Welcome to our exploration of the most unique, quirky, and unusual restaurants in New York State. From eateries with eccentric decor to those serving up dishes you’ve only dreamed of, get ready to discover the dining experiences that truly stand out in New York State!
Welcome to a journey through New York State’s most unique dining spots! Imagine stepping into places where every meal is a leap into another world. From hidden gems tucked away in bustling cities to cozy spots in quiet towns, New York offers a feast for the senses. This guide is your ticket to exploring restaurants that are all about unforgettable experiences.
Whether it’s dining in a place that takes you back in time, or enjoying a meal surrounded by the magic of cinema, each restaurant brings its own flavor of excitement. So, grab your fork and knife (or chopsticks!) and get ready to discover dining like you’ve never seen before.
These aren’t your ordinary eateries; they’re destinations that promise fun, surprises, and, of course, delicious food. Let’s embark on this foodie adventure together and see what incredible tastes New York State has in store!
Unique Restaurants in New York State: 12 Incredible New York State Eateries
From dining in the dark to eating in a castle, we’re showcasing spots that offer more than just great food. Get ready to explore eateries that promise an adventure as memorable as the meals they serve!
1. Trailer Park Lounge
In the heart of Chelsea, Trailer Park Lounge stands out as one of the unique places to eat in NY State. Imagine a place in New York where stepping inside feels like entering a fun, different world. With a bright lime exterior and a unique toilet statue greeting you, it’s hard not to be curious. Once inside, the adventure begins. The lounge is filled with interesting items collected over twelve years. The walls, floors, and ceilings are a treasure trove of fun, clever decorations that capture the imagination.
This spot isn’t just about looking around. The music takes you back in time, creating a lively vibe. People come here to share laughs over a pitcher of margaritas or enjoy a classic Rheingold beer. And the food? It’s all about big flavors and portions. Favorites include fries, burgers, and mac n’ cheese.
Trailer Park Lounge is a dive into a pool of nostalgia and fun. It’s a testament to New York’s creative spirit, making it a must-visit for those seeking a unique dining experience. Whether you’re in for a drink or a feast, this place promises a memorable time.
2. The Pandorica
Nestled in the town of Beacon, The Pandorica opens its doors to fans of the iconic show, Doctor Who. Owned by Shirley Hot, this unique eatery began its journey as an English Tea Room. In 2014, it transformed, mirroring Beacon’s own revitalization. Inspired by a Doctor Who binge-watching session, Shirley noticed the restaurant’s bathroom resembled the TARDIS, sparking the theme’s inception.
As one of the themed restaurants in New York State, The Pandorica is a haven for Whovians. Inside, you’re greeted by sketches of the Doctor’s past incarnations, and yes, a TARDIS-like bathroom that’s a must-visit. The menu is a playful homage to the series, featuring dishes like Gallifreyed Potato Pancakes and Bannakaffalatta Bread Pudding. Each dish is an adventure, blending delicious flavors with whimsical references to the show.
Beyond the food, The Pandorica hosts Doctor Who events, including trivia nights and special guest meet-and-greets. It’s more than a place to eat; it’s a community hub for fans to gather, share their love for the series, and enjoy a meal that’s out of this world!
3. Tokyo Record Bar
Imagine finding a secret door under a red light in Greenwich Village. That’s how you enter Tokyo Record Bar. It’s a cozy spot where you get to pick vinyl records to play. The place feels like a hidden club, with two main times to grab a seat: early at 6:30 pm or a bit later at 8:30 pm. If you’re a night owl, they open up again at 10:30 pm for snacks and tunes.
This spot shines as one of the best places to eat in NY State because it’s not just about food; it’s about the experience. Picture this: you’re munching on togarashi popcorn, the spicy flavor dancing on your tongue, while your friend digs into nori Chex mix. You both share a caviar sandwich, the salty caviar spread thin on a chunky piece of toasted brioche. It’s a mix of fancy and casual, all at once.
The drinks? They’re a journey through sake, from light and refreshing to deep and complex. Imagine sipping on “Chanterelles” sake, feeling the smooth, earthy taste. And the music! The selection spans genres and eras, from the Beastie Boys to Marvin Gaye, making it the venue’s best feature.
4. Last Chance Cheese and Antiques Cafe
Picture a small town where the past and present blend seamlessly. In Tannersville, Last Chance Cheese and Antiques Cafe stands out, not just for its food but for its story. Once an antiques shop, it’s now a place where every meal comes with a slice of history. The walls are lined with items from the past, each with its own tale, waiting to find a new home.
This cafe is a treasure among hidden gem restaurants in New York State. Here, you can bite into a knish-wich, where the crunch of the grilled knish meets the softness of melted cheese and the tang of coleslaw. It’s a taste of tradition that hasn’t changed because it doesn’t need to. Classics like chicken pot pie and French onion soup fill the menu, beloved through the years.
The charm extends beyond the menu. With around 100 cheeses to choose from and a collection of teas, coffees, and nostalgic candies, it’s a gourmet paradise. And if you’re in the mood for a drink, the selection of nearly 300 beers promises a new flavor with every visit. Next door, the tavern comes alive with music and dancing, making the evening unforgettable.
5. Beetle House
Imagine stepping into a scene from a Tim Burton movie. That’s Beetle House in the East Village, where every corner whispers tales from Burton’s mind. Here, the decor pulls you into a world where goth meets whimsy, making you feel like a character in one of his stories.
At this spot, the menu is a playful homage to Burton’s creations. Picture biting into the “Edward Burger Hands”: a juicy burger with layers of flavor from smoked bacon, spicy pepper jack, and a creamy sriracha sauce. Or, imagine the warmth of the “Cheshire Mac,” where seven kinds of cheese melt together, hiding under a crunchy topping of garlic and sea salt breadcrumbs.
Beetle House shines as one of the fun restaurants in New York State. The drinks, mysterious and unnamed, mix ingredients like Rumchata into potions that could’ve been dreamed up by Burton himself. With its cozy size, getting a table feels like uncovering a secret. It’s a spot where the ordinary turns extraordinary, inviting you to celebrate the magic of movies with every visit.
6. ‘76 House
In Tappan, New York, the ‘76 House invites guests into a chapter of American history. This tavern, the oldest in New York, is a bridge to the past. It’s where the spirits of General Nathanael Greene and Major John André linger in its rooms. Here, history is not only remembered but also experienced with every visit.
As one of the unique NY State restaurants, ‘76 House offers a dining experience intertwined with history. The menu pays homage to the era of the Founding Fathers, featuring dishes that blend traditional flavors with a touch of the tavern’s historical significance. Whether savoring French onion soup or indulging in Crème Brulee, diners embark on a journey through time.
‘76 House serves as a living monument to the American Revolution. The interior, adorned with colonial uniforms and muskets, transforms the space into a museum where history and hospitality converge. Guests can dine amidst relics of the past, enjoying meals that might have been familiar to the nation’s early heroes.
7. Grand Central Oyster Bar & Restaurant
Nestled in the heart of Midtown East, inside the iconic Grand Central Terminal, the Grand Central Oyster Bar & Restaurant has been a haven for seafood enthusiasts since 1913. Imagine a place where the chef personally selects the freshest seafood from the New Fulton Fish Market every morning. This dedication ensures that whether you’re craving lobster, various fish, or their famous oysters, you’re getting the best of the day’s catch.
With over 15 varieties of oysters available daily, the restaurant prides itself on offering a diverse seafood experience. Guests can enjoy their meals in a variety of ways, from simple preparations to hearty po’ boys.
The dining experience is enhanced by an extensive wine list, featuring over 250 options. The Oyster Bar is not just a place to eat; it’s a bustling social hub, rich in history and buzzing with activity. This establishment stands out as one of the unique restaurants in New York State, offering a blend of culinary excellence and historical ambiance that’s unmatched.
8. Beardslee Castle
Looking for the best fine dining in NY state? Imagine a castle from 1860, looking like it’s straight out of Ireland, right in Upstate New York. That’s Beardslee Castle for you. Legends whisper it’s haunted, adding a sprinkle of mystery to every visit. It’s a castle with stories etched into its stones.
Dining here is an adventure. The menu changes with the seasons, always fresh and always surprising. Picture wood-grilled meats, fresh seafood, and vegetarian dishes that are a feast for the senses. The castle prides itself on using organic greens and veggies from local farms. Imagine savoring Blackened Faroe Island Salmon or Walnut Crusted Pork Loin in a dining room that feels like stepping back in time.
With five distinct dining rooms and a relaxed bar known as The Dungeon, Beardslee Castle caters to all tastes. Whether you’re here for a casual drink or a lavish meal, you’re in for a treat. The beer selection alone, featuring over 125 varieties, including some rare finds, makes every visit memorable.
9. Ellen’s Stardust Diner
If you’re looking for dining with a side of entertainment, Ellen’s Stardust Diner is one of the most fun places to eat in NY State. Picture this: you’re sitting down to eat, and suddenly, your waiter bursts into song. Located right in the buzz of New York’s Theater District, this diner is all about the 1950s vibe, complete with neon lights and a jukebox playing old hits.
This place is special because the waitstaff are all Broadway stars in the making. While you munch on a bagel loaded with cream cheese and lox, someone’s belting out a tune from “Wicked” just a few feet away. The walls are covered with photos of New York’s past, including those of Miss Subways, a beauty contest of yesteryear.
Ellen’s Stardust Diner is where you can eat breakfast, lunch, or dinner and feel like you’re part of a Broadway show. Serving up smiles and songs daily, it’s a must-visit for a fun time in New York.
10. Maureen’s Kitchen: A Must-Visit Brunch Spot
Maureen’s Kitchen, nestled in Smithtown, Long Island, is a brunch destination that’s hard to miss. For over 20 years, this Suffolk County gem has been drawing crowds with its exceptional service and unique cow-themed decor. From the moment you step in, you’re greeted by a whimsical world of black and white, complete with cow figurines and even a cow-themed motorcycle.
Ranked high among New York State’s best restaurants, Maureen’s Kitchen offers an unforgettable brunch experience. The menu is a treasure trove of delights, boasting massive portions that promise to satisfy. Whether you’re in the mood for blueberry apple crumb pancakes, Oreo white chocolate chip pancakes with strawberries, or a hearty breakfast sandwich special, there’s something for everyone.
The creativity shines through in daily specials, ensuring a new surprise with each visit. And for those who lean towards the sweeter side of brunch, the stuffed French toast with apples, bananas, and fresh berries is a dream come true.
11. Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain
Located in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain was once a pharmacy from the early 1900s. Thanks to a mix of hard work and a bit of TV magic, it’s now a bustling soda fountain that feels like it’s straight out of the 1920s. With its original penny tile floors, red-topped stools, and pressed tin ceilings, the authenticity is undeniable.
Here, the menu brings the past to life with classic soda fountain treats like milkshakes, malts, and egg creams. The food menu doesn’t lag behind, offering diner favorites that make you feel right at home. From grilled cheese sandwiches to a unique pastrami hot dog, there’s comfort in every bite. And for dessert? Their sundaes, especially the Mr. Potato Head, have become the stuff of legend.
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain stands out as one of Brooklyn’s unique restaurants and one of the coolest restaurants in New York State, where every visit is a delicious dive into history. It’s located in one of the most livable neighborhoods of Brooklyn, a place where generations come together over classic American treats.
12. The Playhouse and Swillburger
Imagine a place in Rochester where you can chow down on awesome burgers and play arcade games until your fingers get tired. Welcome to The Playhouse and Swillburger! These are two cool spots inside an old church turned into a gamer’s paradise and burger heaven.
The Playhouse part is all about fun and games. Think arcade classics and pinball machines that’ll take you way back. Plus, there are balconies where you can chill and watch the action from above. Want to throw a party? They’ve got you covered with private spaces too.
Swillburger, on the other hand, is a place serious about burgers. They team up with local farms to get the best beef that’s all about being good for the planet and your taste buds. Not into beef? No worries! They’ve got a beet burger that’s a hit, plus killer sides like onion rings and fries. Oh, and the milkshakes? They’re made with ice cream from Rochester’s own Eat Me creamery. Yum!
The Playhouse and Swillburger is one of those unique restaurants in New York State for dinner where you can eat, play, and hang out. It’s all about good food, good times, and doing good for the community.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Unique Places to Eat in New York State
Got questions? Our New York State restaurant guide FAQ section has all the answers you need to make your dining experience unforgettable.
What is a unique food in New York?
New York is famous for its bagels, but have you tried the best food in NY State, the garbage plate? It’s a wild mix of everything you can imagine: meat, potatoes, beans, and salad, all thrown together on one plate. Originally from Rochester, this dish is a must-try for anyone who loves to dive into local flavors. It’s not just about the taste; it’s about experiencing a piece of New York’s unique foodie culture.
Where do locals eat in New York?
Locals in New York love places where they can get delicious food without the tourist crowds. Many enjoy dining in small, cozy spots in neighborhoods like Astoria for Greek food or Flushing for authentic Chinese cuisine. These areas offer some of the best restaurants in New York State where you can find meals made with love and a touch of home-style cooking. It’s all about finding those hidden gems that serve up big flavors.
Where do celebrities eat in NYC?
Celebrities in NYC often dine in trendy spots where they can enjoy privacy and top-notch meals. Restaurants like Nobu for sushi or The Spotted Pig for gourmet pub dishes are hotspots. These places are known for their exclusive vibes and delicious food, making them some of the best restaurants in New York State for star-spotting. Just remember, these meals might come with a higher price tag due to their popularity and celebrity clientele.
What are some cheap eats in New York State?
For cheap eats in New York State, you’re in luck because there are tons of options! From dollar-slice pizza joints to delicious food trucks serving everything from tacos to falafel, you can eat well on a budget. Many neighborhoods have local delis or bagel shops where you can grab a filling and tasty meal without breaking the bank. It’s all about exploring and finding those deals that let you taste the city’s flavors for less.
What is the most famous restaurant in New York?
When talking about fame, Katz’s Delicatessen often tops the list. Known for its mouth-watering pastrami sandwiches, Katz’s is a New York icon that’s been around since 1888. It’s not just a restaurant; it’s a piece of New York history where people from all over come to experience a classic New York meal. It’s a must-visit for anyone wanting to bite into a big part of the city’s foodie legacy.
Where can I find the best pizza in New York?
The best pizza in New York is a hot debate, but many swear by spots like Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn or Lombardi’s in Manhattan. These pizzerias are famous for their delicious, crispy crusts and fresh, flavorful toppings. Each place has its own secret recipe and method, making their pizzas stand out. Whether you like your slice thin and crispy or thick and saucy, New York has the perfect pizza for you.
Where are the most scenic places in New York State to eat?
For dining with a view, check out restaurants along the Hudson River or those overlooking the Adirondacks. These spots offer not just great food but also breathtaking views, making them some of the scenic places in NY State to eat. Imagine enjoying a meal as you gaze out over serene waters or lush mountains. It’s an experience that combines the beauty of nature with the pleasure of eating delicious food.
What makes New York’s culinary scene unique?
New York’s culinary scene is a melting pot of cultures, making it unique and vibrant, especially during your stay in New York State. You can find dishes from around the world, thanks to the diverse communities that call New York home. From street food to high-end dining, the state offers an endless variety of flavors and experiences. This diversity is what makes New York’s food scene stand out, as there’s always something new and exciting to try, no matter your taste or budget.
Final Thoughts On Unique New York State Restaurants
We hope you enjoyed exploring the flavors and fun spots with our New York State restaurant guide. From unique dishes to places where locals and celebrities hang out, New York State has something for everyone, showcasing its Northeast charm. Whether you’re craving a classic New York bagel, a slice of the best pizza, or want to dine with a view, this guide has got you covered. Remember, it’s all about discovering new tastes and creating memories one meal at a time. So next time you’re in New York State, dive into our guide and let your taste buds lead the way to some unforgettable dining experiences.
