Unique Restaurants in Lancaster PA: 12 Extraordinary Dining Spots and Cafes in The Red Rose City

by Jen
Unique Restaurants in Lancaster PA
This post may have affiliate links, where I may receive a commission if you purchase through them. Here's our Disclosure and Privacy Policy for more info.

Discover the charm of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, through its unique restaurants. Our guide highlights spots where exceptional food meets extraordinary settings. From magical shows to treehouse dining, explore what makes these unique restaurants in Lancaster PA stand out!

Lancaster, Pennsylvania is a hub of culinary diversity, offering plenty of creative dining experiences. This guide takes you through a selection of 12 unique restaurants, each showcasing the distinct flavors and cultural heritage of the area. Lancaster’s food scene is a blend of traditional Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine and innovative, contemporary cooking, providing a range of tastes to explore.

From family-run establishments steeped in history to modern eateries pushing culinary boundaries, these restaurants reflect the vibrant and varied character of Lancaster. Expect to find menus rich in locally sourced ingredients, dishes prepared with time-honored techniques, and atmospheres that capture the essence of their surroundings.

This journey through Lancaster’s dining landscape promises to be both enlightening and delicious. Whether you’re seeking a taste of local tradition or a sample of culinary innovation, these restaurants offer unique experiences that go beyond the ordinary. Prepare to indulge in a culinary exploration that highlights the best of Lancaster’s dining scene.

The top restaurants to visit in Lancaster PA right now

Unique Restaurants in Lancaster, PA: 12 Incredible Lancaster PA Eateries

Explore Lancaster PA’s unique restaurants, where culinary creativity meets local charm. From historic inns serving classic dishes to modern cafes with innovative menus, these spots are full of surprises. Get ready to experience the hidden gems and gastronomic delights that make Lancaster’s dining scene truly special.

1. Shady Maple

Have you ever dined in a place where the buffet stretches over 200 feet? Welcome to Shady Maple, a unique restaurant in Lancaster, PA, where the scale and variety of the buffet are as impressive as the flavors. This family-run smorgasbord, deeply rooted in Pennsylvania Dutch culinary traditions, offers a dining experience that’s both grand and authentic.

At Shady Maple, the choices are endless. From local favorites like apple butter and hot bacon dressing to a 46-item salad bar, the buffet showcases the best of Lancaster’s produce and recipes. It’s a place where traditional dishes meet the expectations of modern palates, making it one of the unique restaurants in Lancaster for dinner.

The restaurant’s vast dining area, capable of seating 1,200 guests, reflects the community’s spirit and hospitality. With offerings that change daily, every visit promises a new culinary adventure.

Shady Maple is one of the unique restaurants in Lancaster PA.
Shady Maple boasts a massive 200-foot buffet, delivering grand and authentic dining.

2. The Exchange

Imagine sipping a cocktail while gazing at a panoramic view of historic downtown Lancaster. The Exchange, perched atop the city’s tallest rooftop, offers just that. This chic, open-air venue transforms dining into a visual feast, making it one of the most scenic places in Lancaster, PA to eat.

The Exchange is known for its upscale comfort food, served as shareable dishes and small plates. The menu, crafted by an executive chef, features seasonal ingredients, ensuring a fresh and unique dining experience with each visit. It’s a place where food, ambiance, and the skyline merge to create memorable moments.

As one of the best places to eat in Lancaster, PA, The Exchange also boasts a creative drinks menu. Their mixologists blend infused spirits, shrubs, and fresh herbs into imaginative cocktails, complementing the culinary delights.

The Exchange offers a chic open-air venue with panoramic views that serve upscale comfort food.
The Exchange offers a chic open-air venue with panoramic views that serve upscale comfort food. | Source: https://www.exchangeroof.com/

3. C’est La Vie

Ever wondered what it feels like to dine in a French bistro without leaving Pennsylvania? C’est La Vie in downtown Lancaster offers this unique experience. Located across from Central Market in the Hager Arcade, it brings artisanal French cuisine to the heart of the city, making it one of the best restaurants in Lancaster, PA.

Opened in 2019, C’est La Vie features a casually elegant atmosphere, where antique French farm tables and Moulin Rouge-inspired artwork create a vibrant setting. The menu emphasizes casual yet sophisticated fare, from boeuf bourguignon to a variety of French-inspired pizzas baked in a brick oven. Ingredients are sourced locally, including from the nearby Central Market, ensuring freshness and a Lancaster touch in every dish.

As a standout among unique places to eat in Lancaster, PA, C’est La Vie also offers an outdoor dining area, providing a view of the bustling street life, especially on market days. The historic Hager building, dating back to 1910, adds to the authentic European ambiance. Whether it’s for a business lunch or a leisurely meal with friends, C’est La Vie promises a culinary journey to France, right in Lancaster.

C'est La Vie offers an authentic French bistro experience.
C’est La Vie offers an authentic French bistro experience.

4. Callaloo

Taste the vibrant flavors of Trinidad in the heart of Pennsylvania! Callaloo, a cozy gem in Lancaster’s West End neighborhood, brings the island’s culinary delights to life. This unique Lancaster PA restaurant is more than a dining spot; it’s a cultural immersion.

Founded by a couple with deep ties to Trinidad, Callaloo offers an authentic taste of the Caribbean. The menu is a celebration of Trinidadian cuisine, featuring dishes like ‘doubles’ – a popular street food of curried chickpeas between fried flatbread. It’s a place where every dish tells a story, making it a unique place to eat in Lancaster, PA.

The restaurant’s atmosphere complements its menu. With reggae music and a tropical vibe, it feels like a mini vacation in Pennsylvania. Callaloo is all about experiencing a different culture. From the hand washing station to the rustic decor, every detail adds to the authenticity. This is where Lancaster meets Trinidad, offering a culinary journey unlike any other.

Callaloo brings the vibrant flavors of Trinidad to Pennsylvania, offering a cultural immersion beyond dining.
Callaloo brings the vibrant flavors of Trinidad to Pennsylvania, offering a cultural immersion beyond dining.

5. Zoetropolis

When it comes to dining with a side of entertainment, it’s hard to beat Zoetropolis. This venue is a unique combination of a movie theater, restaurant, and distillery. This establishment stands out as one of the fun places to eat in Lancaster, PA, providing an experience that goes beyond the traditional dining setting.

Starting in the 1990s as a small art house theater, Zoetropolis has evolved into a vibrant cultural hub. More than just watching films, it’s about enjoying them alongside delicious meals and handcrafted spirits. The restaurant section of Zoetropolis serves dinner and weekend brunch, perfectly timed with showtimes for a seamless entertainment experience.

As one of the coolest restaurants in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, Zoetropolis is more than a place to eat. It’s a community space where art, food, and film intersect. The team behind this unique venue is passionate about creating a home for high-quality art films, spirits, food, and music. It’s a place where each visit offers a new opportunity to engage with the arts in a relaxed and enjoyable setting.

Zoetropolis merges a movie theater, restaurant, and distillery.
Zoetropolis merges a movie theater, restaurant, and distillery. | Source: https://zoetropolis.com/

6. Decades Lancaster

Imagine a place where bowling, arcade games, and gourmet dining blend seamlessly. Welcome to Decades Lancaster, a unique fusion of fun and flavor. This venue is a standout among fun restaurants in Lancaster, PA, offering a nostalgic yet chic experience.

Located in a historic building, Decades Lancaster combines a boutique restaurant, bar, and entertainment space. The menu is a delightful mix of classic and innovative dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. From appetizers to desserts, the food is as much a draw as the games. It’s a perfect spot for family restaurants in Lancaster, where both kids and adults can find joy.

The venue’s vintage vibe is accentuated by its eclectic decor, including items from the TV show “House of Cards”. With a 6-lane bowling alley, retro arcade games, and a hip bar, Decades Lancaster is more than a dining destination; it’s a trip down memory lane. Whether you’re planning a family outing or a night out with friends, this place promises an unforgettable experience.

Decades Lancaster boasts its nostalgic yet chic fusion of fun and flavor.
Decades Lancaster boasts its nostalgic yet chic fusion of fun and flavor.

7. The Pressroom Restaurant and Bar

The Pressroom Restaurant and Bar, nestled in the historic Steinman Hardware Building, is a place where history and modern cuisine meet. This venue is a jewel among Lancaster PA’s best restaurants, combining the charm of the past with contemporary culinary delights.

The Pressroom celebrates the building’s rich history dating back to the mid-1700s. The warm mahogany interiors and cozy booths set the stage for a memorable meal. Seasonal menus and daily specials are a testament to the best food in Lancaster, PA. Guests may enjoy a range of dishes, from burgers and fresh salads to seafood and beef entrees. The specialty flatbreads, freshly baked in a classic pizza oven, are a must-try.

More than just food, The Pressroom also offers a vibrant bar scene. With a daily happy hour, guests can enjoy frosty draft beers, wines, and craft cocktails. Whether it’s a casual meal or a special occasion, The Pressroom promises an experience that’s both historical and delicious.

The Pressroom Restaurant and Bar is one of the unique restaurants in Lancaster PA.
The Pressroom Restaurant and Bar blends history and contemporary culinary delights. | Source: https://pressroomrestaurant.com/

8. Conway Social Club

At Conway Social Club, guests are greeted by a doorman and led up a two-tier staircase, setting the stage for a unique dining adventure. This process makes it one of the most unique restaurants in Lancaster, PA.

Upon arrival, the doorman enlightens guests about the club’s concept. A maître d’ in the lobby then tailors the seating based on the desired experience, whether it’s a quiet conversation, a meal, or socializing with other guests. The interior, seating 54, is a visual feast of old photographs, paintings, and light fixtures, all under the glow of beaded glass chandeliers.

The ambiance inside is deliberately serene and nostalgic. There are no TVs, and jazz music softly plays in the background. The use of cell phones is discouraged, encouraging guests to immerse themselves fully in the experience. The club’s offerings are as unique as its ambiance. The cocktail menu, crafted by renowned mixologist Benjamin Hash, features experimental drinks with homegrown herbs and specialized equipment. The food menu, constantly evolving with seasonal ingredients, is curated by chef Corinna Killian, known for her innovative culinary style.

Conway Social Club sets a unique dining stage, standing out among the city's distinctive restaurants.
Conway Social Club sets a unique dining stage, standing out among the city’s distinctive restaurants.

9. Casey Jones’ Restaurant at Paradise Station

Casey Jones’ Restaurant at Paradise Station allows you to dine in an actual train car. This restaurant, housed in two original P-70 80-ton dining cars from the early 1900s, is a journey back in time. It’s a themed restaurant in Lancaster, PA, that’s truly one-of-a-kind.

Guests at Casey Jones’ Restaurant can enjoy their meal while seated in cars that once rode the rails of the Pennsylvania Railroad. With a seating capacity of 175, the restaurant offers a choice between the Parlor Car and the Dining Car. Each car provides a unique ambiance, perfect for train enthusiasts and history buffs alike.

It’s definitely one of the coolest restaurants in Lancaster, but it’s not just about the novelty of its setting. The menu offers fresh, fun, and affordable dining options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The view of trains at the nearby Strasburg Rail Road and the stunning Pennsylvania Dutch farmland adds to the charm.

Casey Jones' Restaurant offers a unique dining experience inside two original P-70 80-ton dining cars from the early 1900s.
Casey Jones’ Restaurant offers a unique dining experience inside two original P-70 80-ton dining cars from the early 1900s.

10. Dutch Apple Dinner Theater

Ever dined amidst a live Broadway show? Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre makes this possible. It’s a fun restaurant in Lancaster, PA, where guests enjoy a unique mix of fine dining and live entertainment.

Upon entering, you’re greeted by a door manager and seated by a courteous host staff. The atmosphere impresses with its elegant setting, rich colors, and an intimate feel. The 328-seat theatre, designed for an unobstructed view of the stage, ensures every seat is the best in the house. Shows at Dutch Apple feature performers from New York City, Phoenix, South Carolina, and Chicago. Many have graced national tours and Broadway stages.

The culinary journey at Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre is as delightful as the shows. The buffet, crafted by an Executive Chef, offers classic American cuisine that changes with each show. From carved prime rib to over 15 desserts including Turkey Hill ice cream and shoofly pie, the buffet is a feast for the senses.

Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre offers a unique blend of fine dining and live Broadway shows.
Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre offers a unique blend of fine dining and live Broadway shows.

11. The Magic and Wonder Show

At The Magic and Wonder Show, dining transcends into an enchanting world of illusion and spectacle. This fun restaurant in Lancaster, PA, is where magic and meals blend seamlessly, offering a unique experience.

Brett Myers, the magician, has transformed the former Rainbow Comedy Dinner Theater into a realm of wonder. The Magic and Wonder Theater captivates audiences with themed segments like Atlantis, Neverland, and the Roaring 1920s. Each show is a journey through different worlds, from a mysterious Masquerade Ball to the thrilling escapades of a Secret Agent.

Ranked #2 of 208 “Top Things to Do in Lancaster County” on TripAdvisor, Brett Myers’ shows are a blend of dazzling costumes, breathtaking illusions, and dynamic circus arts. The 90-minute shows, with a 15-minute intermission, allow guests to order and enjoy food delivered right to their table.

The Magic and Wonder Show seamlessly blends magic and meals, creating an enchanting dining experience.
The Magic and Wonder Show seamlessly blends magic and meals, creating an enchanting dining experience.

12. Loxley’s Restaurant

Discover Loxley’s Restaurant, a true hidden gem among restaurants in Lancaster, PA. This unique dining spot surprises guests with its extraordinary treehouse setting. Tucked behind the Heritage Hotel, Loxley’s offers a magical escape, blending rustic charm with a touch of whimsy.

Inspired by the legend of Robin Hood, the restaurant’s design transports diners to a storybook world. The menu showcases American classics with a creative flair, featuring dishes like the savory Crab Dip and the mouth-watering Loxley’s Burger. Dining amidst the trees, guests enjoy an intimate and serene atmosphere.

Loxley’s sources ingredients locally, supporting area farmers and reducing their environmental footprint. Their commitment extends to giving back, with a portion of proceeds aiding local charities. This combination of enchanting ambiance, innovative cuisine, and community focus makes Loxley’s one of the hidden gem restaurants in Lancaster, Pennsylvania that you simply can’t miss.

Loxley's Restaurant is one of the unique restaurants in Lancaster PA.
Loxley’s Restaurant surprises with a treehouse setting, a hidden gem blending rustic charm and whimsy.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Unique Places to Eat in Lancaster PA

Got questions about dining in Lancaster? Our Lancaster PA restaurant guide answers them, helping you find the perfect spot for your next meal.

What food is Lancaster PA known for?

Lancaster, PA, is renowned for its Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine. This includes hearty, homemade dishes like chicken pot pie, pork and sauerkraut, and shoofly pie. The area’s rich agricultural heritage means fresh, locally sourced ingredients are a staple in many meals. Lancaster’s traditional dishes reflect a blend of German and Swiss influences, offering a unique taste of local culture and history.

What’s the name of the big smorgasbord in Lancaster?

The big smorgasbord in Lancaster is Shady Maple Smorgasbord. It’s famous for its vast array of Pennsylvania Dutch cooking. This buffet-style eatery offers an impressive selection of meats, vegetables, salads, and desserts. Shady Maple is not just a meal; it’s an experience, showcasing the best of local cuisine in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

Are there unique restaurants in Lancaster PA?

Yes, Lancaster, PA, is home to many unique restaurants. From dining in a train car at Casey Jones’ Restaurant to the magical Magic and Wonder Show, the city offers a variety of one-of-a-kind dining experiences. These establishments combine great food with unique atmospheres, making each meal memorable.

Can I find cheap eats in Lancaster PA?

Absolutely! Lancaster, PA, offers a variety of affordable dining options. From classic diners serving hearty breakfasts to food trucks offering inventive street food, there’s something for every budget. Many local cafes and markets also provide fresh, delicious meals at reasonable prices, ensuring you can enjoy the local flavors without breaking the bank.

Route 30 Diner is a classic American dining spot in Lancaster.
Route 30 Diner is a classic American dining spot in Lancaster.

What are some fine dining options in Lancaster PA?

For fine dining in Lancaster, PA, there are several excellent choices. Restaurants like The Pressroom Restaurant and Bar and Conway Social Club offer sophisticated menus in elegant settings. These establishments focus on high-quality ingredients, expert preparation, and impeccable service, providing a top-tier dining experience.

Is Lancaster PA a good place for foodies?

Lancaster, PA, is a fantastic destination for foodies. The city’s culinary scene is diverse, offering everything from traditional Pennsylvania Dutch fare to contemporary cuisine. With its rich agricultural roots, Lancaster boasts fresh, locally sourced ingredients, making it a haven for those who appreciate quality and variety in their food.

What types of international cuisine can I find in Lancaster?

Lancaster’s dining scene includes a wide range of international cuisines. You can find authentic Italian, Mexican, Asian, and Middle Eastern restaurants throughout the city. These eateries offer genuine flavors and dishes, often prepared by chefs native to the countries represented, ensuring an authentic dining experience.

Are there vegetarian or vegan options in Lancaster?

Yes, Lancaster offers a variety of vegetarian and vegan dining options. Many restaurants have dedicated vegetarian and vegan menus, while others are entirely plant-based. These establishments range from casual cafes to fine dining, ensuring that those following a plant-based diet have plenty of choices.

Final Thoughts On Unique Lancaster PA Restaurants

This Lancaster PA restaurant guide has explored a diverse array of dining experiences, from the unique to the traditional, the luxurious to the affordable. Lancaster’s rich cultural heritage and strong agricultural roots are reflected in its vibrant food scene, offering something for every palate and occasion.

Whether you’re seeking a magical evening filled with illusion and fine dining, a step back in time in a rustic setting, or a taste of the world in the heart of Pennsylvania, Lancaster’s restaurants deliver. Each establishment we’ve featured stands out for its unique character and commitment to quality.

The top restaurants in Lancaster PA for all types of travelers
Enjoyed reading about the unique restaurants in Lancaster PA? Pin it!

You may also like

Leave a Comment