Looking for a unique place to stay in New Jersey? This small but mighty state is packed with hidden gems, from cozy beachside cottages to luxurious cabins in the woods. I’ve been to every corner of New Jersey and explored its best stays firsthand. Whether you’re craving the charm of a coastal escape or the thrill of a lakefront retreat, I’ve got the top picks to make your stay unforgettable.
Here’s the kicker: while Airbnb has some great options, I dug into other vacation rental platforms like Vrbo and more to find better deals where possible. These 12 amazing rentals are the best of the best, offering both unique experiences and better value. So if you’re ready for a New Jersey adventure in 2025, these are the stays that deliver the vibe, comfort, and price you’re looking for.
The Coolest Airbnbs in New Jersey: Top Vacation Rentals in 2025
Here are the best Airbnbs in New Jersey by category, taking into account different amenities, trip types, and budgets. The subsequent sections will cover each listing in more detail.
- Top Airbnb in New Jersey: Sunset Bay Vacation Home
- Best Luxury Mansion Vacation Rental New Jersey: Mansion on the Beach
- Top Romantic Airbnb in New Jersey: Jersey Shore Beach House Rental
- Best New Jersey Airbnb for Large Groups: Ultimate Pool House
- Coolest Cheap Airbnb in NJ: Budget Friendly House in Union City
- Best Beach House Airbnb in New Jersey: Deluxe Beach House on the Ocean
- Top Airbnb New Jersey with a Pool: Modern Home for Rent with Heated Pool
- Coolest Cabin Rental in NJ: Quiet Log Cabin
- Most Unique Airbnb in New Jersey: Cape May Beachfront House for Rent

11 Best Airbnbs in New Jersey
If romantic condos, cabins, houses for rent, and luxury vacation rentals in New Jersey all sound good to you, get excited! Below are some of the most unique stays in New Jersey:
1. Lake Glenwood A-Frame Cabin with Stunning Views
Location: Sussex, New Jersey
Rates from: $257 per night
Accommodates: 6 guests


Nestled in the heart of Sussex, NJ, the Lake Glenwood A-Frame Cabin promises an escape that’s both rejuvenating and thrilling. With its A-frame architecture, this cabin stands as a testament to classic design combined with modern amenities.
The cabin boasts stunning views of the lake, ensuring every morning starts with a dose of nature’s beauty. Whether you’re sipping your morning coffee on the deck or gathering around the fire pit in the evening, the lake’s presence is a constant companion. For those who crave some indoor entertainment, the game room is ready to host your group, and the EV charger ensures your electric vehicle is always ready for the next adventure.
With two bedrooms equipped with queen beds and a common area featuring a double futon, the cabin comfortably sleeps six guests. The bathroom is designed with contemporary needs in mind, offering both a bathtub and a separate shower.
The cabin’s prime location is evident in its proximity to attractions. The Wawayanda State Park is just a 2-minute walk away, while thrill-seekers can reach the Mountain Creek Ski Resort and Mountain Creek Waterpark within a 12-minute drive.
For those seeking a blend of relaxation and adventure in Sussex, the Lake Glenwood A-Frame Cabin is an ideal choice.
2. Atlantic City Airbnb Home with Rooftop Deck
Location: Atlantic City, New Jersey
Rates from: $236 per night
Accommodates: 12 guests


If you’re traveling to New Jersey with a larger group, then this Airbnb in Atlantic City is the perfect accommodation for you! Twelve guests can stay here at a time and it’s only a short walk away from the shore and a quick drive from the beach.
This luxury house for rent in New Jersey has three bedrooms, three bathrooms, a full kitchen, a living room, and a rooftop deck with outdoor furniture so guests can dine with a view. Guests will also have access to a barbecue grill for a family fun cookout. Is this one of the best Airbnbs in New Jersey? Absolutely!
3. Historic Mansion Retreat on Private Lake
Location: Trenton, New Jersey
Rates from: $1,225 per night
Accommodates: 25 guests


Experience a luxurious retreat at this family-friendly historic mansion nestled on a private lake in Trenton, NJ. Perfect for large gatherings, this stunning property sleeps up to 25 guests with eight bedrooms and six-and-a-half bathrooms.
Enjoy a host of amenities, including a hot tub, pool, and spacious dining areas. Each room combines historic charm with modern comforts, and the expansive outdoor spaces feature a garden, deck, and outdoor shower. Just minutes from Cadwalader Park and the New Jersey State Museum, it’s an ideal setting for relaxation and adventure alike. Plus, you won’t be far from New Jersey’s vibrant nightlife.
4. Luxury Airbnb Mansion in New Jersey on the Beach
Location: Brigantine, New Jersey, United States
Rates from: $1,200 per night
Accommodates: 16 guests


Stay at this New Jersey vacation rental on the beach and you’ll be in for a treat. This mansion is one of the top-rated mansions in the whole state! It’s incredibly luxurious and hosts up to sixteen guests at a time. This Airbnb rental in New Jersey is situated a short walk away from all the best things to do in Brigantine, including the beach, farmer’s market, and top restaurants.
This New Jersey vacation home features eight bedrooms and eight full bathrooms and a full kitchen, dining area, living room, and a private balcony. The inside is very bright and comfortable, with tons of windows throughout. Don’t forget to enjoy the private pool and outdoor grill! It won’t be long until you realize why this is among the best vacation rentals in New Jersey on Airbnb and VRBO.
5. Sunset Bay Vacation Home in New Jersey’s Long Beach
Location: Long Beach Township, New Jersey
Rates from: $258 per night
Accommodates: 6 guests


This beach house rental in New Jersey is among the best Airbnbs in the state, hands down. This recently renovated home is a great place to stay for six guests. It’s also known for having some of the most beautiful sunrises and sunsets in the area.
The interior of this New Jersey vacation rental is very bright and cheerful, with lots of windows, nautical decor, and even a private patio that overlooks the water. There’s also a washer and dryer, full kitchen, and free parking. If you’re looking for a best-value beach house Airbnb in New Jersey, this is it! This accommodation truly embodies the beauty of New Jersey.
6. Water Gap Log House
Location: Knowlton Township, New Jersey
Rates from: $592 per night
Accommodates: 18 guests


Nestled in the serene surroundings of Knowlton Township, the Water Gap Log House beckons travelers seeking a genuine log cabin experience. This expansive cabin, with its rustic charm and modern amenities, promises a stay that’s both authentic and comfortable.
With 5 spacious bedrooms, the cabin can comfortably sleep up to 18 guests. The sleeping arrangements are diverse, including rooms with queen beds, a king bed, and even a kids’ room equipped with twin bunk beds and an additional twin bed. The property boasts 3 bathrooms, ensuring convenience for larger groups.
The cabin’s location is a highlight, with attractions such as the Pequest River just a 6-minute drive away. Wine enthusiasts can head to the Brook Hollow Winery, a mere 7-minute drive from the property. For those looking to immerse themselves in nature, the Delaware River is a 14-minute drive away. This makes it one of the most livable spots in New Jersey.
Whether you’re planning a family reunion, a getaway with friends, or simply seeking solitude in nature’s lap, the Water Gap Log House offers the perfect setting. Its blend of rustic aesthetics and modern comforts ensures a memorable stay for all.
7. Dog Friendly Cozy Cape May Cottage
Location: Cape May, New Jersey
Rates from: $175 per night
Accommodates: 2 guests


Tucked away in the picturesque town of Cape May, NJ, the Cozy Cape May Cottage offers an intimate retreat for travelers. This charming cottage, with its welcoming ambiance and modern amenities, promises a stay that’s both relaxing and memorable.
The cottage is designed to cater to couples, with a comfortable queen bed ensuring restful nights. The bathroom is equipped with a shower, and there’s also an outdoor shower for those who enjoy a more natural experience. The kitchen is fully functional, allowing guests to whip up their favorite meals. An added bonus for pet lovers is the cottage’s dog-friendly policy, ensuring your furry friend can join in on the vacation.
Its prime location in Cape May ensures you’re never too far from local attractions. The Cape May Market is just a 2-minute drive away, perfect for stocking up on local produce and delicacies. For those interested in model trains, the Cape May Model Trains is a mere 3-minute drive. Additionally, the bustling Washington Street Mall is also a short 3-minute drive, offering a plethora of shopping and dining options.
Whether you’re exploring the local sights or simply lounging in the cottage’s garden, this retreat promises a delightful experience in Cape May.
8. Jersey Shore Beach House Rental – A Top Vacation Rental on Airbnb and VRBO
Location: Lavallette, New Jersey
Rates from: $172 per night
Accommodates: 10 guests


Do you want to head to the Jersey Shore for a fun-filled vacation? Then, this New Jersey vacation rental on Airbnb and VRBO might be perfect for you! It’s located in Lavallette, New Jersey, and is right near the beach. The house is very spacious, so ten guests can stay here at a time.
Inside, there are four bedrooms, two bathrooms, a full kitchen, and an outdoor space that is right next to the sand of the beach. Plus, beach access is private, so it won’t be overrun by other tourists heading to Jersey Shore for a vacation. If you’re seeking a top Airbnb in Jersey Shore, this is it!
9. Beachfront Beauty
Location: Sea Isle City, New Jersey
Rates from: $525 per night
Accommodates: 9 guests


Imagine waking up to the soothing sounds of waves crashing on the shore and the gentle sea breeze caressing your face. Welcome to the Beachfront Beauty located on 59th Street in Sea Isle! This stunning property offers breathtaking ocean views and is just a stone’s throw away from the pristine Sea Isle City Beach.
This spacious beachfront house boasts four beautifully appointed bedrooms. The master bedroom features a luxurious king bed, while the second bedroom offers a cozy queen bed. The third bedroom is perfect for kids or a group, with a twin bunk bed and a double bed. The fourth bedroom houses two twin beds, ensuring a comfortable stay for up to 9 guests. With three well-equipped bathrooms and an additional outdoor shower, convenience is at its best.
The house’s prime location in Sea Isle City ensures you’re in the heart of all the action. A mere 1-minute walk will take you to the Sea Isle City Beach, where you can indulge in sunbathing, beach volleyball, or simply building sandcastles. For those looking to explore beyond the beach, the property is a short drive from the bustling Atlantic City, offering a mix of entertainment, shopping, and dining options.
Whether you’re sipping on a morning coffee on the patio, watching the sunrise, or enjoying a BBQ evening with loved ones, this Beachfront Beauty promises an unforgettable beach vacation.
10. New Jersey Airbnb for Rent Near Cape May
Location: Middle Township, New Jersey
Rates from: $330 per night
Accommodates: 8 guests


This fantastic beach house rental in New Jersey offers some of the best views possible of Delaware Bay! Just imagine catching the sunrise or sunset from the comfort of your very own accommodation. Eight guests can stay here at a time, with five bedrooms, three bathrooms, a full kitchen, a living room, a dining area, and a private patio overlooking the beach.
Enjoy the private beach with stunning coastal views, where you can go kayaking, canoeing, fishing, or swimming. It won’t be long until you see why this is one of the top New Jersey rentals near Cape May!
Read next: Most Unique Rentals in San Francisco
11. Budget-Friendly Union City Airbnb in New Jersey
Location: Union City, New Jersey
Rates from: $138 per night
Accommodates: 12 guests


For budget-conscious travelers, it doesn’t get any better than this Airbnb for rent in Union City, New Jersey. It’s right next to Hoboken and is across the water from New York City, so you can cross two states off your bucket list by staying here.
The NJ apartment rental on Airbnb is spacious and has three bedrooms, as well as a huge kitchen and a living room area. The inside is very nice, with unique lighting and fun pops of color on the wall, which help to brighten the space up. If you’re looking for a cheap accommodation in New Jersey, you can’t go wrong with a stay at this Union City home.

Coolest Airbnbs in New Jersey: Apartments, Mansions, Houses for Rent + More
Have you ever stayed in a unique Airbnb vacation rental in New Jersey? Definitely let me know! As I’m always looking to add to this list of the best Airbnbs in New Jersey!
Considering other unique destinations in the US? Here are some ideas:
– Top Vacation Stays in Vermont
– Half Moon Bay Vacation Getaway
– Best Places to Stay in Jackson Hole, WY
– Unique Airbnb Rentals in Colorado
– Coolest Places in the Berkshires MA
– Vacation Rentals in the White Mountains
– Unique Stays around New England