12 Best Places to Live in Long Island for the Highest Quality of Life

Jon Miksis Jon Miksis clock Updated December 31, 2023 tourism Dream Destinations
by Jem
This post may have affiliate links, where I may receive a commission if you purchase through them. Here's my Disclosure and Privacy Policy for more info.

Long Island is more than just a place. It’s a lifestyle. Here, you’ll find everything from beautiful beaches to quaint villages and lively towns. Long Island offers a wide range of living styles. But with so many choices, picking the right spot can be hard. That’s why I made this guide to the best places to live in Long Island.

I’ve spent years getting to know Long Island. It’s full of surprises. You have peaceful beaches in the North Fork and busy streets in Huntington. There’s the academic buzz of Stony Brook and the calm of Plainview. Whether you love the beach, want a family-friendly suburb, or fancy an upscale area, Long Island has lots of beautiful places.

So, where should you start? Everyone has their own dream spot. Maybe you want to be near the beach, or good schools are important, or you want a strong community.

Join me as I show you Long Island’s best spots. Based on what I’ve learned and seen, I’ll help you find the perfect place. I’ve analyzed stats and local opinions to make a list for all kinds of lives and budgets. Let’s start this adventure!

The top places to live in Long Island for all

The Best Places to Live in Long Island       

Curious about the most beautiful places to live in Long Island? When you go to New York, Long Island caters to a diverse array of preferences. Keep reading to find out about the top living spots in Long Island.

Looking for the perfect home in Long Island? Whatever your needs, Long Island has the right spot for you.

  • Best for academic vibrancy: Stony Brook
  • Best for family-friendly suburban living: Plainview
  • Best for educational excellence: Massapequa
  • Best for a close-knit community: Smithtown
  • Best for sports lovers: Commack
  • Best for seaside charm: Greenport
  • Best for community spirit: Northport
  • Best for community-centered lifestyle: Bellmore
  • Best for upscale living: Manhasset
  • Best for vibrant nightlife: Huntington
  • Best for cultural richness: Great Neck
  • Best for serene beaches: Merrick

Here are the best places in Long Island that you should know about:

1. Stony Brook

Imagine a quaint village where academic vibrancy meets coastal charm. That’s Stony Brook, a gem on Long Island’s north shore. Here, the blend of historic sites, nature preserves, and a bustling university campus creates a unique community vibe.

Stony Brook’s heart beats around its university, fostering a culturally rich environment. Art galleries, museums, and a regular calendar of events make it a best place to live in Long Island for those who love an intellectually stimulating atmosphere. Yet, it’s not all about academia. The serene Avalon Park and Preserve offers a peaceful retreat, with trails meandering through forests and gardens.

In Stony Brook, the housing market caters to diverse preferences, from charming family homes to modern apartments. This balance of educational richness, natural beauty, and community spirit solidifies it as the best city to live in Long Island. Here, every stroll through its historic streets or along the harbor feels like stepping into a living postcard.

Stony Brook, one of the best places to live on Long Island, is a charming community where intellectual vibrancy and seaside charm combine.
Stony Brook, one of the best places to live on Long Island, is an idyllic town where logical vibrancy and seaside charm merge.

2. Plainview

A suburban dream with a twist of luxury, Plainview is more than meets the eye. This neighborhood boasts lush parks, low crime rates, and top-notch amenities, painting a picture of the ideal family-friendly suburb.

Plainview’s reputation for excellence isn’t accidental. Its schools rank among the best, creating a strong educational foundation for the community. Moreover, accessibility is a breeze, with the Long Island Expressway and mass transit options just a stone’s throw away, making it one of the coolest places to live in Long Island for commuters.

The area’s affluence is visible in its well-maintained streets and vibrant local businesses. Yet, Plainview retains a warm, neighborly feel, where community ties are strong and the welcome is always warm. Residents relish in a balanced lifestyle where both convenience and charm coexist.

Here, every day is an opportunity to experience the best of suburban living. Plainview, undeniably, stands out as one of Long Island’s best cities to live, offering a slice of heaven on New York’s doorstep.

Plainview is beyond what first meets the eye—it's a luxurious suburban dream come true.
One of Long Island’s greatest places to reside is Plainview, which provides a taste of the good life close to New York.

3. Massapequa

Welcome to a neighborhood where young families thrive and nature’s beauty is a backdrop to everyday life. Massapequa is a unique blend of educational excellence and outdoor adventures, making it a paradise for those seeking a dynamic suburban lifestyle.

This famous suburb isn’t just about its six elementary schools and high-ranking high schools. It’s a community that values education and offers a wealth of programs for students aspiring to excel. The commitment to learning here makes Massapequa one of the best places in Long Island to live for families.

Beyond the classrooms, the local parks with their splendid trails and the popular Massapequa Cove offer endless opportunities for fishing and outdoor fun. This blend of education and nature creates a vibrant, wholesome environment.

Massapequa’s affluence is evident not only in its educational opportunities but also in its array of recreational activities. This suburb truly offers the finer things in life, proving itself as a nice city to live in Long Island for those who value a balanced, enriching lifestyle.

Massapequa is one of the best places to live on Long Island due to its exceptional combination of recreation and excellent schools.
Massapequa is one of the best places to live on Long Island due to its exceptional combination of recreation and excellent schools.

4. Smithtown

Nestled fifty miles from the hustle of New York City, Smithtown emerges as a quintessential example of Main Street America. Here, a sense of community and small-town charm blends seamlessly with modern living, offering a unique lifestyle experience.

Smithtown is a town where neighbors know each other and work together towards a brighter future. Its streets are lined with quaint shops and restaurants, creating a vibrant local culture that’s all about connection and community spirit. This warm, inclusive atmosphere makes it the best place to live in Long Island for those seeking a close-knit community.

The town’s affinity for craft beer is evident in spots like Tap & Barrel, boasting a selection of over 50 beers. This love for the local and artisanal is a thread that runs through every aspect of Smithtown life.

Smithtown isn’t just a place; it’s a community that embodies the spirit of togetherness. Its blend of friendliness, local charm, and modern amenities makes it an irresistible choice for anyone pondering where to live in Long Island. Here, you’re not just finding a home; you’re becoming part of a story.

Smithtown comes out as a classic illustration of Main Street America, making it one of the best places to live in Long Island.
Smithtown comes out as a classic illustration of Main Street America, making it one of the best places to live in Long Island.

5. Commack

Envision a suburb where the spirit of competition and camaraderie thrives. Commack is a place that blends a love for sports with an engaging community atmosphere, making it an exciting and vibrant place to call home.

Known for its athletic zeal, Commack was once home to the Long Island Arena, and its legacy lives on in the community’s passion for sports and recreation. This city-suburb is a magnet for sports enthusiasts and those who enjoy a healthy, active lifestyle. It’s this blend of vigor and community that places Commack among the good places to live in New York.

Commack isn’t just about sports; it’s a hub for networking and cultural exchanges. The presence of notable personalities and a diverse community adds a dynamic layer to life here. Engaging local events and activities ensure there’s always something to do or someone interesting to meet.

This suburb strikes the perfect balance between a lively social atmosphere and the comforts of suburban living, making it one of the best Long Island cities. In Commack, life is an exciting game, and everyone’s a part of the team.

Commack is a center for networking and cross-cultural interactions in addition to athletics.
Commack is a center for networking and cross-cultural interactions in addition to athletics. | Image Credit: Zillow

6. Greenport

Step into Greenport, where the charm of maritime life is ever-present. This vibrant port town on the North Fork of Long Island is a haven for lovers of the sea, fine dining, and rich history.

In Greenport, every day feels like a nautical adventure. The maritime heritage is evident in its picturesque marinas, historic shipyards, and the iconic Greenport Carousel. The town’s bustling Main Street, with its array of unique shops and gourmet restaurants, is a delight for both locals and visitors. This blend of historical allure and modern amenities makes Greenport one of the best areas to live in Long Island.

The town also boasts a lively arts scene, with galleries and theaters showcasing local talent. Festivals and events throughout the year keep the community spirit alive and buzzing.

Greenport offers a lifestyle where tranquility and vibrancy coexist, making it one of the nice parts of Long Island to call home. Whether it’s savoring fresh seafood by the water or enjoying a sunset sail, life here is an endless array of picturesque moments.

Greenport is one of the nicer areas of Long Island to call home since it provides a lifestyle where vitality and quiet combine.
Greenport is one of the nicer areas of Long Island to call home since it provides a lifestyle where vitality and quiet combine.

7. Northport

Discover Northport, a picturesque village where the essence of coastal living and artistic flair come together. This charming locale on Long Island’s north shore is a treasure trove for those who appreciate the arts, nature, and a close-knit community feel.

Northport’s scenic harbor sets the stage for its vibrant downtown area, bustling with quaint shops, galleries, and eateries. The village’s commitment to preserving its rich cultural heritage and nurturing the arts is evident in its popular theater and frequent community events. This artistic heart makes Northport stand out as a great place to live in Long Island.

Nature enthusiasts revel in Northport’s parks and beaches, where tranquility and outdoor activities abound. Whether it’s kayaking on the calm waters or strolling through verdant paths, there’s a sense of peace and adventure here.

With its enchanting blend of natural beauty, artistic culture, and community warmth, Northport truly embodies where is the best place to live in Long Island. It’s a locale where every day is an opportunity to immerse oneself in a life of artistic inspiration and serene coastal living.

Northport is the ideal Long Island community to live in with its enticing fusion of scenic beauty, creative culture, and friendly locals.
Northport is the ideal Long Island community to live in with its enticing fusion of scenic beauty, creative culture, and friendly locals.

8. Bellmore

Bellmore invites you into a world where suburban tranquility and community vibrancy coalesce beautifully. This friendly neighborhood in Nassau County is renowned for its welcoming spirit and family-friendly atmosphere.

The essence of Bellmore is in its community-centered lifestyle. Residents take pride in their local events, from street fairs to outdoor concerts, creating a bond that’s palpable throughout the neighborhood. This sense of community, coupled with excellent schools and parks, places Bellmore among the Long Island’s best places to live.

For the gastronomically inclined, Bellmore’s array of eateries offers a taste of local and international flavors. The neighborhood’s commitment to fostering a warm, inclusive environment extends to its vibrant dining scene.

Living in Bellmore is about enjoying the best of both worlds – the peace of suburban life with a dash of excitement. It represents the essence of most livable cities in Long Island, where life is celebrated in its streets, parks, and community gatherings.

Bellmore offers you a world where communal energy and suburbia peace coexist harmoniously.
Bellmore offers you a world where communal energy and suburbia peace coexist harmoniously.

9. Manhasset

In Manhasset, a blend of luxury and community spirit creates a living experience like no other. This upscale hamlet on Long Island’s North Shore is synonymous with refined living, offering a lifestyle that many dream of but few attain.

Manhasset’s allure lies in its elegant neighborhoods and premier shopping destinations, like the famed Americana Manhasset. The hamlet is a shopping mecca for those who appreciate high-end brands and bespoke experiences. This luxury, combined with beautiful parks and a strong sense of community, makes Manhasset one of the best cities to live in Long Island.

Yet, Manhasset isn’t just about luxury. It’s a place where community ties are strong, and local traditions are cherished. Annual events and gatherings are a testament to the hamlet’s vibrant community spirit.

Manhasset represents a perfect marriage of sophistication and community warmth, embodying what are the best places to live in Long Island. For those seeking an upscale yet grounded lifestyle, Manhasset offers an unparalleled living experience.

Manhasset epitomizes the best places to live on Long Island, offering the ideal balance of refinement and small-town charm.
Manhasset epitomizes the best places to live on Long Island, offering the ideal balance of refinement and small-town charm.

10. Huntington

Venture into Huntington, where the vibrancy of a town meets the charm of Long Island’s Suffolk County. This bustling area, one of the largest in Suffolk, is a mosaic of minor neighborhoods, each with its unique flair and attractions.

Huntington’s draw is its eclectic mix of nightlife, gourmet food, and music scenes, appealing to a wide range of tastes and preferences. This variety, coupled with top-notch schools and family-friendly locales, makes Huntington a microcosm of the best suburban life has to offer. It’s a place where one can enjoy the glitz of a night out and the quiet of a suburban retreat, solidifying its place as one of the best Long Island towns to live.

The town’s appeal extends beyond its amenities. Huntington is a community where cultural events and outdoor activities are a part of daily life. From art exhibitions to community parks, there’s always something to explore and enjoy.

Huntington is a tapestry of experiences, making it among the ideal places to move in Long Island. Its ability to offer something for everyone, from nightlife enthusiasts to families, makes it a standout destination in the Long Island landscape.

Explore Huntington, where the charm of Suffolk County, Long Island, melds with the energy of a town.
Being a patchwork of experiences, Huntington is one of the best places on Long Island to relocate.

11. Great Neck

A tapestry of culture, history, and modern elegance, Great Neck stands out as a distinctive area in Long Island. Located on the North Shore of Long Island, this area offers a lifestyle that blends the best of suburban comfort with the allure of upscale living.

The spirit of Great Neck is captured in its diverse community and rich cultural backdrop. Theaters, art galleries, and historical sites dot the landscape, offering residents a daily immersion in culture and history. This cultural richness, combined with top-tier schools and lush parks, makes Great Neck one of the best towns to live in Long Island.

But it’s not just about culture. Great Neck’s dining scene is a culinary adventure, offering flavors from around the world. The neighborhood’s commitment to diversity and quality is evident in every aspect of community life.

In Great Neck, every day is an opportunity to experience a life that’s both enriching and comfortable. It stands as a where to live in LI for those who value a community that’s as diverse and dynamic as it is tranquil and homely.

A unique region of Long Island, Great Neck is a patchwork of culture, history, and contemporary elegance.
A unique region of Long Island, Great Neck is a patchwork of culture, history, and contemporary elegance.

12. Merrick

Merrick unfolds as a suburban sanctuary, offering a blend of seaside charm and community warmth. This Nassau County gem is a captivating mix of tranquil residential life and vibrant local culture.

In Merrick, the allure is in its serene beaches and picturesque parks, making it an ideal retreat for nature lovers and families alike. The community thrives on its strong bonds, evident in local gatherings and events that bring residents together. This harmonious blend of natural beauty and community spirit places Merrick among the top cities in Long Island to live.

The town’s dining scene reflects its coastal setting, with seafood restaurants offering fresh, local catches. Beyond the culinary delights, Merrick’s array of shops and community centers adds to its appeal, providing everything one needs within a close-knit environment.

Living in Merrick means embracing a lifestyle where peace and activity harmoniously coexist. It’s a place that proudly stands as one of the best Long Island cities, where life’s pace is just right – energetic yet relaxing, making every day in Merrick a delightful experience.

Merrick emerges as a suburban haven that provides a harmonious combination of coastal allure and neighborhood coziness.
Merrick emerges as a suburban haven that provides a harmonious combination of coastal allure and neighborhood coziness.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About the Best Places to Live in Long Island                 

Want to learn more about the top living spots in Long Island? Below, I’ve compiled some frequently asked questions about the best places to live in Long Island.

Where is the best place to live in Long Island?

The best place to live in Long Island really depends on your lifestyle preferences. For those seeking a blend of suburban comfort and easy access to beaches, Stony Brook and Northport are excellent choices. Plainview and Commack offer great schools and community spirit, ideal for families.

If you’re drawn to upscale living with a vibrant cultural scene, Manhasset and Great Neck stand out. For a more laid-back, seaside vibe, consider Greenport or Merrick. Each area has its unique charm, making Long Island a region with diverse, appealing options for different tastes and needs.

What is the safest community on Long Island?

When it comes to safety, Plainview is often highlighted as one of the safest communities on Long Island. Known for its low crime rates, Plainview offers a secure environment, making it a top choice for families and individuals seeking peace of mind.

The community’s commitment to safety is complemented by its excellent schools and family-friendly amenities. Additionally, places like Smithtown and Manhasset, with their strong community ties and proactive approach to safety, also rank high in terms of security and comfort.

Where is it affordable to live on Long Island?

Affordability on Long Island varies, but certain areas stand out for their more budget-friendly living options. Bellmore and Merrick offer a balance of affordability and quality of life, making them attractive for those seeking value without compromising on community amenities.

For those who don’t mind a bit more distance from New York City, Greenport presents a cost-effective option with its charming maritime character. It’s also worth exploring areas like Commack and Smithtown, where reasonable housing prices can be found, especially when compared to the higher-cost neighborhoods on the Island.

Long Island, it is evident that this area provides a special fusion of convenience, charm, and community.
Long Island, it is evident that this area provides a special fusion of convenience, charm, and community.

Is Long Island a good place to live in?

Absolutely, Long Island is a fantastic place to live. Its diversity in neighborhoods, from bustling suburbs to serene coastal towns, offers something for everyone. Areas like Stony Brook and Manhasset provide excellent education and cultural experiences, while Greenport and Northport offer a relaxing seaside lifestyle.

Long Island is also known for its safety, quality of life, and community spirit, seen in places like Plainview and Smithtown. With its proximity to New York City, residents enjoy the perks of urban life without sacrificing the comfort and space of suburban living. Whether you’re seeking vibrant community life, peaceful retreats, or a family-friendly environment, Long Island delivers.

Where not to live on Long Island?

While most of Long Island offers great living options, there are a few areas that might not be ideal for everyone. This can depend on factors like budget constraints, lifestyle preferences, or commute requirements. For instance, areas closer to New York City can be pricier, which might not suit those looking for more affordable living options.

Some might find the bustling atmosphere of the more urban areas less appealing than the quieter, more suburban parts. Additionally, certain neighborhoods might have higher traffic or fewer public amenities, which could be a downside for some. It’s important to research and consider what aspects of living are most important to you before deciding on a specific area.

Is Long Island safer than NYC?

Generally, Long Island is considered safer than New York City. This perception is largely due to Long Island’s lower crime rates compared to NYC. Areas like Plainview, Smithtown, and Manhasset are particularly noted for their safety and family-friendly environments. However, it’s important to recognize that safety can vary from neighborhood to neighborhood.

Long Island’s suburban settings often contribute to a sense of security and community cohesion, which can differ from the more urban and densely populated areas of New York City. Each area has its unique characteristics, so consider specific needs and preferences when comparing safety between Long Island and NYC.

Final Thoughts on the Best Places to Live in Long Island    

As we wrap up our journey across Long Island, it’s clear that this region offers a unique blend of charm, community, and convenience. Whether it’s the serene shores of the North Fork, the bustling streets of Huntington, or the scholarly vibe of Stony Brook, Long Island presents a living tapestry rich in diversity. Each neighborhood has its own personality, catering to different lifestyles and dreams.

In Long Island, you find more than just a place to live; you discover a place to belong. From family-friendly suburbs to upscale enclaves, this region invites you to be part of a community that aligns with your lifestyle and aspirations. So, whether you’re seeking a peaceful seaside retreat or a vibrant suburban life, Long Island stands ready to welcome you.

Thank you for joining me on this exploration of Long Island’s best places to live. I hope this guide helps you find your perfect spot in this diverse and dynamic region. Here’s to finding your place in Long Island, where every neighborhood tells a story, and every resident is part of a larger community tapestry.

The top places to live in Long Island right now
The top places to live in Long Island right now

You may also like

Leave a Comment