake, perfect for cozy mornings or winding down at night. The open kitchen makes cooking easy, and you can dine indoors or outside under the gazebo. After a day on the water, unwind in the new hot tub or gather around the fire pit.
Kids and adults alike will love the brand-new game room, complete with arcade machines, ping pong, Xbox, and Oculus VR. Step right off the dock to kayak or paddleboard, or hang out in the yard with lawn games.
While the home feels secluded, you’re just a short drive from Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, Resorts World Catskills, Monticello Casino, and the Kartrite Indoor Water Park.
3. Lakefront Cottage
- 📍 Location: Stoney Point, Lake Erie, near Westfield, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $300/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private beachfront, lake and creek views, direct beach access, walkable to Barcelona Harbor
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family getaways 👨👩👧👦, fishing trips 🎣, lake lovers 🌅
Set along the peaceful shores of Lake Erie, this spacious lakefront cottage offers a comfortable, all-season retreat for families or groups of friends.
Nestled in a quiet, wooded setting on Stoney Point, the home features direct beach access, a large porch perfect for taking in colorful sunsets, and cozy indoor and outdoor gathering spaces. With two bedrooms, three bathrooms, and room to sleep eight, there’s plenty of space to relax after a day of lakeside fun.
Spend your time collecting beach glass, walking to Barcelona Harbor for fresh fish and cocktails, or casting a line into the legendary Chautauqua Creek fishery. In summer, explore Chautauqua Lake by boat or enjoy a tour through Lake Erie Wine Country. In winter, head to nearby ski resorts and snowmobile trails for cold-weather adventures
✈️ Pro Travel Tip:
I use Going.com to find crazy flight deals...($300 roundtrip to Europe kind of crazy).
It’s free, and I honestly check it more than Google Flights. For a limited time only, they are offering 25% off on Premium and Elite to readers of my website, using my special code: JON25)
4. Garden Cottage
- 📍 Location: Whiteface Club Resort, Lake Placid, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $394/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 4 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Historic stone fireplace, cathedral beam ceilings, private garden, access to beach, golf, and cross-country ski trails
- 🌟 Perfect For: Romantic escapes 💑, honeymoons 💍, nature-filled retreats 🌲
If you’re dreaming of a peaceful mountain retreat with a touch of timeless charm, the Garden Cottage at Whiteface Club Resort is calling your name.
Once a 19th-century smoking gazebo for the original inn, this lovingly restored 1-bedroom cottage blends Adirondack history with modern comfort. From a birch tree headboard to a custom dining table crafted by local artisan Steve Bowers, every detail is thoughtful and unique, offering warmth and character in every corner.
Outside, guests enjoy a private garden and a cozy stone hearth, along with access to resort amenities like lakeside dining, a private beach, clay tennis courts, and an 18-hole championship golf course. In the winter, snowshoe or ski right from your doorstep.
In summer, dive into Lake Placid or wander nearby trails. Just minutes from Main Street Lake Placid, this cottage is perfect for couples or solo travelers seeking rustic elegance and quiet mountain beauty.
5. Lake LaFever Log Estate – Luxury Lakefront Retreat
- 📍 Location: East Meredith, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $295/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private lakefront, firepit on the point, spacious log cabin design, boats included, large deck with panoramic views
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family getaways 👨👩👧👦, fishing trips 🎣, nature retreats 🌲
If you’re looking for a secluded lakefront escape with rustic charm, Lake LaFever Log Estate is the perfect retreat. This 2,800 sq. ft. luxury log cabin offers breathtaking water views, a fire pit on the point, and complimentary boats for exploring the lake.
Unwind on the spacious deck or balcony, gather around the fire pit, and enjoy meals in the separate dining area. The fully equipped kitchen makes home-cooked meals easy, while modern amenities like air conditioning, a washer, and a BBQ grill ensure a comfortable stay.
With easy access to Hobart Book Village, Brewery Ommegang, and the National Baseball Hall of Fame, this cabin is a peaceful getaway with nearby attractions for adventure.
Whether you’re fishing, relaxing by the fire, or taking in the lake views, Lake LaFever Log Estate is the perfect setting for a nature-filled escape.
6. Cozy Home with Stunning Views
- 📍 Location: Willsboro, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $400/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 13 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private beach, outdoor fire pit, Foosball table, mini-refrigerator, ping pong, pet-free property
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family vacations 👨👩👧👦, outdoor enthusiasts 🌲, lake lovers 🚣♀️, relaxation seekers 🌅
This beautiful Lake Champlain home offers stunning lake views and is the perfect getaway for family and friends. With 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, it comfortably sleeps up to 13 guests.
The Great Room features a vaulted wood ceiling and a sectional couch, providing a cozy space to relax while enjoying panoramic views of the lake. The expansive deck, equipped with a new dining set and a Blackstone grill, is perfect for dining outdoors.
Surrounded by nature, the property is ideal for hiking or biking and boasts a private beach for sunbathing and swimming. Guests can explore local wineries, Ausable Chasm, the University of Vermont, or visit Church Street Marketplace.
The downstairs area is a hit with kids, featuring a flat-screen TV, games, and a ping-pong table. Whether you seek outdoor adventure or wish to unwind by the fire, this home provides the perfect mix of relaxation and fun.
7. The Pine Cone Point Home
- 📍 Location: Brantingham, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $225/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 9 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private waterfrontage, two docks, screened porch, canoe & kayaks, no stairs to water
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 🏖️, nature lovers 🌲, water sports enthusiasts 🚤
Welcome to Pine Cone Point – a cozy Adirondack camp with 180 feet of pristine Brantingham Lake frontage. Perfect for families or groups, this rustic getaway blends lakeside fun with classic cabin charm.
Inside, the knotty pine interior and stone wood-burning fireplace set the scene for relaxing nights. The fully equipped kitchen, spacious living room, and screened porch overlooking the lake offer space to unwind and connect. Upstairs, you’ll find a loft and two bedrooms that comfortably sleep up to 9 guests.
Step outside and you’re just feet from the water, with private lake access, canoes, kayaks, and a shallow swimming area ready to enjoy.
When you’re ready to explore, local favorites like Snow Ridge Ski Resort (10 minutes), Brantingham Lake (6 minutes), and scenic Dark Island (a 14-minute walk) are close by. Whether it’s hiking, biking, boating, or fishing, this spot puts you right in the heart of the Adirondacks.
8. Modern Lakeside Cabin
- 📍 Location: Bolton Landing, NY, on Lake George
- 💵 Price Per Night: $343/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private HOA sandy beach, 2 kayaks & 2 SUPs, stunning lake views, outdoor fire pit
- 🌟 Perfect For: Relaxing lake getaways 🌊, adventure seekers 🚣, cozy retreats by the fire 🔥
Tucked along the scenic shores of Lake George, this modern lakeside cabin is a dream retreat for nature lovers and water adventurers alike. Floor-to-ceiling windows flood the space with sunlight, while the open-concept layout seamlessly connects the kitchen, dining, and living areas, creating a warm, welcoming vibe from the moment you arrive.
Just steps from the cabin, you’ll find a private HOA sandy beach, perfect for sunny afternoons and lake swims. Spend the day paddling with the included kayaks and stand-up paddleboards, then wind down by the fire pit under the stars.
For off-the-water fun, head to nearby favorites like the Adirondack Extreme Adventure Course or play a round at The Sagamore Golf Club. With two bedrooms and a cozy loft, this stylish getaway sleeps six—ideal for families, couples, or small groups ready to relax in lakeside comfort.
9. Cozy Lake House with Amazing Views
- 📍 Location: Lake Luzerne, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $298/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Fire pit, private dock, hammock, Adirondack chairs, game room, outdoor play area
- 🌟 Perfect For: Nature lovers 🌲, water enthusiasts 🚤, adventure seekers 🏞️, families 👨👩👧👦
Discover the charm of the Lake Luzerne Home, set right on the Hudson River—a perfect spot for both relaxation and adventure. Start your day casting a line from your private dock, hiking the trails at Moreau Lake State Park, or heading out for a whitewater rafting trip nearby. There’s something for every kind of outdoor lover here.
After a day of exploring, wind down by the fire pit with mountain views or watch the sun set over the river. Inside, this 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offers cozy comfort, including free WiFi, a fully equipped kitchen, and a fun-packed game room with pool, air hockey, and arcade machines.
Nearby, enjoy skiing at West Mountain in winter or tubing at Tubby Tubes River Co. in summer. Take a short drive to Saratoga Springs for shopping, dining, and attractions like Saratoga Spa State Park, the Saratoga Automobile Museum, and the Saratoga Race Course. Just 17 minutes away, Lake George awaits with beaches, boat rentals, and lakefront fun.
10. Lazy Loon Cottage
- 📍 Location: Hammondsport, NY, on Keuka Lake
- 💵 Price Per Night: $275/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Lakefront views, private deck, outdoor play area, pet-friendly
- 🌟 Perfect For: Couples retreats 💑, family vacations 👨👩👧👦, wine tours 🍷
Tucked along the peaceful shores of Keuka Lake, Lazy Loon Cottage is a charming retreat with stunning lake views and all the cozy touches that make a getaway special. With 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and 1,200 square feet of inviting space, it’s a great fit for families or small groups looking to slow down and soak up the lakeside vibe.
Start your mornings with sunrise views over the water, sip coffee on the private deck, or let the kids enjoy the outdoor play area. Just a 1-minute stroll brings you to the lake for swimming, fishing, or kayaking.
Wine lovers will enjoy being just 18 minutes from Keuka Lake Vineyards and other standout wineries. In the colder months, cozy up indoors and watch the snow fall across the lake.
Whether you’re after peace and quiet or outdoor fun, Lazy Loon Cottage is the kind of place where lifelong memories are made.
- Read Next: 20 Magical Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes
11. Log Cabin on a Lake
- 📍 Location: Holmes, NY
- 💵 Price Per Night: $458/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private lakefront, sandy beach, swim dock, canoe, kayak & paddleboard included
- 🌟 Perfect For: Couples 💑, families 👨👩👧👦, lake lovers 🛶
Welcome to the Log Cabin on the Lake – a peaceful retreat just one hour from NYC. Nestled on Lake Dutchess, this cozy cabin offers private lake access, a sandy beach, and everything you need for a relaxing escape.
Inside, the fully equipped kitchen, dining area, and living space open onto a deck with water views – perfect for morning coffee or sunsets. With three bedrooms and one bathroom, the cabin sleeps up to 6 guests.
Step outside to swim, paddle, or unwind in the swing chair. A canoe, kayak, and paddleboard are all included for lake adventures.
Nearby, explore Whaley Lake for fishing and paddling, or visit the Stormville Antique Show. Take a drive to the Hudson Valley for wineries and scenic hikes. This lakeside retreat blends comfort, charm, and natural beauty.
12. Spacious Beachfront Lake House
- 📍 Location: Willsboro, NY, on Lake Champlain
- 💵 Price Per Night: $430/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 11 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private beachfront, breathtaking lake views, expansive deck, outdoor play area
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large family gatherings 👨👩👧👦, waterfront relaxation 🌊, nature escapes 🌲
Set on the shores of Lake Champlain, this 2,700 sq. ft. beachfront retreat offers stunning panoramic views and direct access to the water. With 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, there’s plenty of space for families and groups to spread out and enjoy a peaceful getaway.
Wake up to spectacular sunrises, unwind on the private balcony, or gather around the outdoor play area for fun with the kids. Just a 29-minute drive to Ausable Chasm, this home is perfectly located for outdoor adventures. Take a scenic drive to Burlington, VT, for shopping and dining at Church Street Marketplace or explore the nearby University of Vermont.
Enjoy a peaceful retreat or an action-packed adventure—either way, this Spacious Beachfront Lakehouse is the perfect place to create lasting memories.
13. Spectacular Panoramic Lake Views
- 📍 Location: Waterport, NY, near Lakeside Beach State Park
- 💵 Price Per Night: $195/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 3 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private deck with breathtaking lake views, romantic secluded setting, direct access to waterfront seating
- 🌟 Perfect For: Romantic getaways 💕, solo retreats ☕, nature lovers 🌿
Welcome to your private slice of Lake Ontario, where stunning sunrises, glowing sunsets, and crystal-blue waters set the stage for an unforgettable vacation. Nestled on 200 feet of private lakefront, this beautifully remodeled 1-bedroom retreat is perfect for couples seeking a romantic getaway or small families looking to reconnect by the water.
Wake up to panoramic lake views right from your deck, sip coffee with the birdsong, and end your day around the crackling fire pit under star-filled skies. Thoughtfully designed for comfort, this cottage features an open floor plan, a queen-sized bed, a full kitchen, a cozy living room with a convertible sleeper sofa, and a newly renovated bathroom.
In addition, Lakeside Beach State Park is just a short walk away. Nearby attractions include Oak Orchard State Marine Park for boating and fishing, as well as the historic town of Brockport, perfect for day trips.
Whether you’re here for wine tasting on the Niagara Wine Trail, exploring charming canal towns, biking scenic trails, or simply relaxing on the deck with a glass of local wine, you’ll quickly realize why over 150 guests have rated this property a 10/10.
Top Lakefront New York Airbnbs and VRBOs: Coolest Rentals on the Lake in NY
Have you ever stayed in a unique Airbnb or VRBO rental on a lake in NY? Let me know in the comments or on Insta, as I’m always looking to add to this list of the most unique lake houses in New York!
So, pack your bags and set out for the beauty of Upstate New York. You’ll truly love what you see!
Looking for more awesome East Coast adventures? Check out these dreamy destinations:
– Most Unique Poconos Rentals by the Lake
– Top Cabins for Rent in Indiana
– Coolest Rentals in Pennsylvania
– Best Lake Winnipesaukee Vacation Homes
– Top Airbnb Rentals in New England
– Coolest Rentals in Massachusetts
– Unique Airbnbs in the White Mountains
– Best Vacation Homes in Rhode Island
Need help planning your trip? Check out these helpful links:
- ✈️ Find cheap flights – I save $10k per year on flights thanks to this tool
- 🏨 Book accommodations – My favorite platform for boutique hotels and budget stays
- 🚗 Compare rental car prices – Great rates from trusted companies
- 🎟️ Discover affordable tours and day trips – Skip the line and explore more
