Ready to explore Long Island’s best eateries? It’s a wild mix of fresh seafood, cool diners, and surprises at every turn. Let’s dig into the most unique restaurants in Long Island, NY!
Ready to spice up your Long Island adventure with some epic eats? This place isn’t just about sun, sand, and surf. It’s a playground for your taste buds, showcasing the culinary diversity found in islands in New York, with a lineup of eateries that are as unique as they are delicious.
From cozy nooks serving up local seafood to buzzing spots with international flair, there are plenty of unique places to eat on Long Island, a New York gem. And I’m not just talking about good food – these places are experiences in themselves. We’re going to dive into spots that are not only about satisfying your hunger but also about creating stories you’ll love to share.
So, grab your appetite, and let’s explore 12 of the unique restaurants in Long Island. I’m taking you to LI’s coolest, quirkiest, and most unforgettable dining destinations. Trust me, you’re in for some serious treats!
Unique Restaurants in Long Island
Long Island’s unique restaurants offer a feast for the senses, blending delicious flavors with unforgettable atmospheres. From dining in historic speakeasies to enjoying cuisines from Germany and Eastern Europe, Long Island’s food scene is simply incredible. Dive into this journey of taste and discover the hidden gems in Long Island that make dining truly special!
1. Plattduetsche Park
First stop on our list of Long Island’s unique restaurants is Plattduetsche Park in Franklin Square. Established in 1939, this spot is all about bringing authentic German flavors to the table. Here, you can indulge in classic dishes like bratwursts and schnitzels, perfectly paired with a wide selection of German beers.
But Plattduetsche Park is more than a restaurant. It’s a lively cultural venue, hosting events that showcase the best of German traditions. Whether it’s their renowned Oktoberfest or an evening filled with energetic live music, this place keeps the spirit of Germany alive in Long Island.
One of my favorite things about Plattduetsche Park is its blend of affordability and authenticity. You get to immerse yourself in a genuine German experience without stretching your budget.
I highly recommend keeping an eye on their event calendar. Timing your visit with one of their festive events elevates the whole experience!
2. Charlotte’s Speakeasy
Next up is Charlotte’s Speakeasy in Farmingdale, a hidden gem that takes you back to the roaring 1920s. This place is all about the Prohibition era, complete with a secret entrance and an ambiance that screams Gatsby-style parties. It’s one of the most fun restaurants in Long Island where history meets modern dining.
Once inside, you’re greeted by a world of vintage charm. The menu offers a mix of contemporary American cuisine, and their cocktails are a nod to the past, each with its own twist. The live jazz music adds to the speakeasy vibe, which makes your dining experience both immersive and entertaining.
Charlotte’s Speakeasy isn’t just for history lovers. It appeals to anyone looking for a dining experience that’s out of the ordinary. The blend of historical intrigue and modern culinary flair makes it a standout destination.
If you’re after a table, remember to book in advance, as this spot is quite the talk of the town. Dress to impress and step back in time for a night of clandestine fun!
3. Witches Brew
If you’re in West Hempstead, Witches Brew is the go-to spot for a truly magical coffee experience. Opened in 1996, this café stands out as one of the most unique places to eat in Long Island, especially for those who love a touch of the mystical in their daily brew.
Witches Brew charms you with its gothic, cozy interior, perfect for those who appreciate a darker, more enchanting aesthetic. The menu is a delightful surprise, featuring an array of vegan and vegetarian options, alongside classic café fare. I recommend trying their homemade mac and cheese, which is also available vegan.
But it’s the coffee that’s the real star here. Each cup is crafted with care, offering a variety of unique blends and flavors. If you’re a coffee aficionado or just in need of a cozy nook to unwind, Witches Brew has you covered.
This café is more than a place for great coffee and food. It’s a little escape into a world that feels like a page from a fantasy novel. So, next time you’re nearby, drop in for a spellbinding experience!
4. JBBQ
Heading over to Shirley, we find JBBQ, a place that redefines barbecue. It’s one of the best places to eat in Long Island for those who crave an interactive dining experience. Here, it’s all about Korean-style barbecue, where you become the chef at your table.
JBBQ’s vibrant atmosphere is matched by its diverse menu. You get to choose from a variety of meats and veggies, then grill them to perfection right at your table. It’s not only a feast for the taste buds but also a fun activity to enjoy with friends or family.
The side dishes, or banchan, are equally impressive, offering a taste of authentic Korean flavors. From kimchi to seasoned soybean sprouts, these small dishes add an extra layer of flavor to your meal.
JBBQ stands out for its unique approach to barbecue dining. It’s a place where food and fun come together, which makes it a must-visit for anyone looking for a lively and delicious experience. Grab your apron and get ready for a barbecue like no other!
5. Standard Rec
Without a doubt, one of the most fun restaurants in Long Island is Standard Rec. Located in Hemptead, this place is a playground for adults who love good food and good fun. Standard Rec blends delicious eats with an arcade experience.
Here, the game is always on, both on the screens and in the arcade section. After savoring their gourmet twists on American pub classics – like their mouth-watering burgers and creative appetizers – you can dive into a world of arcade games, board games, and cards. It’s an unbeatable mix of entertainment and dining.
Standard Rec takes your casual dining experience up a notch. With a variety of craft beers to choose from, you can sip on your favorite brew while challenging friends to a game of Pac-Man or poker. The atmosphere buzzes with energy, which makes it the perfect spot for a lively night out.
This place is more than just a sports bar. It’s a destination where food, sports, and arcade games create a uniquely fun atmosphere. If you’re in Hempstead and looking for a place that offers great food and a great time, Standard Rec is your go-to spot!
6. Betterman Distilling
In the heart of Patchogue, Betterman Distilling is a standout destination for spirit lovers and food enthusiasts alike. This place is redefining the craft distillery scene in Long Island, offering a unique blend of artisanal spirits and delectable eats.
As you step into Betterman Distilling, the vibe is immediately welcoming. The distillery tour is an eye-opener. It’s fascinating to see how they transform simple ingredients into exquisite vodkas and whiskeys. Each sip tells a story of passion and precision.
Let’s not forget the food. Their Charcuterie board is a crowd-pleaser, featuring an array of cheeses and meats that pair beautifully with their spirits. It’s the perfect accompaniment to an evening of relaxed indulgence.
The tasting room is where the fun really begins. With a cocktail menu that showcases their spirits in creative ways, each drink is a delightful surprise. The staff’s expertise adds to the experience, which makes every visit both educational and enjoyable.
Betterman Distilling in Patchogue is a place where fine spirits meet great food in a cozy, inviting setting. It’s definitely a must-visit for anyone looking to explore cool places to eat in Long Island.
7. Birdies Indoor Golf and Cocktail Bar Long Island
Patchogue is home to Birdies Indoor Golf and Cocktail Bar, a place that brilliantly combines sport and dining. One of the unique restaurants in Long Island, this spot is a paradise for golf enthusiasts and food lovers.
Birdies isn’t your average bar. Here, you can enjoy a round of indoor golf, practicing your swing in a fun, relaxed environment. The golf simulators are top-notch, offering a realistic experience that’s both challenging and enjoyable, regardless of your skill level.
The food and drink here are just as impressive as the golf. The menu features a variety of delicious options, perfect for refueling after a game. I recommend the duck empanadas, which are absolutely delicious. Their cocktails are crafted with care, each with a unique twist that complements the overall experience.
What makes Birdies stand out is its ability to offer a complete entertainment package. It’s the ideal spot for a night out with friends, a date, or even a solo visit. The combination of great food, inventive drinks, and indoor golf makes it a must-visit restaurant in Long Island.
If you’re looking for a place that offers fun, food, and golf under one roof, Birdies is your go-to destination!
8. The Village Lanterne
Ever dreamed of a cozy European getaway right in Long Island? The Village Lanterne in Lindenhurst brings that dream to life. This charming spot is one of the unique restaurants in Long Island for those seeking a taste of authentic German cuisine in a quaint, old-world setting.
The Village Lanterne is all about creating an immersive experience. As you step inside, you’re greeted by an ambiance that feels like a traditional German village inn. The warm, inviting decor sets the perfect stage for a memorable meal.
Their menu is a delightful journey through German culinary traditions. From hearty schnitzels to savory sausages, each dish is prepared with a focus on authenticity and flavor. And let’s not forget the beer – their selection of German brews is impressive, offering the perfect pairing for your meal.
What sets The Village Lanterne apart is its commitment to providing a genuine German dining experience. It’s ideal for a family dinner, a romantic evening, or just a casual night out with friends. Get ready to enjoy a slice of Germany in the heart of Long Island!
9. Biscuits & Barbeque
In Mineola, Biscuits & Barbeque is redefining comfort food with a Southern twist. This restaurant has quickly become one of the best places to eat in Long Island for those who love hearty, soul-warming dishes.
Tucked away in a converted diner, Biscuits & Barbeque offers a cozy, unpretentious atmosphere. It’s like stepping into a little slice of the South. The menu is a celebration of classic Southern cuisine, with each dish packed full of flavor. Their biscuits are the talk of the town – flaky, buttery, and just plain delicious.
But the real star here is the barbecue. Slow-cooked to perfection, their meats are tender, juicy, and full of smoky goodness. Pair them with their homemade sides, like mac ‘n’ cheese or collard greens, and you’ve got a meal that feels like a warm hug.
Biscuits & Barbeque is more than a restaurant. It’s a place that brings a sense of Southern hospitality to Long Island. If you’re a barbecue aficionado or just looking for a comforting meal, this spot in Mineola is a must-visit. Trust me, every bite feels like home at this spot!
10. Pierogibites and more
Situated in the heart of Bellmore, Pierogibites and more is a hidden gem that’s all about celebrating Polish & Ukrainian cuisine. Undoubtedly, this quaint spot is one of the unique places to eat in Long Island for its authentic, homemade pierogis and other Eastern European specialties.
Step into Pierogibites and more, and you’re instantly hit with the comforting scent of dough and fillings being lovingly prepared. The ambiance is cozy and unassuming, a perfect backdrop for a culinary adventure. Here, it’s like you’re part of a close-knit family, all gathered around for a traditional meal.
Their pierogis steal the show, each one a little parcel of joy with fillings that range from the classic potato and cheese to inventive creations like sweet potato and marshmallow. They’re cooked to a golden perfection, crispy on the outside and delightfully soft inside. And let’s not overlook their other offerings – from robust kielbasa to heartwarming stews, every dish is a nod to the rich flavors of Poland.
Pierogibites and more is perfect for a casual lunch or a comforting dinner. Here, simplicity meets flavor, offering a unique dining experience in Massapequa. So, for a taste of Eastern Europe without leaving Long Island, this is your go-to spot.
11. Burgerology
Fancy creating your own burger masterpiece? At Burgerology, with locations in Farmingdale, Rockville Centre, Huntington, Patchogue, and Stony Brook in Long Island, you get to do just that. This place isn’t only about serving unique burgers – it’s about letting you become a ‘Burgerologist’ yourself.
The concept is simple and exciting: you get to build your own burger from a variety of fresh ingredients. Choose your patty, pick your toppings, and add sauces to craft a burger that’s uniquely yours. It’s a fun, interactive experience that adds a personal touch to your meal.
Apart from the ‘Be Your Own Burgerologist’ option, their menu features innovative burgers like the Mac Attack Burger. Imagine a juicy beef patty topped with creamy, rich mac ‘n’ cheese – it’s comfort food taken to a whole new level!
Burgerology’s approach to burger-making is all about creativity and quality. Each location offers a lively atmosphere, perfect for a fun meal out with friends or family. With several spots across Long Island, finding your nearest Burgerology for a unique dining experience is easy. For those looking to enjoy the best food in Long Island, Burgerology is a must-visit destination.
12. Big Daddy’s
Last on our list of unique restaurants in Long Island is Big Daddy’s in Massapequa. This place is a celebration of Southern flavors, bringing a taste of New Orleans to the heart of Long Island. It’s where Cajun meets Creole in a vibrant, lively setting.
Big Daddy’s stands out for its authentic Southern cuisine. The menu is a journey through the rich culinary traditions of the South. From spicy jambalaya to succulent gumbo, each dish is bursting with flavor. Their po’boys and étouffée are crowd favorites, transporting diners straight to the bayou.
It’s not just the food that makes Big Daddy’s special. The restaurant’s decor, with its Mardi Gras beads and jazz-themed artwork, adds to the immersive experience. Live music nights further enhance the New Orleans vibe, which makes every visit a mini-celebration.
Big Daddy’s is one of the best places to eat in Long Island for those seeking a festive atmosphere and hearty, flavorful food. It’s the perfect spot to round off our culinary tour of LI, offering a dining experience that’s as unique as it is delicious.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Unique Restaurants in Long Island
Searching for more information to help you decide where to eat in Long Island? Here are some common questions (and answers) I get asked a lot about Long Island’s best restaurants.
What food is Long Island known for?
Long Island is renowned for its seafood, thanks to its extensive coastline. You can’t miss trying the fresh clams, oysters, and the famous Long Island duck. Also, the local wineries are a must-visit, offering some fantastic local wines. For a real taste of the island, I recommend hitting a seafood shack by the shore. There’s nothing like enjoying fresh seafood with a sea breeze!
Does Long Island have restaurant week?
Yes, Long Island has its own Restaurant Week. It usually happens twice a year, once in the spring and once in the fall. During this week, participating restaurants offer special prix-fixe menus. It’s a great opportunity to try out some high-end restaurants at more affordable prices. Keep an eye on their official website for dates and participating restaurants.
Is Long Island famous for seafood?
Absolutely! Long Island’s seafood is a highlight, thanks to its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean. The area is particularly known for its fresh clams, oysters, and scallops. Seafood lovers should definitely check out the restaurants in towns like Oyster Bay and Montauk for some of the freshest catches.
Is it expensive to eat in Long Island?
The cost of eating out in Long Island can vary. You’ll find a range of dining options, from budget-friendly eateries to upscale restaurants. While some high-end places can be pricey, there are plenty of cheap eats in Long Island, especially in casual dining and seafood shacks. My tip: explore local diners and family-run businesses for good value.
What is unusual about Long Island?
Long Island is unique for its diverse range of dining experiences within a relatively small area. You can enjoy everything from beachside seafood shacks to elegant vineyard restaurants. The island’s geography, with its mix of bustling towns and serene coastal areas, also adds to its unique charm. Plus, its rich history is reflected in some of the historic eateries and speakeasies.
