Having visited the Finger Lakes three times, I’ve had the chance to experience some of the most stunning vacation homes in this breathtaking region. From cozy lakefront cabins to luxurious houses perched on the water, there’s no better way to soak in the beauty of upstate New York than by staying in one of these gems.
Whether you’re into quiet retreats by the water, exploring nearby wineries, or outdoor adventures, these 20 incredible Airbnb and VRBO listings have it all. I’m excited to share my personal favorites with you—each offering a perfect blend of comfort, charm, and those unbeatable Finger Lakes views!
The 20 Nicest Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes, NY
Here are the best Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes by category, taking into account different amenities, trip types, and budgets. The next sections will cover each listing, as well as other Airbnb vacation rentals, in more detail.
- Top Overall: Castle Point Paradise in the Finger Lakes
- Best Luxury Rental: Dramatic Lakefront Chalet in Ithaca
- Most Romantic: Luxurious Finger Lakes Home
- Best for Large Groups: Elegant Estate Tucked in Nature
- Best Cheap Airbnb: Hunt Hollow Cottage and Spa
- Coolest Treehouse: Leap Frog Treehouse
- Best Cabin: Cozy, Quiet Cabin on Seneca Lake
- Top with a Pool: Copper Ridge Hillside Retreat
- Best Winter Airbnb: Cozy Winter Getaway in Canandaigua
- Best Lake House: Private Beachfront House
- Most Unique: Luxury Houseboat on Seneca Lake
Note: The properties below are featured on Airbnb, VRBO, Booking and Expedia. For each listing, I’ve only included the link to the website with the cheapest rates.
1. Cozy Luxury Home
- 📍 Location: Burdett
- 💵 Price Per Night: $789/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 12 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Lake views, hot tub, plunge pool, outdoor kitchen, bunkroom loft
- 🌟 Perfect For: Wine lovers 🍷, families 👨👩👧👦, group getaways
Settle into this cozy-luxury retreat in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Trail. With space for up to 12 guests and sweeping lake views, it’s designed for easy group getaways.
Cook meals together in the chef’s kitchen, relax by the fireplace, or let the kids take over the fun bunkroom loft. The primary suite features a king bed, soaking tub, and private ensuite for a little extra comfort.
Walk to Two Goats Brewing or sip your way through local favorites like Atwater Estate Vineyards and Chateau LaFayette Reneau. For outdoor adventure, Watkins Glen State Park is just minutes away.
Before you book anything, don’t miss these deals 👇
- ✈️ Find cheap flights you won't see on Google - Going.com saves me $200+ per ticket
- 🏨 Book your stay – The best 2025 deals on boutique hotels and vacation homes
Whether it’s a wine weekend or a family escape, this scenic stay makes the perfect Finger Lakes base.
2. Castello Home
- 📍 Location: Himrod
- 💵 Price Per Night: $661/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Hot tub under the stars, pool table, three decks with lake views
- 🌟 Perfect For: Wine lovers 🍷, couples 💑, families 👨👩👧👦, friend groups
Tucked just above Seneca Lake, Castello is a modern cabin that balances upscale comfort with Finger Lakes charm. Although set back on a quiet private lane, you’re still just minutes from Route 14 and the region’s top wineries.
The home features an open-concept layout with a granite kitchen island, a dining table for eight, and a cozy living room warmed by a gas fireplace. A pool table offers extra fun for laid-back nights in.
Outdoors, relax in the hot tub under the stars or gather on the spacious deck for grilling and lake views. The yard includes a fire pit and plenty of space for lawn games or simply lounging with friends.
Spend your days exploring the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, launching your boat at Severne Point, or visiting nearby favorites like Hermann J. Wiemer and Torrey Ridge Winery. Castello is a true Finger Lakes base for making lasting memories.
3. Dramatic Lakefront Timberframe Home
- 📍 Location: Ithaca
- 💵 Price Per Night: $3,266/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 12 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: 5,000 sq. ft. luxury timber frame, two docks, Lakeview hot tub
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, wine trail explorers 🍷, luxury seekers 🛁
Experience Cayuga Lake from this one-of-a-kind timber frame estate with nearly 200 feet of private shoreline. Set just 15 minutes from Downtown Ithaca, this lakeside retreat offers a blend of rustic elegance and high-end amenities.
Inside, soaring wood-beamed ceilings frame the gourmet kitchen and open living areas, while three fireplaces add warmth and ambiance. The main floor features two master suites, and upstairs you’ll find additional bedrooms along with a fun bunkroom for the kids.
Step outside to two spacious decks, a lakeview hot tub, and a custom outdoor kitchen complete with a grill and smoker. Spend evenings by the fire pit, fish from one of the docks, or unwind with music on the Sonos sound system.
✈️ Pro Travel Tip:
I use Going.com to find crazy flight deals...($300 roundtrip to Europe kind of crazy).
It’s free, and I honestly check it more than Google Flights. For a limited time only, they are offering 25% off on Premium and Elite to readers of my website, using my special code: JON25)
From wine tasting along the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail to hiking local gorges or visiting Cornell University, this property is the perfect Finger Lakes luxury base.
4. Rock Stream Estate
- 📍 Location: Rock Stream
- 💵 Price Per Night: $2,290/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 30 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Hot tub, formal dining for 28, 5 private acres, ideal for events
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family reunions 👨👩👧👦, wellness retreats 🧘, wine trail getaways 🍷
Step back in time at this grand 1927 country estate nestled on five serene acres in the heart of Finger Lakes wine country. With room for 30 guests, Rock Stream Estate is designed for gatherings—whether it’s a family reunion, retreat, or special event.
The home offers a formal living room, a cozy breakfast nook, and a grand dining space that seats 28. The kitchen is ready for group meals with double stoves and fridges, while fireplaces and game tables invite guests to unwind.
Outdoors, soak in the hot tub, relax in the gazebo, or enjoy morning coffee while watching the sunrise over the valley. Wide lawns and peaceful walking paths make this property feel like your own private park.
Explore nearby Watkins Glen State Park, sip local wines at Glenora Wine Cellars, or cruise along Seneca Lake. From festive dinners to quiet mornings, this estate offers an unforgettable Finger Lakes experience.
5. Cozy Lake House with Indoor Pool
- 📍 Location: Canandaigua
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,869/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 14 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Indoor heated pool, jacuzzi with lake views, five fireplaces
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family reunions 👨👩👧👦, lake lovers 🚤, winter escapes ❄️
Gather your group for a lakeside getaway at this Canandaigua home, where comfort meets adventure. With an indoor heated pool, jacuzzi, and five fireplaces, it’s a year-round retreat for family and friends.
The home includes two spacious living areas with vaulted ceilings and cozy spots to relax. The kitchen is built for entertaining, featuring double ovens, dual refrigerators, a beverage fridge, and plenty of seating for shared meals.
Spend your days skiing at Bristol Mountain, catching a show at CMAC Performing Arts Center, or strolling through downtown Canandaigua’s shops and restaurants. In warmer months, head out on the lake for boating, fishing, or kayaking.
Whether you’re hosting a winter escape or a summer reunion, this home provides a comfortable and scenic base for Finger Lakes fun.
6. Spacious Waterfront Lodge
- 📍 Location: Burdett
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,883/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 20 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private 300+ ft lake frontage, boat dock & slip, timber frame design
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, wine lovers 🍷, nature seekers 🌲, lake adventurers 🚤
Escape to this expansive timber-frame lodge on the southeastern shore of Seneca Lake. With over 5,000 square feet of living space and 300 feet of private waterfront, it’s the ultimate Finger Lakes retreat for large groups.
The home features six bedrooms and five bathrooms, with open living and dining areas that frame the lake through oversized windows. Gather in the chef’s kitchen, lounge by the fireplace, or relax in one of the many cozy nooks.
Outside, enjoy your private dock, boat slip, and lakeside sun deck. Paddle the calm waters, unwind in the hot tub beneath the stars, or simply soak in the quiet of this secluded four-acre property.
Explore Seneca Harbor, hike Watkins Glen State Park, or tour local wineries like Castel Grisch. Adventure and relaxation come together seamlessly at this lakeside retreat.
7. Baby Blue at Sugar Creek
- 📍 Location: Penn Yan
- 💵 Price Per Night: $185/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 2 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private 10-acre setting, Sugar Creek frontage, oversized deck
- 🌟 Perfect For: Couples 💑, solo travelers 🌿, Finger Lakes wine lovers 🍷
Discover Baby Blue at Sugar Creek, a designer tiny home tucked beneath towering sycamore and black walnut trees. This 8×20 shipping container home is set on 10 private acres, complete with a gentle creek running through.
Inside, you’ll find a full-size Murphy bed, a sleek kitchenette with a mini-fridge and Nespresso machine, and a spa-like bathroom with subway tile and a custom rainwater shower. A modern composting toilet adds an eco-friendly touch.
Step out onto the oversized deck—your open-air living room—perfect for grilling, lounging, and enjoying peaceful forest views.
Just minutes from Keuka Lake, local wineries, breweries, and hiking trails, Baby Blue offers a one-of-a-kind Finger Lakes escape for couples or solo travelers.
8. Amazing Lakefront Bungalow
- 📍 Location: Romulus
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,458/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 10 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Level lakefront with no steps, jetted tub, mahogany porch
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨👩👧👦, wine lovers 🍷, lakefront retreats 🌅
This lakefront bungalow blends modern comfort with classic lakehouse style, set right on the eastern shore of Seneca Lake. With room for 10 guests and a flat, walk-out beach, it’s an ideal spot for family escapes or lake days with friends.
The home features four bedrooms, three full baths, a fully equipped kitchen with a wine fridge, and a cozy living room with a gas fireplace. In the main-floor suite, unwind in the jetted tub after a day on the water.
Outside, launch a kayak from the shore, gather around the fire pit, or relax on the mahogany porch while the sun sets over the lake.
Explore local wineries like Three Brothers Estates, roam Sampson State Park, or spend the afternoon in Geneva for dining and shopping. This is Finger Lakes living at its most relaxed.
9. Shale Beach
- 📍 Location: Hammondsport
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,319/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 20 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: 150′ natural shale beach, dock, new hot tub, lake toys
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, reunions 🎉, lake lovers 🌊
Shale Beach is a luxury lakefront home with 150 feet of natural shoreline on Keuka Lake. Designed for large groups, this spacious retreat combines upscale amenities with laid-back lake life.
Inside, you’ll find four bedrooms, six bathrooms, and over 4,000 sq ft of living space. The open kitchen is built for entertaining, and oversized windows offer stunning water views throughout.
Outdoors, enjoy a covered porch, lakeside fire pit, and private dock with kayaks, paddleboards, and a pedal boat. There’s also a new hot tub and an EV charger to keep things stress-free.
Spend your days sipping wine at Bully Hill Vineyards, exploring Keuka Lake Vineyards, or strolling the charming village of Hammondsport. From boat rides to s’mores by the fire, this home makes lake days unforgettable.
10. Frog’s Leap Tree-House
- 📍 Location: Hemlock
- 💵 Price Per Night: $266/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 3 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Off-grid treehouse, private ponds, canoes & kayaks
- 🌟 Perfect For: Nature lovers 🦌, couples ✨, peaceful retreats 🌲
Frog’s Leap is a secluded, off-grid treehouse tucked deep in the woods of Hemlock, NY. It’s the perfect hideaway for couples or small groups looking to unplug and reconnect with nature.
The cozy two-story cabin features a queen bed in the loft, a sofa bed below, and a compact kitchen with a two-burner stove, mini-fridge, toaster oven, and cold water sink.
Days here are best spent on the water or in the woods—paddle the ponds, fish for bass, or explore the forest trails where deer, herons, and frogs make frequent appearances.
This is a one-of-a-kind retreat for anyone craving stillness, stars, and solitude.
11. Private EcoBarn Home
- 📍 Location: Burdett
- 💵 Price Per Night: $550/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 5 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Outdoor clawfoot tub, screened lanai, organic garden
- 🌟 Perfect For: Nature lovers 🌿, couples 🌅, wellness seekers 🛁, wine trail explorers 🍷
The EcoBarn is a private, eco-friendly escape set on 100 peaceful acres in the Finger Lakes. Built with reclaimed materials, this unique retreat offers sunset views, privacy, and easy access to top wineries, trails, and waterfalls.
Sliding glass doors throughout the home create a seamless connection to nature. The open layout includes a full kitchen, cozy living room, and sleeping space for five with a king, queen, and twin beds.
Soak under the sky in the outdoor clawfoot tub, gather herbs from the garden, or share stories by the fire pit. A tranquil pond, pavilion, and seasonal shower complete the experience..
Swim in Seneca Lake, hike nearby trails, or follow the Finger Lakes Wine Trail. Whether you’re here to explore or simply unwind, the EcoBarn is a destination in itself.
12. Lakeside Log Cabin
- 📍 Location: Penn Yan
- 💵 Price Per Night: $422/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private lakefront, dock & boat hoist, screened porch
- 🌟 Perfect For: Wine lovers 🍷, families 👨👩👧👦, outdoor enthusiasts 🌳
This lakeside log cabin is a cozy waterfront retreat nestled among the trees on Seneca Lake. Located along the Wine Trail, it’s a peaceful base for families or couples to relax and reconnect.
Inside, the open layout offers cedar-scented charm, a full kitchen, and a warm living room with an ornamental wood stove. A screened porch invites slow mornings with coffee and lake breezes.
Downstairs, a game room with Ping-Pong, air hockey, and board games keeps everyone entertained. Outside, gather around the fire pit, grill dinner, or take the boat out from your private dock.
Spend the day at nearby wineries, hike scenic trails, or paddle along the shore at sunset. From s’mores to stargazing, this cabin is the perfect place to unwind.
13. Copper Ridge
- 📍 Location: Beaver Dams
- 💵 Price Per Night: $950/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Heated pool, year-round hot tub, pickleball court
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨👩👧👦, outdoor lovers 🏞️, race fans 🏁, wine country explorers 🍷
Welcome to Copper Ridge, a private 70-acre estate where outdoor adventure meets upscale comfort. With a heated pool, hot tub, and pickleball court, this Finger Lakes retreat has something for everyone.
The open floor plan includes four bedrooms, three full baths, a fully stocked kitchen, and a game room with foosball and a 9-foot pool table.
Step outside to enjoy the oversized heated pool, unwind in the 8-person hot tub, or play a round of pickleball surrounded by nature.
Located just six miles from Watkins Glen International and close to Seneca Lake, waterfalls, and wineries, Copper Ridge is your year-round home base for fun and relaxation.
14. Drift Away
- 📍 Location: Geneva
- 💵 Price Per Night: $616/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 5 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Direct lakefront, hot tub, kayaks, fire pit
- 🌟 Perfect For: Small families 👨👩👧👦, lake lovers 🌊, wine trail explorers 🍷
Drift Away is a peaceful hideout on the edge of Seneca Lake, with panoramic water views and a private dock. Relax in the hot tub, play a game of ping pong, or gather by the fire pit under the stars.
Indoors, the home features two cozy living rooms, a fireplace, and a fully stocked kitchen for shared meals and game nights.
Out on the dock, launch a kayak at sunrise or kick back in an Adirondack chair while the lake shimmers.
Located just 10 minutes from Downtown Geneva, this retreat keeps you close to wineries, great dining, and outdoor adventures, while still feeling worlds away.
15. Chickadee Cabin
- 📍 Location: Hemlock
- 💵 Price Per Night: $242/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 4 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Secluded woodland setting, private pond with dock & pedal boat
- 🌟 Perfect For: Couples ❤️, writers ✍️, nature lovers 🌲, quiet retreats 🔥
Chickadee Cabin is a peaceful woodland escape nestled on the hillside above Honeoye Lake. This newly renovated hideaway combines rustic charm with the modern comforts you need to relax and recharge.
The cabin features an open kitchen, dining, and living area with serene views and a wood-burning fireplace. Two cozy queen bedrooms and a full bath make it ideal for couples or small families.
Step onto the spacious deck to grill, dine al fresco, or watch the sunset through the trees. The property also includes a private pond with a pedal boat, a hammock for lazy afternoons, and a fire pit perfect for starlit evenings.
When you’re ready to explore, you’re minutes from Honeoye Lake, local hiking trails, ski resorts, breweries, and charming small-town shops—everything you need for a quiet Finger Lakes retreat.
16. Cozy Lakeside Home
- 📍 Location: Canandaigua
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,347/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 16 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: New heated pool, 120′ of level lakefront, hot tub, seasonal dock
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, reunions 🎉, lake lovers 🌊
This cozy lakeside retreat offers 120 feet of flat, private Canandaigua Lake frontage, plus a half-acre of lawn backed by 14 wooded acres—perfect for family getaways or group gatherings.
The home features six bedrooms and four full baths, including three king suites and a fun bunkroom for kids. The fully renovated kitchen comes with dual refrigerators, a 9-foot island, and modern appliances built for group meals.
Spend your days lounging by the brand-new heated pool, relaxing in the hot tub, or grilling on the lakeside patio. The seasonal dock makes it easy to swim, kayak, or fish right from shore.
Less than a mile away, enjoy dining at The Lake House, catch a concert at CMAC, or tour nearby wineries. From poolside mornings to lakefront sunsets, this home has everything for a classic Finger Lakes escape.
17. Private Lakefront Compound
- 📍 Location: Trumansburg
- 💵 Price Per Night: $711/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 12 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Three separate living structures, lakefront dock, pedal boat & kayaks
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, reunions 🎉, Cornell/Ithaca College visits 🎓, nature lovers 🌲
This private lakefront compound offers 120 feet of secluded beachfront and three separate living spaces, giving everyone room to spread out while staying connected.
The property includes a main house, a cozy beach suite, and a separate boathouse. With four bedrooms and flexible sleeping arrangements, the setup comfortably hosts up to 12 guests.
Spend mornings sipping coffee on the deck, afternoons paddling kayaks, and evenings gathered around the fire pit. The large lawn, gas grill, and ample seating make it easy to entertain.
Located just a mile from Taughannock Falls State Park and under 30 minutes from Cornell University and Ithaca College, this is a perfect home base for hiking, wine tours, or graduation weekends.
18. High End Hideaway
- 📍 Location: Skaneateles
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,206/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 10 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: 220 feet of Skaneateles Lake frontage, tennis court with cabana
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨👩👧👦, lake lovers 🚣, group getaways 🎉
Escape to High End Hideaway, a private retreat with 220 feet of lakefront on Skaneateles Lake. Just 9 miles from the village, this thoughtfully designed home offers luxury, privacy, and picture-perfect water views.
Inside, enjoy an open layout with a high-end kitchen, wet bar, and spacious dining area. A grand stone fireplace anchors the living room, while the main-floor suite includes a private deck overlooking the lake.
Take a soak in the jacuzzi, rinse off in the outdoor shower, or play a round of tennis before heading down to the water. The property comes with paddleboards, kayaks, a canoe, and two fire pit areas for relaxing by the lake.
When it’s time to explore, browse the boutique shops and restaurants of Skaneateles Village, or simply stay put and enjoy the view. From lake paddles to sunset cocktails, this hideaway has it all.
19. Historic Railcar Cabin
- 📍 Location: Homer
- 💵 Price Per Night: $420/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 7 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Restored 1936 stainless steel railcar, 198′ of private lakefront
- 🌟 Perfect For: Train lovers 🚂, families 👨👩👧👦, lakefront dreamers 🌊, vintage design fans ✨
Climb aboard this rare 1936 stainless steel railcar — a restored 110-ft gem set on 198 feet of private Skaneateles Lake shoreline, blending vintage charm with lakeside comfort.
Indoors, you’ll find cozy oak and cherry interiors milled from the property itself. The railcar features three bedrooms (plus futons for extra guests), two full baths, and a well-equipped kitchen.
Located steps from Skaneateles Lake and a short drive from Otisco Lake and SUNY Cortland, this unique retreat puts you close to boating, local wineries, village shops, and scenic hiking trails.
Whether you’re watching the sunset from the railcar windows or jumping into the lake from your private dock, this is Skaneateles living like you’ve never seen before.
20. Sensational Seneca Lake Home
- 📍 Location: Romulus
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,166/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 12 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: 100-ft dock, hot tub, lakeside deck, game room,
- 🌟 Perfect For: Wine lovers 🍷, families 👨👩👧👦, lake life enthusiasts 🌅
Sensational Seneca Lake Home is a beautifully renovated getaway with stunning water views and prime access to the best of Finger Lakes Wine Country.
The home features a modern kitchen with a breakfast nook, an open living area with leather seating, and a wood-burning fireplace. Five bedrooms comfortably accommodate up to 12 guests, making it perfect for families or groups.
Spend the day paddling from the 100-foot dock, soaking in the hot tub, or relaxing on the lakeside deck. When night falls, gather for game nights in the rec room or unwind by the fire under the stars.
Hike the 20+ trails at Sampson State Park, tour nearby wineries, or visit wedding venues like Belhurst Castle and Ventosa Vineyards. From sunrise paddles to sunset toasts, this lakefront home is made for memory-making.
Top Airbnbs in the Finger Lakes NY
Have you stayed in any unique Airbnbs or vacation rentals in the Finger Lakes? Let me know in the comments, as I’m always looking to add to this lineup of the best Finger Lakes Airbnbs!
If you’re looking for more cool destinations in the northeast USA, check out these destinations:
– The Best Airbnbs in New York State
– Unique Airbnbs in New England
– Top Airbnbs in the White Mountains
– Coolest Airbnbs in Massachusetts
– Unique Airbnbs in Rhode Island
– Best Airbnbs in the Berkshires
Need help planning your trip? Check out these helpful links:
- ✈️ Find cheap flights – I save $10k per year on flights thanks to this tool
- 🏨 Book accommodations – My favorite platform for boutique hotels and budget stays
- 🚗 Compare rental car prices – Great rates from trusted companies
- 🎟️ Discover affordable tours and day trips – Skip the line and explore more
