7 Fun & Unique Restaurants in New Jersey (Foodie Guide)

515

New Jersey’s food scene is seriously underrated, and after visiting several times over the years, I’ve discovered just how diverse and exciting it really is. From cozy waterfront bistros along the Hudson River to rooftop eateries in Hoboken with stunning skyline views, this state has it all. Whether you’re into classic Italian spots in Jersey City, seafood shacks on the Jersey Shore, or trendy cafes in Montclair, you’ll find a little bit of everything here.

Each town has its own flavor, and the mix of cultures makes dining in NJ a real treat. Here are 7 of the most unique and fun restaurants across New Jersey that every foodie should try at least once!

• 👉 Pro Tip: I HIGHLY recommend doing this dinner cruise with dolphin watching in Cape May. It’s a scenic sunset dinner cruise that brings you to landmarks in Delaware Bay, including Cape May Lighthouse, as well as whale and dolphin spotting. This tour is an absolute must-do on any New Jersey itinerary in my opinion. A great birthday gift, too!

Unique Restaurants in New Jersey

Are you excited to explore the most fun and unique restaurants in New Jersey? There are incredible places to eat in NJ that will please all locals and travelers alike. Are you looking for a Venetian gondola dining experience by the water? Or would you prefer a journey through time with dishes from different decades? Whatever you’d like to eat, there are unique places to eat in New Jersey that got you covered. These eateries are some of the best spots on the East Coast, hands down.

1. Rat’s Restaurant – Hamilton

• 📍 Location: Hamilton (Grounds For Sculpture)
• 💲 Price range: $50 – $100+ per person
• 🍽️ Cuisine Style: French Country / Upscale
• 🔥 Standout Features: Monet’s Giverny setting, sculpture garden views, refined French.
• 🎯 Perfect For: Romantic occasions, art/garden lovers, and upscale French dining.

Step into a living Monet painting at Rat’s Restaurant, nestled within the breathtaking Grounds For Sculpture in Hamilton! This enchanting spot is designed to evoke Giverny, with charming country French architecture, lily pad-dotted ponds, and stunning views of the surrounding sculptures. The air is filled with an atmosphere of romantic artistry.

You’ll definitely want to try the classic French onion soup gratinée or the flavorful Escargots de Bourgogne. For a main course, the steak frites is a popular choice. Their wine list is excellent. It’s a truly magical dining experience.

2. Delsea Drive-In – Vineland

• 📍 Location: Vineland
• 💲 Price range: $10 – $20 per person (Movie ticket + concessions)
• 🍽️ Cuisine Style: Classic American Drive-In Fare / Movie Snacks
• 🔥 Standout Features: NJ’s only drive-in, retro double features, classic concessions.
• 🎯 Perfect For: Nostalgic movie nights, unique family fun, and American drive-in eats.

Roll back the clock for a double feature of fun and food at the Delsea Drive-In in Vineland, New Jersey’s last remaining drive-in movie theater! This beloved institution offers a wonderfully nostalgic experience, where you can watch movies from the comfort of your car under the stars. The aroma of popcorn and grilling burgers is pure Americana.

Grab classic drive-in fare from their concession stand. People rave about their juicy cheeseburgers and crispy fries. Of course, a movie isn’t complete without hot popcorn, and for a sweet treat, the funnel cake is a must. It’s a fantastic way to enjoy a night out.

3. Medieval Times – Lyndhurst

• 📍 Location: Lyndhurst
• 💲 Price range: $50 – $80+ per person (Dinner & Show)
• 🍽️ Cuisine Style: American / Medieval Feast / Dinner Theater
• 🔥 Standout Features: Live medieval tournament, jousting/horsemanship, utensil-free castle dining.
• 🎯 Perfect For: Theatrical family outings, medieval fantasy fans, and interactive dinner-shows.

Huzzah! Prepare for a feast and a battle of epic proportions at Medieval Times Dinner & Tournament in Lyndhurst! Cheer for your knight as they joust, sword fight, and perform incredible feats of horsemanship in a grand arena, all while you devour a utensil-free meal.

The castle setting and thrilling tournament create an electrifying atmosphere. The feast includes hearty roasted chicken, sweet buttered corn, and herb-basted potatoes. You also get a tasty tomato bisque. It’s a full-blown spectacle where you eat with your hands!

4. The Silverball Museum – Asbury Park

• 📍 Location: Asbury Park
• 💲 Price range: $10 – $20 per person (Game play, food separate)
• 🍽️ Cuisine Style: Classic American Boardwalk Fare / Snacks
• 🔥 Standout Features: Vintage pinball/arcade, playable games, casual boardwalk eats.
• 🎯 Perfect For: Pinball wizards, retro arcade fans, and fun boardwalk bites.

Get your game on at The Silverball Museum in Asbury Park, a haven for pinball wizards and lovers of all things retro arcade! This isn’t just a museum; it’s a playable archive of hundreds of classic pinball machines and arcade games. They also offer classic boardwalk-style fare.

Grab quick and tasty boardwalk eats. Many visitors enjoy a classic hot dog or some salty fries. A warm soft pretzel or a slice of pizza also hit the spot to fuel your gaming adventures. The flashing lights create an incredibly fun atmosphere.

5. The Knife & Fork Inn – Atlantic City

• 📍 Location: Atlantic City
• 💲 Price range: $50 – $100+ per person
• 🍽️ Cuisine Style: Classic American Steakhouse / Seafood / Historic
• 🔥 Standout Features: Iconic AC institution, Prohibition-era history, classic fine dining.
• 🎯 Perfect For: Historic fine dining, Boardwalk Empire fans, and upscale steak/seafood.

Step into a piece of Atlantic City history at The Knife & Fork Inn, an iconic institution since 1912. This legendary spot, once a haunt of Nucky Thompson, exudes old-world charm, serving up classic American steakhouse and seafood fare in a refined setting.

For a truly classic experience, many recommend their famous Lobster Thermidor. The filet mignon is cooked to perfection, and their crab cakes are a local favorite. It’s a timeless choice for an upscale, atmospheric meal steeped in AC history.

6. Lucy’s Kitchen – Princeton

• 📍 Location: Princeton
• 💲 Price range: $15 – $30 per person
• 🍽️ Cuisine Style: Polish / Eastern European / Home-Style
• 🔥 Standout Features: Homemade Polish cuisine, cozy/unpretentious, beloved local gem.
• 🎯 Perfect For: Polish comfort food, pierogi/kielbasa lovers, and Eastern European taste.

Get ready for a delicious taste of Poland right in Princeton at Lucy’s Kitchen! This cozy and unpretentious spot is a beloved local gem, serving up authentic, homemade Polish cuisine that’s pure comfort food. The air is filled with wonderful aromas.

You should certainly try their incredible pierogi, handmade with fillings like potato and cheese or meat. A hearty plate of kielbasa and sauerkraut is a must, and their stuffed cabbage (golabki) is wonderfully satisfying. It’s like a Polish grandmother’s kitchen.

7. Heirloom Kitchen – Old Bridge

• 📍 Location: Old Bridge
• 💲 Price range: $70 – $150+ per person (Often tasting menu/prix fixe)
• 🍽️ Cuisine Style: Modern American / Farm-to-Table / Tasting Menu & Cooking School
• 🔥 Standout Features: Chef’s counter/tasting menus, cooking school, hyper-seasonal/local.
• 🎯 Perfect For: Serious foodies, unique culinary experiences, and local/seasonal cuisine.

Experience food as art and education at Heirloom Kitchen in Old Bridge. This unique spot is part intimate restaurant offering incredible tasting menus and part interactive cooking school, all driven by a passion for hyper-seasonal, locally sourced ingredients.

Reservations are essential for the tasting events. Expect dishes highlighting Jersey Fresh produce, like creative seasonal vegetable courses. Perfectly prepared local seafood, such as scallops, and inventive handmade pasta dishes are common features.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Unique Restaurants in New Jersey

Searching for more content to help you decide where to eat in New Jersey? Here are some common questions (and answers) I get asked a lot about New Jersey’s best restaurants.

What is New Jersey’s most iconic food?

If there’s one dish that stands out in New Jersey, it’s the Taylor Ham (or Pork Roll) sandwich. This breakfast staple, often served with egg and cheese on a bagel or roll, has been a favorite among locals for decades. Whether you’re at a diner or a food truck, you’re sure to find this unique New Jersey delicacy on the menu!

What is one thing New Jersey is known for?

Aside from New Jersey’s restaurants, New Jersey is famously known as the “Garden State.” With its lush farmlands and fresh produce markets, the state boasts a rich agricultural heritage. From juicy tomatoes to sweet blueberries, New Jersey’s produce is a testament to its fertile lands and farming traditions.

Are there any unique places in New Jersey to eat that cater to vegetarians?

Absolutely! New Jersey’s dining scene is diverse, with many restaurants offering extensive vegetarian and vegan menus. Places like “Green Goddess Cafe” in Princeton or “Veggie Heaven” in Teaneck are just a couple of the many establishments catering to plant-based diets.

Which areas in New Jersey are best for food enthusiasts?

New Jersey is an incredible destination for food lovers. Here’s a quick rundown of areas that are a must-visit for any culinary enthusiast:

• Newark’s Ironbound District: Known for its Portuguese, Spanish, and Brazilian eateries.
• Asbury Park: A mix of trendy cafes, bakeries, and fine dining options.
• Princeton: Home to upscale restaurants and charming bistros.
• Hoboken: Famous for its Italian delis and waterfront dining spots.

How does the fine dining scene in New Jersey compare to New York?

While New York City has a globally recognized dining scene, New Jersey’s fine dining establishments, like “The Ryland Inn” or “Restaurant Latour,” offer top-notch culinary experiences without the Manhattan price tag. Plus, many of New Jersey’s best restaurants provide a cozier, more intimate setting.

Are reservations necessary when dining at popular New Jersey restaurants?

For most of the best restaurants in New Jersey, especially during weekends or holidays, I recommend making a reservation. Some popular spots can get booked weeks in advance, so it’s always a good idea to plan ahead.

What’s the best way to discover hidden gem restaurants in NJ?

Local food festivals, farmer’s markets, and word of mouth are great ways to uncover lesser-known dining spots. Additionally, online platforms and food blogs often feature reviews and recommendations for hidden gem restaurants in NJ.

What is the most famous food in New Jersey?

New Jersey is known for a variety of iconic foods. Some of the most famous include:

1. Taylor Ham (or Pork Roll): A type of processed pork product that’s often enjoyed as a breakfast sandwich with egg and cheese.
2. Salt Water Taffy: Originating from the boardwalks of Atlantic City, this chewy candy comes in a variety of flavors.
3. Tomato Pies: A type of pizza where cheese and toppings are placed directly on the crust, followed by a tomato sauce on top.
4. Jersey Tomatoes: Widely regarded as some of the best in the U.S., they’re a staple in summer salads and sandwiches.
5. Disco Fries: Similar to Canada’s poutine, disco fries are made with french fries topped with cheese and gravy.
6. Italian Hot Dogs: A double hot dog served in pizza bread with onions, peppers, and potatoes.
7. Hoagies: Known as subs or sandwiches in other parts of the U.S., hoagies are a staple in New Jersey, especially in the southern part of the state.
8. Clams Casino: A dish with clams on the half shell that are topped with breadcrumbs and bacon.
9. Frozen Custard: Especially popular along the Jersey Shore, it’s creamier and denser than regular ice cream.
10. Ripper Hot Dogs: Deep-fried hot dogs that rip apart during the frying process, popularized by places like Rutt’s Hut.

What restaurants do they have in New Jersey?

New Jersey boasts a diverse culinary scene with a wide range of restaurants catering to various cuisines, tastes, and budgets. Here’s a snapshot of some notable restaurants and eateries across the state:

1. White House Subs (Atlantic City): Famous for its submarine sandwiches.
2. Razza (Jersey City): Known for its artisanal pizzas and has been lauded as one of the best pizzerias in the country.
3. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que (Newark): A popular spot for barbecue lovers.
4. The Frog and The Peach (New Brunswick): A fine-dining institution offering New American cuisine.
5. Dock’s Oyster House (Atlantic City): A historic seafood restaurant that’s been around since 1897.
6. Cafe Matisse (Rutherford): An upscale restaurant known for its picturesque setting and gourmet dishes.
7. Zeppoli (Collingswood): Offers traditional Sicilian dishes and an intimate setting.
8. Sagami Japanese Restaurant (Collingswood): Renowned for its authentic sushi.
9. Montclair Bread Company (Montclair): Famous for its doughnuts and artisanal breads.
10. Marcel Bakery and Kitchen (Montclair): A popular spot for Mediterranean-inspired dishes.
11. Carlos Bakery (Hoboken): Made famous by the TV show “Cake Boss,” it’s a go-to for pastries, especially cakes.
12. Tony Boloney’s (Atlantic City, Hoboken, and more): Known for its inventive pizzas and subs.
13. Peter Luger Steak House (Hackensack): An offshoot of the famous Brooklyn steakhouse.
14. De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies (Robbinsville): A favorite for traditional tomato pies.
15. Veggie Heaven (Multiple locations): A popular vegetarian and vegan restaurant chain.

What food is Jersey City famous for?

Jersey City, located in the shadow of Manhattan, has a rich culinary scene influenced by its diverse population. While it doesn’t have one specific dish it’s singularly famous for, it’s known for a variety of foods and culinary experiences. Here are some highlights:

1. Ethnic Cuisines: Due to its diverse population, Jersey City is home to a wide range of ethnic restaurants. From Filipino to Indian, from Italian to Middle Eastern, the city offers a culinary journey around the world.
2. Pizza: Like much of the tri-state area, Jersey City has its share of pizzerias serving up both traditional and innovative pies. Some local favorites are among the best in the state.
3. Diners: New Jersey has its share of classic diners, and Jersey City is no exception. These establishments offer a wide range of American comfort foods.
4. Bakeries: The city has several renowned bakeries offering everything from fresh bread to pastries and cakes. Some have ethnic specialties, reflecting the city’s diverse population.
5. Seafood: Given its location along the Hudson River and near the Atlantic Ocean, Jersey City has some excellent seafood restaurants.
6. Food Markets: Places like the Downtown Jersey City Farmers’ Market offer a range of local produce, gourmet foods, and artisanal products.
7. Food Festivals: Jersey City hosts various food festivals throughout the year, celebrating everything from specific cuisines to local produce.
8. Craft Breweries and Distilleries: The craft beverage scene has been growing in Jersey City, with local breweries and distilleries offering unique drinks.

Discovering Unique Restaurants in New Jersey: Recap

New Jersey truly is a culinary playground. From the celestial-themed Solar Saloon in Montclair to the time-traveling charm of Timeless Teahouse in Asbury Park, there are unique places to eat in NJ that are as diverse as they are delightful. Each restaurant we’ve explored brings its own unique flavor and ambiance, ensuring that every visit is memorable.

The Garden State boasts eateries that cater to every palate and pocket. Craving a taste of the Sahara in the heart of the city? Desert Dreams Café in Hoboken has you covered. Looking for a touch of Venetian romance without the transatlantic flight? The Golden Gondola in Trenton offers just that. And let’s not forget Alpine Atrium in Newark, where nature and gourmet dining merge seamlessly.

New Jersey’s dining scene showcases its rich cultural tapestry. There’s something for everyone, from those on a budget to those looking to splurge on a special occasion. With such a vast array of unique dining options, one thing’s for sure: every meal in New Jersey promises to be an adventure.