20 MAGICAL Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes (With Photos)

Jon Miksis Jon Miksis clock Updated September 21, 2024 tourism Dream Destinations
by Jon Miksis
Best Airbnbs Finger Lakes Featured Image
This post may have affiliate links, where I may receive a commission if you purchase through them. Here's our Disclosure and Privacy Policy for more info.

Having visited the Finger Lakes three times, I’ve had the chance to experience some of the most stunning vacation homes in this breathtaking region. From cozy lakefront cabins to luxurious houses perched on the water, there’s no better way to soak in the beauty of upstate New York than by staying in one of these gems.

Whether you’re into quiet retreats by the water, exploring nearby wineries, or outdoor adventures, these 20 incredible Airbnb and VRBO listings have it all. I’m excited to share my personal favorites with you—each offering a perfect blend of comfort, charm, and those unbeatable Finger Lakes views!

The 20 Nicest Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes, NY

Here are the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes by category, taking into account different amenities, trip types, and budgets. The next sections will cover each listing, as well as other Airbnb vacation rentals, in more detail.

Note: The properties below are featured on Airbnb, VRBO, Booking and Expedia. For each listing, I’ve only included the link to the website with the cheapest rates.

Epic Finger Lakes vacation homes

1. Luxurious Finger Lakes Home w/ Home Gym, Game Room

Location: Rushville, New York

Rates from: $882 per night

Accommodates: 14 guests

Luxurious home rental in the heart of the Finger Lakes
Luxurious home rental in the heart of the Finger Lakes. | Credit: Expedia
Elegant living room and dining area
Elegant living room and dining area. | Credit: Expedia

For those seeking a blend of luxury and comfort in the heart of the Finger Lakes region, the Luxurious Finger Lakes Home stands as an epitome of grandeur. Located in Rushville, New York, this sprawling property spans 6,275 sq ft, ensuring ample space for all its guests.

The home boasts five elegantly designed bedrooms. The master suite features a plush queen bed, while two other rooms are adorned with king beds. Another bedroom offers a queen bed, and the fifth bedroom is equipped with four double beds, catering to larger groups or families.

A highlight of this property is its state-of-the-art home gym, allowing fitness enthusiasts to keep up with their routines even while on vacation. The game room promises endless entertainment, making it a hit among both kids and adults.

For those who love the outdoors, the deck and patio provide the perfect setting to relax and soak in the scenic views. The property’s location in Rushville ensures that guests are never too far from the region’s renowned vineyards and attractions.

The Luxurious Finger Lakes Home is not just a place to stay; it’s an experience, a retreat where luxury meets comfort, and every moment is cherished.

2. Castle Point Paradise: Gorgeous Cabin with Lake Views

Location: Himrod, New York

Rates from: $378 per night

Accommodates: 8 guests

A beautiful cabin with a view.
A beautiful cabin with a view. | Credit: VRBO
Rustic log cabin vibes at this Finger lakes vacation home
Rustic log cabin for rent Finger Lakes. | Credit: VRBO
Outdoor terrace overlooking the countryside
Furnished deck with a view. | Credit: VRBO
Outdoor Jacuzzi on the back deck
Finger Lake rental with a hot tub. | Credit: VRBO

If you’re looking for the quintessential Finger Lakes experience, look no further. This gorgeous cabin overlooking Seneca Lake is the best-value Airbnb you’ll find in the Finger Lakes region. It offers sweeping lake views, log cabin vibes, a spacious deck with a hot tub, and even private balconies in the rooms. I can’t imagine a better home base for exploring the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, and the Finger Lakes in general.

Soak in the hot tub and catch the sunrise and sunset from this amazing Airbnb in the Finger Lakes. You won’t have to stay anywhere else!

3. Dramatic Lakefront Chalet in Ithaca: The best luxury Airbnb rental in the Finger Lakes

Location: Ithaca, New York

Rates from: $2,500 per night

Accommodates: 12 guests

A lakefront chalet Airbnb in the Finger Lakes.
A lakefront chalet overlooking Lake Cayuga. | Credit: VRBO
Elegant interior living space
Credit: VRBO
Beautiful home for rent overlooking the lake
Credit: VRBO

This is one of the most beautiful buildings, let alone Airbnbs, in the Finger Lakes region of New York. It proudly stands watch over Lake Cayuga, one of the most beautiful lakes in upstate New York.

Comprised of 5,000 sq. ft. of living space, this luxurious chalet is decked out with everything you’ll need for a memorable stay, including 2 docks, a custom hot tub, a home theater/projector, three fireplaces, and more. The attention to detail is staggering, with beautiful wooden furnishings and fixtures that resemble the chalets of the Swiss Alps.

With incredible lakefront and all sorts of amazing amenities, this chalet definitely deserves to be mentioned among the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes.

4. Secluded Yurt, Nestled in Woods and Gardens

Location: Trumansburg, New York

Rates from: $140 per night

Accommodates: 6 guests

A secluded yurt nestled in the woods in New York
A secluded yurt nestled in the woods in New York. | Credit: Expedia
Rustic living room inside the vacation rental
Rustic living room inside the vacation rental. | Credit: Expedia

For travelers seeking a unique and intimate escape, the Secluded Yurt in Trumansburg, NY, offers a refreshing change from the usual. Nestled amidst lush woods and beautifully manicured gardens, this yurt promises a stay that’s both rejuvenating and memorable.

The interior of the yurt is thoughtfully designed to provide comfort and convenience. It features a cozy futon and a loft bed, ensuring a restful sleep for its guests. The kitchenette is equipped with all the essentials, including dishes, cups, pots, pans, organic coffee, and basic spices, ensuring that every meal feels like a gourmet experience. The dining table, which comfortably seats four, is perfect for intimate meals or game nights.

The yurt’s location in Trumansburg ensures that guests are never too far from local attractions. The Hillendale Golf Course is just a 13-minute drive away, while the Robert H. Treman State Park and Ithaca Commons are also within close proximity.

The Secluded Yurt is more than just a place to stay; it’s an experience, a retreat where nature’s embrace is felt at every corner, and every moment is cherished.

5. Cozy Finger Lakes Cabins for Rent on Seneca Lake

Location: Lodi, New York

Rates from: $158 per night

Accommodates: 2 guests

Comfortable lake house cabin rental in the Finger Lakes region of NY.
Comfortable lake house cabin rental in the Finger Lakes region of NY. | Credit: Airbnb
Sunset views of the lake
Sunset views of the lake. | Credit: Airbnb

Looking to stay at one of the best-value cabin rentals in the Finger Lakes? This cozy lakefront home is calling your name!

Located on the east side of Seneca Lake, this private cabin rental is just a few miles from many top wineries, breweries, and waterfalls. Enjoy stunning sunsets and days spent kayaking and paddle boarding on the lake. With so much charm and personality, it’s no wonder this is among the best Finger Lakes vacation rentals!

6. Wine Trail Estate Surrounded by Nature – Among the Coolest Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes

Location: Rock Stream, New York

Rates from: $1,090 per night

Accommodates: 16 guests

Beautiful Finger Lake estate for rent for large groups of family/friends.
Beautiful estate for rent for large groups of family/friends. | Credit: Expedia
Large dining room area
Credit: Expedia
Spacious property backyard
Credit: Expedia

Experience the magic of the Finger Lakes from this grand estate in the countryside. It’s set on 5 acres of peaceful land, equipped with 8 bedrooms and 8 baths, making it one of the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes for large groups.

Take advantage of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail that’s nearby. Or spend the days relaxing in the outdoor hot tub and taking in the gorgeous nature views.

Curl up beside one of the 3 fireplaces at night, and you’ll see why this historic estate is among the coolest Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes region of NY!

7. Tiny House Cabin Rental in the Finger Lakes

Location: Penn Yan, New York

Rates from: $125 per night

Accommodates: 2 guests

Finger Lakes tiny house in the middle of nature
Finger Lakes tiny house in the middle of nature. | Credit: Airbnb
Deck with breathtaking views of the forest
Deck with breathtaking views of the forest. | Credit: Airbnb

This tiny house vacation rental in the Finger Lakes is ideal for couples looking for a romantic retreat in nature. It’s set in a 8×20 ft. shipping container on 10 acres filled with Sycamore and Black Walnut trees.

Go hiking and bike riding around the property. Hit the local wineries and breweries. And after a long day of activities, retreat to this beautiful Finger Lakes cabin rental in the middle of nature. It won’t be long until you see why it’s among the coolest vacation homes in the Finger Lakes!

8. Placid Dog-Friendly Water View Cabin

Location: Rock Stream, New York

Rates from: $218 per night

Accommodates: 9 guests

Water view cabin rental in the Finger Lakes
Water view cabin rental in the Finger Lakes. | Credit: Expedia
Rustic and charm living area
Rustic and charm living area. | Credit: Expedia

Nestled in the serene surroundings of Rock Stream, NY, the Water View Cabin offers a tranquil escape for those looking to reconnect with nature. This cabin, with its picturesque water views, promises a stay that’s both rejuvenating and memorable.

The cabin features three spacious bedrooms, ensuring comfort for all its guests. The master bedroom boasts a plush king bed, while the second bedroom is adorned with a cozy queen bed. The third bedroom offers a twin bed and a double sofa bed, providing flexible sleeping arrangements. An additional double sofa bed is available in the loft, ensuring ample space for larger groups.

For those who love the outdoors, the cabin deck and patio are perfect spots to relax and soak in the scenic views. The firepit adds a touch of warmth, making evenings delightful. The fully equipped kitchen ensures that every meal feels like a gourmet experience.

In terms of nearby attractions, the Lakewood Vineyards are just a 5-minute drive away, offering wine enthusiasts a treat. Additionally, the Seneca Harbor and Glenora Wine Cellars are within close proximity, ensuring guests have plenty to explore.

The Water View Cabin is more than just a place to stay; it’s a haven where memories are forged amidst nature’s embrace.

9. Hunt Hollow Hideaway and Spa – One of the best cheap Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes

Location: Honeoye, New York

Rates from: $150 per night

Accommodates: 6 guests

A top budget-friendly Airbnb in the Finger Lakes.
A top budget-friendly Airbnb in the Finger Lakes. | Credit: Expedia
Wraparound deck with hot tub and deck furniture
Back porch with hot tub. | Credit: VRBO

Located in the heart of NY wine country, this unique Airbnb in the Finger Lakes is the perfect home base for relaxation. It’s set on 9 acres of beautiful woodsy property with gardens, a creek, and hiking trails.

Gaze up at a sky full of stars from the hot tub, and you’ll see why this is one of the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes.

10. Leap Frog Tree House – Best Airbnb Treehouse in the Finger Lakes

Location: Hemlock, New York

Rates from: $250 per night

Accommodates: 3 guests

One of the best Airbnb treehouses in the Finger Lakes region of New York
One of the best Airbnb treehouses in the Finger Lakes region of New York. | Credit: Airbnb
Pond in the backyard
Credit: Airbnb
Beautiful living room inside the vacation rental
Credit: Airbnb

Feed your imagination from this unique Airbnb treehouse in the Finger Lakes.

It’s set on 100 acres of pristine land, home to a variety of wildlife and two ponds. There are several trails on the property that you can explore, and two canoes and a kayak you may use during your stay.

Fun fact: this treehouse is solar powered! Can you imagine a more romantic Airbnb treehouse in the Finger Lakes? I think not!

11. Eco Barn Home with Amazing Views – Top Finger Lakes Vacation Rentals for Couples

Location: Burdett, New York

Rates from: $396 per night

Accommodates: 2 guests

Quiet and secluded Finger Lakes vacation rental with a view
Quiet and secluded Finger Lakes vacation rental with a view. | Credit: Airbnb
Rustic and modern interior living space
Rustic and modern interior living space. | Credit: Airbnb

For a romantic stay in Upstate New York, look no further than this Finger Lakes vacation rental with sensation views.

This newly constructed barn home was built mostly with organic, reused materials. It offers glass doors in every room, bringing the outdoors to you. Enjoy the privacy and seclusion from the pavilion, fire pit, and pond. There’s also an organic garden, berry bushes and fruit trees. You won’t be far from many local wineries, hiking trails, and waterfalls. However, after stepping foot inside this mesmerizing Finger Lakes rental, it will be hard to get up and leave!

12. Cozy Finger Lakes Cabin Rental on Seneca Lake

Location: Penn Yann, New York

Rates from: $297 per night

Accommodates: 6 guests

One of the best cabin rentals in the Finger Lakes
One of the best cabin rentals in the Finger Lakes. | Credit: VRBO
Beautiful views of Seneca Lake
Stunning Seneca lake views. | Credit: VRBO
Rustic cabin architecture
Rustic cabin furniture. | Credit: VRBO

This magical cabin on Seneca Lake is easily one of the top vacation rentals in the region. It boasts stunning views of the lake, and the interior log cabin design is equally spectacular.

Take a refreshing swim in the lake or make some s’mores in the fire pit. The fall foliage around the property is also stunning.

Visit any time of year, and you’ll appreciate the cozy cabin experience. What more could you want in one of the coolest cabins in the Finger Lakes?

13. Hillside Retreat in the Finger Lakes Region with a Pool

Location: Beaver Dams, New York

Rates from: $759 per night

Accommodates: 8 guests

One of the top Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes with a pool.
One of the top vacation rentals in the Finger Lakes with a pool. | Credit: VRBO
Outdoor swimming pool at this Finger Lakes cabin rental.
Outdoor swimming pool at this Finger Lakes cabin rental. | Credit: VRBO
Elegant wooden decor
Modern interior designs and furniture. | Credit: VRBO

Discover the best that the Finger Lakes has to offer from this large vacation rental in the middle of nature.

This home lies near the Finger Lake Wine Trail and Watkins Glen, but you won’t want to leave the property after you see its salt water hot tub and pool! There’s also a pool table, foosball, ping pong, cornhole, and frisbee golf. Plenty of fun for the whole family!

Stay at this 70-acre property in the Finger Lakes region, and you’ll never want to vacation anywhere else.

14. One of the Best Houses to Rent in Finger Lakes NY with Hot Tub

Location: Geneva, New York

Rates from: $350 per night

Accommodates: 4 guests

Beautiful house to rent in the Finger Lakes region of New York
Beautiful house to rent in the Finger Lakes region of New York. | Credit: VRBO
Jacuzzi with breathtaking views of Seneca Lake
Jacuzzi with breathtaking views of Seneca Lake. | Credit: VRBO

This gorgeous house to rent in the Finger Lakes will leave you speechless. It’s located on Seneca Lake with incredible views as far as the eye can see.

Be sure to spend plenty of time rejuvenating in the hot tub, playing ping pong, and Pac Man. Enjoy a cocktail on the Adirondack chairs with views of the lake. You’ll only be a stone’s throw away from the Seneca Lake Wine Trail and many other top attractions in the region. With so much to see and do throughout the property, it’s easy to see why this is among the top Finger Lakes vacation rentals!

15. Chickadee Cabin – Among the Best Cabins for Rent in Finger Lakes

Location: Hemlock, New York

Rates from: $147 per night

Accommodates: 4 guests

Unique cabin for rent in the Finger Lakes
Unique cabin for rent in the Finger Lakes. | Credit: Airbnb
Oversized back deck with outdoor furniture and a hammock.
Oversized back deck with outdoor furniture and a hammock. | Credit: Airbnb

For nature lovers, it doesn’t get any better than this cabin for rent in the Finger Lakes. It’s situated in the woods and has all the rustic amenities you’ll need for a memorable stay.

Make use of the backyard area with a fire pit and hammock, as well as a small pond with a dock and pedal boat. I can’t imagine a better place to recharge your batteries than at this beautiful Finger Lakes cabin rental!

16. The Little House – Cozy Winter Getaway

Location: Canandaigua, New York

Rates from: $215 per night

Accommodates: 4 guests

A cozy winter lodge for rent in the Finger Lakes.
A cozy winter lodge for rent. | Credit: Expedia
Swimming pool perfect for large groups of family or friends.
Credit: Expedia

Looking for a cozy Airbnb in the Finger Lakes to visit in the winter? This one is among the best.

It’s set on a 14 acre property with beautiful views and all the amenities you’ll need for a comfortable stay. If you’re looking to go skiing, you’ll be happy to know that the Bristol Mountain Ski Resort is just a few minutes away.

In the warmer months, take advantage of the swimming pool, hiking trails, campfire, and grill on the property. You’ll also be close to many great farmer’s markets, wineries, and craft breweries. There’s truly something for everyone here, so it’s no wonder this is among the best vacation rentals in the Finger Lakes.

17. 120 Feet of Private Beachfront

Location: Trumansburg, New York

Rates from: $950 per night

Accommodates: 12 guests

One of the best house rental in the Finger Lakes
One of the best house rental in the Finger Lakes. | Credit: VRBO
Spacious living room area
Spacious living room area. | Credit: VRBO

Nestled in the heart of Trumansburg, NY, the Private Beachfront House promises an unparalleled escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. With its expansive private beach, this retreat offers guests the luxury of basking in nature’s beauty, right at their doorstep.

The property boasts four well-appointed bedrooms, ensuring ample space and comfort for all guests. The Beach House room, adorned with a plush queen bed, offers serene views of the beach, while the Blue Room, Master Bedroom, and Pink Room provide a mix of queen, double, and twin beds, catering to diverse sleeping preferences.

For those who love to cook, the property comes equipped with a state-of-the-art kitchen, ensuring that every meal is a gourmet experience. And if relaxation is on the agenda, the deck, patio, and garden spaces beckon guests to unwind and soak in the picturesque surroundings.

In terms of nearby attractions, the Ithaca, NY (ITH-Tompkins Regional) is a mere 29-minute drive away, making it convenient for guests flying in. The property’s location in Trumansburg also ensures that guests are never too far from local attractions and activities.

The Private Beachfront House is not just a place to stay; it’s a haven where memories are made, laughter is shared, and the beauty of nature is celebrated every day.

18. Finger Lakes Houseboat Rental on Seneca Lake – The Most Unique Finger Lakes Vacation Rental

Location: Geneva, New York

Rates from: $495 per night

Accommodates: 10 guests

This luxury houseboat is one of the most unique Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes.
This luxury Finger Lakes houseboat rental is one of the most unique Airbnbs in the region. | Credit: Expedia
A houseboat rental in the Finger Lakes NY like no other.
A houseboat rental in the Finger Lakes NY like no other. | Credit: Expedia

Looking to stay in one of the most unique Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes? You’re looking at it.

Measuring 67 feet long and 15 feet wide, this luxury Finger Lakes houseboat rental is the perfect way to experience Seneca Lake. It’s fully equipped with a deck, a hot tub, gas grill, waterslide, and watersports. Spend the afternoons swimming in the lake or grilling on the deck. You won’t want to experience the Finger lakes any other way!

19. Surprisingly Spacious Historic Railcar on Beautiful Skaneateles Lake

Location: Homer, New York

Rates from: $399 per night

Accommodates: 7 guests

One of the most unique Airbnb rental in New York
One of the most unique Airbnb rental in New York. | Credit: VRBO
Tranquility along one of the USA's most pristine lakes
Tranquility along one of the USA’s most pristine lakes. | Credit: VRBO

For those with a penchant for unique accommodations, the Spacious Historic Railcar on Skaneateles Lake offers an experience like no other. This 110ft historic 1936 Stainless Budd Rail Carriage, stationed on the pristine shores of Skaneateles Lake, promises a stay that’s both nostalgic and luxurious.

The rail car boasts three well-appointed bedrooms. The master bedroom features a comfortable queen bed, while the second bedroom offers twin beds. The third bedroom is equipped with a twin bunk bed. Additionally, there are two double futons available for extra guests, ensuring flexibility in sleeping arrangements.

The railcar’s location in Homer, NY, ensures that guests are surrounded by natural beauty and tranquility. Just a minute’s walk away lies the breathtaking Skaneateles Lake, perfect for morning strolls or evening reflections. For those looking to explore, the Bahar Nature Preserve and Carpenter Falls are just a short drive away, offering scenic views and hiking opportunities.

The Spacious Historic Railcar on Skaneateles Lake is not just a place to stay; it’s an adventure, a journey back in time, where every moment is a blend of history and luxury.

20. Waneta Lakeside Cottage – Among the Top Finger Lakes Vacation Rentals

Location: Dundee, New York

Rates from: $179 per night

Accommodates: 4 guests

Cozy lake house cottage for rent in the Finger Lake
Cozy lake house cottage for rent in the Finger Lakes. | Credit: Expedia
Finger Lakes lake house rental with kayaks and private beach
Finger Lakes lake house rental with kayaks and private beach. | Credit: Expedia

It would be a crime to list the top Finger Lakes houses for rent without mentioning this one in Dundee, NY. This quaint lakeside cottage is nestled on Waneta Lake, one of the best hidden gems in the Finger Lakes Region of New York.

Dine and relax on the covered deck with views of the waterfront. Take advantage of the private beach with 4 kayaks. This is especially a nice place to stay during the peak fall foliage season when wine season is in full swing. If you’re dreaming of the perfect lake house vacation rental in the Finger Lakes, look no further!

Best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes pinterest photo pin
Enjoyed reading about these top vacation rentals in theFinger Lakes? Pin it!

Top Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes NY

Have you stayed in any unique Airbnbs or vacation rentals in the Finger Lakes? Let me know in the comments, as I’m always looking to add to this lineup of the best Finger Lakes Airbnbs!

If you’re looking for more cool destinations in the northeast USA, check out these destinations:

– The Best Airbnbs in New York State

– Unique Airbnbs in New England

– Top Airbnbs in the White Mountains

– Coolest Airbnbs in Massachusetts

– Unique Stays in Vermont

– Unique Airbnbs in Rhode Island

– Best Airbnbs in the Berkshires

You may also like

Leave a Comment