Looking for a unique place to stay in New Jersey? This small but mighty state is packed with hidden gems, from cozy beachside cottages to luxurious cabins in the woods. I’ve been to every corner of New Jersey and explored its best stays firsthand. Whether you’re craving the charm of a coastal escape or the thrill of a lakefront retreat, I’ve got the top picks to make your stay unforgettable.
Here’s the kicker: while Airbnb has some great options, I dug into other vacation rental platforms like Vrbo and more to find better deals where possible. These 12 amazing rentals are the best of the best, offering both unique experiences and better value. So if you’re ready for a New Jersey adventure in 2025, these are the stays that deliver the vibe, comfort, and price you’re looking for.
The Coolest Airbnbs in New Jersey: Top Vacation Rentals in 2025
Here are the best Airbnbs in New Jersey by category, taking into account different amenities, trip types, and budgets. The subsequent sections will cover each listing in more detail.
- Top Airbnb in New Jersey: Sunset Bay Vacation Home
- Best Luxury Mansion Vacation Rental New Jersey: Mansion on the Beach
- Top Romantic Airbnb in New Jersey: Jersey Shore Beach House Rental
- Best New Jersey Airbnb for Large Groups: Ultimate Pool House
- Coolest Cheap Airbnb in NJ: Budget Friendly House in Union City
- Best Beach House Airbnb in New Jersey: Deluxe Beach House on the Ocean
- Top Airbnb New Jersey with a Pool: Modern Home for Rent with Heated Pool
- Coolest Cabin Rental in NJ: Quiet Log Cabin
- Most Unique Airbnb in New Jersey: Cape May Beachfront House for Rent
11 Best Airbnbs in New Jersey
If romantic condos, cabins, houses for rent, and luxury vacation rentals in New Jersey all sound good to you, get excited! Below are some of the most unique stays in New Jersey:
1. The Lake Glenwood A-Frame Cabin
- 📍 Location: Sussex
- 💵 Price Per Night: $327/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Game room, Breo fire pit, pet-friendly, wraparound deck
- 🌟 Perfect For: Skiers ⛷️, lake lovers 🚣, small families 👨👩👧👦, remote workers 💻
I couldn’t write a list of the best Airbnbs in New Jersey without including this classic A-frame cabin at Lake Glenwood. It sleeps six across two bedrooms plus a loft, with a wraparound deck for lake views and a fire pit and game room for relaxing nights.
This cabin works well year-round. You can hit the slopes at nearby Mountain Creek in winter or enjoy boating and hiking when the weather warms up. The fully equipped kitchen and smart TVs make downtime easy.
When you’re ready to explore, check out Wawayanda State Park for lakeside trails. For dinner, I always stop at The Farmstead in Vernon because their farm-to-table dishes are some of the best in the area.
Before you book anything, don’t miss these deals 👇
- ✈️ Find cheap flights you won't see on Google - Going.com saves me $200+ per ticket
- 🏨 Book your stay – The best 2025 deals on boutique hotels and vacation homes
2. Spectacular Oceanfront Home
- 📍 Location: Harvey Cedars
- 💵 Price Per Night: $2,714/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 16 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Direct beach access, rooftop deck, hot tub, Sonos on every deck
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, beach lovers 🏖️, reunion trips 🎉
If oceanfront views are at the top of your wishlist, this Harvey Cedars home is the one to book. It sits directly on the sand with three decks facing the water, including a rooftop for sunrise coffee or sunset cocktails.
The house sleeps 16 and was built for family gatherings. There are six bedrooms, including three master suites for the adults and bunk rooms the kids will love. You’ll find a hot tub, two wet bars, and Sonos speakers on every deck. The top floor has a big kitchen and great room designed to keep the views front and center.
When you’re ready to explore, grab dinner at Black Eyed Susans or ice cream at Neptune Market. The Harvey Cedars Bay Park is just two blocks away and has tennis courts, a crabbing dock, and unbeatable sunset views.
3. The Historic Lakeside Mansion
- 📍 Location: Trenton
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,536/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 25 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private lake, 10,000 sq ft historic mansion, pool, tennis court
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family reunions 👨👩👧👦, history buffs 🏰, large groups 🎉
If you’ve ever wanted to stay in a historic mansion with its own private lake, this spot near Trenton is calling your name! Built in 1775, it’s packed with old-world charm but comes with a pool, hot tub, and even a theater room.
There’s room for the whole crew here. The house sleeps up to 25 with eight bedrooms, two kids’ playrooms, and plenty of cozy gathering spaces. You’ll also find a greenhouse, a library, and a full bar. Outside, guests can enjoy tennis, pickleball, a beach area, and nature trails right on the property.
For local eats, I recommend Pat’s Original Diner for breakfast or Blooming Grove Inn for dinner. Sesame Place is just 11 minutes away if you’re bringing the kids, and Rosedale Park is great for a scenic hike.
- Read More: 12 Epic Things to Do in New Jersey at Night
4. The Brigantine Beach Mansion
- 📍 Location: Brigantine
- 💵 Price Per Night: $1,307/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 18 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Rooftop deck, private pool, glass elevator
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, beach lovers 🏖️, special gatherings 🎉
Looking for a Brigantine beach house that fits your whole crew and feels like a private resort? This eight-bedroom mansion is it! Every bedroom has its own bathroom, so no one’s stuck waiting in line after a beach day.
The setup is perfect for large families or multigenerational groups. There’s a private pool, a rooftop deck for sunset cocktails, and even a glass elevator. The gourmet kitchen has two Sub-Zero fridges and a massive breakfast bar, and the side yard has its own putting green for post-dinner games.
✈️ Pro Travel Tip:
I use Going.com to find crazy flight deals...($300 roundtrip to Europe kind of crazy).
It’s free, and I honestly check it more than Google Flights. For a limited time only, they are offering 25% off on Premium and Elite to readers of my website, using my special code: JON25)
You’re one block from Brigantine Beach, and I recommend grabbing lunch at Pirate’s Den or swinging by La Scala’s Beach House for dinner. Atlantic City’s casinos and boardwalk are just a 10-minute drive if you want a change of pace.
- Read More: 20 Fun & Unique Restaurants in New Jersey
5. Beach House Retreats
- 📍 Location: Beach Haven Crest
- 💵 Price Per Night: $2,807/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 27 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Rooftop hot tub, massive kitchen, multiple gathering areas
- 🌟 Perfect For: Family reunions 👨👩👧👦, beach getaways 🏖️, milestone celebrations 🎉
This is the kind of beach house where game nights turn into family traditions. With room for 27, it’s one of the most group-friendly stays on Long Beach Island.
The setup is built for big gatherings. There’s a massive kitchen with a Thermador range, backyard grills for post-beach barbecues, and a giant dining table that seats 20. You’ll also find a rooftop deck with a hot tub for sunset hangs, plus ocean and bay views. Bonus: you’re just three houses from the sand, so beach days are basically mandatory.
While you’re here, grab ice cream at Skipper Dipper, pick up fresh seafood from Pinky’s Shrimp, and don’t miss the pizza at Vita! Liberta!. If you need beach gear or rentals, Brighton Beach Surf Shop is just a block away.
- Read More: 12 Bucket List-Worthy Places in New Jersey
6. Water Gap Log House
- 📍 Location: Knowlton Township
- 💵 Price Per Night: $705/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 18 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Hot tub, glass game room, modern kitchen, bunk room with tipi tents
- 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨👩👧👦, reunions 🎉, mountain escapes 🌄
This log house has the kind of setup that makes family weekends effortless and fun. It sleeps 18 comfortably, with bunk beds and toys for the kids and plenty of space for the adults to unwind.
There’s a hot tub on the deck, a fully stocked game room with pool and shuffleboard, and a giant kitchen for big group dinners. Parents will appreciate the toddler-safe layout, and kids will love the teepees in the bunk room. It’s the kind of cabin where you’ll want to stay up late playing games, then sip coffee in the morning while watching the mountains wake up.
While you’re here, stop by Brook Hollow Winery for a tasting, or take the kids to Land of Make Believe in nearby Hope. For fresh produce, I recommend Race Farm Market, just a few minutes away.
7. Cozy Cape May Cottage
- 📍 Location: Cape May
- 💵 Price Per Night: $190/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 2 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Dog-friendly, private fenced yard, outdoor shower, beach passes
- 🌟 Perfect For: Couples 💑, pet owners 🐾, beach lovers 🏖️
If you’re dreaming of a quiet Cape May getaway with your dog, this cozy backyard cottage is the spot. It’s just the right size for two, with a private fenced yard and everything you need for a no-fuss beach trip.
The cottage has a queen bed, a full kitchen, air conditioning, and Wi-Fi. You’ll also get two bikes, two beach chairs, and beach passes. There’s even an outdoor shower, which is perfect after a sandy day on the shore.
When you’re ready to explore, grab breakfast at Bella Vida Café, then bike over to Sunset Beach to catch the evening flag ceremony. I always stop at West End Garage for local art and vintage finds. It’s just a few minutes away and worth the trip!
8. Jersey Shore Escape
- 📍 Location: Lavallette
- 💵 Price Per Night: $295/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Oceanfront access, 1-min walk to private beach, balcony
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨👩👧👦, beach lovers 🏖️, group getaways 🌅
If your idea of vacation is rolling out of bed and straight onto the sand, this Lavallette beach house has you covered. It’s literally steps from the dunes, tucked at the end of a quiet street with its own private beach access.
The house sleeps eight across four bedrooms, with plenty of room for families or friends. There’s a full kitchen, two baths, and a private balcony where you can sip coffee while the waves roll in. It’s simple, relaxed, and all about location.
For a low-key afternoon, swing by The Music Man Singing Ice Cream Shoppe for dessert and a show, then grab fresh seafood at Lenny’s Pizza & Italian Grill. If you need supplies, Ortley Beach Supermarket is just ten minutes away.
9. Beachfront Beauty
- 📍 Location: Sea Isle City
- 💵 Price Per Night: $516/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 9 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Direct beach access, unobstructed ocean views, furnished deck
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨👩👧👦, beach lovers 🏄♀️, friend groups 🎉
I couldn’t write a list of the best New Jersey beach houses without including this one! This Sea Isle City stay puts you right on the sand with incredible ocean views from the top-floor living space.
The home sleeps nine with four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and a deck perfect for catching sunrise. There’s a full kitchen, gas fireplace, outdoor shower, and parking for four cars. It’s a great spot for families or groups who want a classic Jersey Shore experience without the crowds.
When you’re ready to explore, walk to Marita’s Homemade Ice Cream or grab fresh seafood at Mike’s Seafood & Dock Restaurant. Dealy Field is just down the street too, with tennis courts, a playground, and a skate park.
10. Bayfront Private Retreat
- 📍 Location: Middle Township
- 💵 Price Per Night: $503/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: Private bayfront deck, sunset views, fishing off the deck
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨👩👧👦, nature lovers 🐚, fishing enthusiasts 🎣, sunset chasers 🌅
If you love peaceful water views and local wildlife, this Reeds Beach bayfront house is calling your name! It’s the kind of spot where you can sip coffee while watching herons glide by, then cast a fishing line right off the deck.
The house sleeps eight with five bedrooms, three baths, and plenty of space to spread out. There’s also kayaks, bikes, fishing gear, and a paddleboard ready to go, plus incredible sunset views from the deck and balcony.
For a fun day trip, head to Stone Harbor or Avalon for boutique shopping and beach time. I also recommend checking out the Cape May County Zoo (it’s free) or grabbing dinner at The Lobster House in nearby Cape May.
- Read next: Most Unique Rentals in San Francisco
11. Beach Block Getaway
- 📍 Location: Brigantine
- 💵 Price Per Night: $518/night
- 🛏️ Sleeps: 7 guests
- 🔥 Unique Features: 450 sq ft deck, sunrise viewing deck, hot tub, 8 bikes, beach gear
- 🌟 Perfect For: Families 🏖️, beach lovers ☀️, weekend getaways 🚲
If you’re dreaming of a Jersey Shore escape that’s all about decks, ocean breezes, and easy beach days, this Brigantine home nails it! It’s just one block from the sand, with multiple outdoor spaces for morning coffee, happy hour, or sunset yoga.
The house sleeps seven with three comfy bedrooms, plus an open-concept living space upstairs that’s perfect for family hangouts. You’ll have bikes, beach chairs, yard games, and even a hot tub ready to go. Bonus: the beach here is extra wide thanks to a recent replenishment project.
For dinner, grab seafood at Hoopers or head into Atlantic City for a night out since it’s just a 10-minute drive. If you’d rather keep things low-key, bike to Pirate’s Den for breakfast. Their pancakes are legendary.
Coolest Airbnbs in New Jersey: Apartments, Mansions, Houses for Rent + More
Have you ever stayed in a unique Airbnb vacation rental in New Jersey? Definitely let me know! As I’m always looking to add to this list of the best Airbnbs in New Jersey!
Considering other unique destinations in the US? Here are some ideas:
– Top Vacation Stays in Vermont
– Half Moon Bay Vacation Getaway
– Best Places to Stay in Jackson Hole, WY
– Unique Airbnb Rentals in Colorado
– Coolest Places in the Berkshires MA
– Vacation Rentals in the White Mountains
– Unique Stays around New England
Need help planning your trip? Check out these helpful links:
- ✈️ Find cheap flights – I save $10k per year on flights thanks to this tool
- 🏨 Book accommodations – My favorite platform for boutique hotels and budget stays
- 🚗 Compare rental car prices – Great rates from trusted companies
- 🎟️ Discover affordable tours and day trips – Skip the line and explore more
