12 Hidden Gems in Key West: Discovering the Island’s Secret Wonders

by Flora
This post may have affiliate links, where I receive a commission if you purchase through them. Here's our Disclosure and Privacy Policy for more info.

Are you looking for the best hidden gems in Key West? Here’s your ultimate guide to the most underrated places in Key West. Get ready to discover Key West off the beaten path.

Welcome to Key West, a tropical paradise with sun-kissed beaches and vibrant streets. But beyond the bustling Duval Street and the famous Sunset Celebration at Mallory Square lies a hidden world, a bundle of secret spots in Key West that even the most seasoned traveler might miss. These are the places where the essence of the island truly shines, away from the crowded tourist trails.

In this journey through Key West’s less traveled roads, we dive into corners that reveal the island’s true character. From serene natural reserves to quaint, historic sites, this guide to the best hidden gems in Key West is your ticket to an unforgettable experience. These destinations make this wondrous destination one of Florida’s must-visit spots.

So, if you’re looking for what to do in Key West that’s off the conventional tourist radar, you’re in the right place. Prepare to discover beautiful destinations in Key West that resonate with the spirit of this stunning island. Let’s embark on a journey to uncover the most unique places to visit in Key West, where every turn is a story waiting to be told and every hidden corner a new possibility.

The best hidden gems in Key West right now

Hidden Gems in Key West

Eager to uncover Key West’s best-kept secrets? As we’ve explored, this island is brimming with destinations beyond the typical tourist spots, appealing to a wide range of interests. From historical landmarks to serene beaches, Key West has much to offer.

Are you seeking quiet beaches for relaxation or historical sites that transport you back in time? Key West caters to various preferences. Dive into this guide to discover the most underrated places in Key West, where every corner is a new adventure waiting to be experienced.

1. The Unmarked Home of Tennessee Williams

If you’re exploring hidden gems in Key West, don’t miss 1431 Duncan St, the former home of Tennessee Williams. It’s a refreshing contrast to the popular Ernest Hemingway House, a must-visit destination in Florida Keys. Tennessee Williams, the iconic playwright, once called this place home, adding a unique literary touch to Key West’s culture.

Located conveniently near downtown, it’s not only easy to reach but also free to enter, making it a perfect choice for budget-conscious visitors. The self-guided nature of the visit allows you to explore at your leisure, adding to its charm.

While discovering Key West's hidden gems, explore 1431 Duncan St, once the residence of Tennessee Williams. | Image Credits: Florida Memory
While discovering Key West’s hidden gems, explore 1431 Duncan St, once the residence of Tennessee Williams. | Image Credits: Florida Memory

For a more intimate experience, I recommend visiting during the early mornings or late afternoons when it’s quieter.

This spot is not just for literary fans but also for those in search of peaceful corners in Key West. It offers a glimpse into a different, more serene side of island life, far from the usual tourist trails.

It’s an excellent choice for travelers looking to explore Key West off the beaten path. Here, you can gain a rare insight into the life of a celebrated writer in a setting that remains untouched by mainstream tourism.

2. Garbo’s Grill

In the heart of Key West, Garbo’s Grill offers a unique culinary adventure. This humble food truck, run by a passionate couple, is famous for its mahi and Korean beef tacos. Located conveniently on Greene St., it’s a short stroll from the well-known Sloppy Joe’s bar.

Garbo’s Grill represents the essence of Key West’s culinary diversity. It serves a blend of local and international flavors that satisfy diverse tastes. Despite limited seating, the food’s exceptional quality compensates. It’s one of the top places to go in Key West for an unforgettable dining experience.

Garbo's Grill excels in Key West's culinary scene, blending traditional and modern flavors. | Image Credits: Garbo's Grill Facebook
Garbo’s Grill excels in Key West’s culinary scene, blending traditional and modern flavors. | Image Credits: Garbo’s Grill Facebook

The menu includes popular items like the renowned tacos and shrimp burritos. Garbo’s Grill, open for both lunch and dinner, is ideal for a quick, flavorful bite. To best enjoy this hidden spot, visit during non-peak hours. It helps avoid the usual crowds and enhances the dining experience.

As a standout in Key West’s hidden culinary scene, Garbo’s Grill is more than a food truck. It’s a journey into the flavors that make Key West special. It displays the island’s flair for combining traditional and modern tastes. This spot is a must-visit for food lovers and those exploring hidden places in Key West.

3. Smathers Beach

For those seeking a peaceful day by the sea, Smathers Beach in Key West is a must-visit destination. This beautiful beach, located on the island’s eastern side, is often overlooked by tourists, making it one of the best secret spots in Key West. Its extended sandy shores provide an ideal setting for sunbathing, picnics, and tranquil strolls.

Smathers Beach is also perfect for water sports. Visitors can indulge in activities like kayaking, paddle boarding, and jet skiing in its clear waters. The beach also offers rental facilities for convenience. Early mornings or late afternoons are optimal times to visit, offering a more intimate beach experience.

Smathers Beach is an ideal spot for engaging in various water sports.
Smathers Beach is an ideal spot for engaging in various water sports.

This spot is easily accessible, with ample parking available. It’s a short drive from downtown Key West, making it a convenient getaway. The beach’s natural beauty is complemented by its well-maintained facilities, including restrooms and shower areas.

Smathers Beach is an ideal location for families, couples, and solo travelers alike. It offers a glimpse into Key West’s natural beauty, away from the crowded tourist spots. This beach is an underrated place in Key West, where visitors can unwind and enjoy the island’s serene side.

4. Key West Cemetery

Discover the intriguing Key West Cemetery, a place that offers a unique viewpoint of the island’s history and culture. Unlike typical tourist destinations, this cemetery is celebrated for its unique epitaphs, echoing the character and humor of Key West’s community.

Located conveniently near the city center, the cemetery provides a quiet escape. It’s a compelling site for history lovers and those interested in Key West’s lesser-known stories. Entry is complimentary, making it an accessible option for all visitors. For a comfortable visit, early mornings or late afternoons are recommended, avoiding the midday sun.

Key West Cemetery offers a unique blend of historical exploration and local pride. | Image Credits: City of Key West Florida
Key West Cemetery offers a unique blend of historical exploration and local pride. | Image Credits: City of Key West Florida

The cemetery’s atmosphere is reflective and serene, allowing visitors to wander among historic tombstones. Each epitaph tells a story, from heartfelt to humorous, offering a personal connection to the past. This site is not only a historical landmark but also a cultural hub, revealing the diverse heritage and enduring spirit of the Key West community.

Visiting the Key West Cemetery is a distinctive experience, combining historical exploration with a sense of local pride. It stands as one of the most unique places to visit in Key West, capturing the essence of the island’s rich tapestry of life and legacy.

5. The Seamonkey Sandbar Charter

Embark on an aquatic adventure with the Seamonkey Sandbar Charter, a highlight among the hidden gems in Key West. This charter is your gateway to exploring the serene sandbars, hidden away in the clear waters surrounding Key West. Ideal for those looking for best things to do in Key West, Seamonkey offers an exceptional experience away from the crowded beaches.

Departing from Key West, the charter provides various options, including half-day and full-day trips. These excursions are perfect for families, groups, or individuals seeking a memorable day on the water. Activities like snorkeling and paddleboarding allow you to engage with the vibrant marine life up close.

Seamonkey Charters ensures a secure and comfortable experience, providing all necessary equipment for your convenience. | Image Credits: Sea Monkey Charters
Seamonkey Charters ensures a secure and comfortable experience, providing all necessary equipment for your convenience. | Image Credits: Sea Monkey Charters

Seamonkey Charters ensures a comfortable and safe experience, providing all necessary gear. Their knowledgeable guides enhance the journey with insights into the local ecosystem. For those planning a visit, booking in advance is recommended, especially during peak season. This charter experience is not just a trip; it’s an exploration of Key West’s hidden natural beauty, offering a blend of adventure and tranquility.

6. Key West’s Shipwreck Museum

Go on a historical journey to the Shipwreck Museum, a standout among Key West’s hidden gems. Situated in the heart of the city, it unveils the daring world of shipwreck salvage operations. This museum is ideal for those seeking unique places in Key West, combining education with immersive storytelling.

The museum’s interactive exhibits bring to life the tales of numerous shipwrecks around the Florida Keys. Displayed artifacts and treasures add to the intrigue. Climbing the lookout tower, guests are treated to stunning views of Key West and its waters, offering a different perspective of the city.

The Shipwreck Museum's storytelling approach engages and makes history accessible to all visitors. | Image Credits: Key West’s Shipwreck Museum
The Shipwreck Museum’s storytelling approach engages and makes history accessible to all visitors. | Image Credits: Key West’s Shipwreck Museum

The museum is easily accessible and caters to a diverse audience, including history enthusiasts and families. Its focus on the lucrative and perilous era of shipwreck salvaging provides insights into a significant part of Key West’s past. The museum’s storytelling approach makes history engaging and accessible to all visitors.

The Shipwreck Museum represents an integral part of Key West’s heritage. It is a must-visit for those exploring the city’s historical side. As one of the most underrated destinations in Key West, it offers a captivating experience that combines educational elements with the thrill of adventure and discovery.

7. Dry Tortugas National Park

Discover the enchanting beauty of Dry Tortugas National Park, one of the most beautiful places in Key West. Situated 70 miles west of the city, it’s accessible only by boat or seaplane. This remote park is famed for its pristine waters, vibrant coral reefs, and the historic Fort Jefferson. It’s an essential destination for those exploring Key West off the beaten path.

The park offers a variety of activities. Visitors can enjoy snorkeling in the clear waters, bird watching, or exploring the massive Fort Jefferson. Planning a trip to Dry Tortugas requires preparation, as there are no facilities on the islands. Visitors should bring water, food, and sun protection. The journey to the park is an adventure in itself. Once there, the serene environment and picturesque views are unparalleled.

Dry Tortugas National Park is an escapade into a realm of natural wonders and historical enigmas.
Dry Tortugas National Park is an escapade into a realm of natural wonders and historical enigmas.

Dry Tortugas National Park is an escape into a world of natural wonders and historical mysteries. It’s an underrated destination in Key West that provides an unforgettable experience for nature lovers and history buffs alike.

8. Key West Botanical Gardens

Escape to the Key West Botanical Gardens, a tranquil oasis that is nestled away from the city’s hustle, offering a unique glimpse into the region’s diverse flora. It’s an ideal destination for nature enthusiasts and families alike, providing a peaceful environment to explore and relax.

The gardens feature a variety of habitats, including lush butterfly gardens and a dense tropical forest. Educational tours are available, offering insights into the native plants and wildlife of the Florida Keys. These guided excursions are not just informative but also a chance to deeply connect with the natural world.

Key West Botanical Gardens is a tranquil oasis tucked away from the city's hustle. | Image Credits: Key West Gardens
Key West Botanical Gardens is a tranquil oasis tucked away from the city’s hustle. | Image Credits: Key West Gardens

Visitors can enjoy leisurely walks along the winding paths, surrounded by vibrant blooms and exotic plants. The botanical gardens are also a haven for birdwatchers, with numerous species frequenting the area. Additionally, the gardens host various events and workshops throughout the year, making each visit unique.

Located conveniently within Key West, the botanical gardens are easily accessible and offer a quiet retreat for those looking to unwind. A visit here is more than just a walk in the park; it’s an exploration of the natural wonders and serene beauty of one of the most beautiful destinations in Key West.

9. Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park

Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park, a blend of historical intrigue and natural splendor, stands out as one of Key West’s best hidden gems. Situated at the island’s southern tip, the park offers a unique experience for history enthusiasts and beachgoers alike. It is renowned for its crystal-clear waters and rich Civil War history.

Visitors can explore the well-preserved Fort Zachary Taylor, dating back to the 19th century. Guided tours provide fascinating insights into the fort’s role in American history. The park’s beach is a haven for snorkelers, boasting vibrant marine life and calm waters.

Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park is undeniably one of Key West's most distinctive destinations.
Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park is undeniably one of Key West’s most distinctive destinations.

Picnic areas and nature trails add to the park’s appeal, making it a perfect spot for family outings or solo explorations. The park also hosts historical reenactments and cultural events, offering an immersive experience into Key West’s past.

Accessible all year round, the park is ideal for a full-day visit. Morning hours are best for exploring the fort, while afternoons are perfect for relaxing on the beach. As a convergence of history and natural beauty, Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park is undoubtedly one of the most unique places to visit in Key West.

10. Blue Heaven Restaurant

Blue Heaven, tucked away in Key West’s Bahama Village, offers a dining experience unlike any other. Renowned for its distinctive ambiance and outdoor setting, it’s a culinary delight that ranks high on the list of coolest places to go in Key West. The restaurant’s charm lies in its lush outdoor gardens and the whimsical presence of roaming chickens, creating a truly eclectic atmosphere.

Famous for its Caribbean-inspired cuisine, Blue Heaven emphasizes fresh, locally sourced seafood. Breakfast lovers will enjoy their varied menu, including lobster Benedict and pancakes. Lunch and dinner feature dishes like yellowtail snapper and Caribbean BBQ shrimp, showcasing the island’s rich flavors.

Blue Heaven's exceptional food, laid-back vibe, and quirky setting create a memorable experience. | Image Credits: Blue Heaven website
Blue Heaven’s exceptional food, laid-back vibe, and quirky setting create a memorable experience. | Image Credits: Blue Heaven website

The restaurant’s Key lime pie, known for its distinctive gingersnap crust, is a must-try. Visitors also rave about the homemade banana bread and the refreshing mojitos. Blue Heaven provides a relaxed yet vibrant dining experience, perfect for both romantic dinners and casual meals with friends.

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak seasons. The blend of exceptional food, a laid-back vibe, and the quirky surroundings make Blue Heaven a memorable stop. As one of Key West’s hidden culinary gems, it captures the essence of the island’s food culture in a beautiful setting.

11. The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum

The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum is a cornerstone of Key West’s cultural heritage, located on Whitehead Street. This historic site, where the renowned author lived and wrote for over a decade, is steeped in literary significance. The home, meticulously preserved, offers visitors an intimate look into Hemingway’s life and creative process.

Touring the house, guests can see Hemingway’s writing studio and personal artifacts, which remain as he left them. The property’s gardens are a serene haven, home to the famous polydactyl cats, descendants of Hemingway’s own pets. These cats, with their unique six-toed paws, have become a symbol of the house and a favorite among visitors.

The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum stands as a cornerstone of Key West's cultural heritage and literary legacy.
The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum stands as a cornerstone of Key West’s cultural heritage and literary legacy.

The museum aspect provides deeper insight into Hemingway’s adventurous life, his literary achievements, and his connection to Key West. It’s an enriching experience for literature fans and history buffs alike. The museum also highlights Hemingway’s influence on the local culture and the broader literary world.

Visiting the Hemingway Home and Museum is a journey into the past, offering a unique perspective on one of America’s most celebrated authors. It stands out as one of the must-see places to visit in Key West, a place where history and literary legacy combine. This landmark is a living tribute to Hemingway’s enduring impact on literature and Key West.

12. Key West Lighthouse and Keeper’s Quarters Museum

The Key West Lighthouse and Keeper’s Quarters Museum, a beacon in Key West’s maritime history, stands as a symbol of guidance and resilience. Located in the heart of Key West, this lighthouse has been a guiding light for sailors since the 19th century, making it a must-visit for those exploring hidden places in Key West.

Climbing the 88 steps to the lighthouse’s top, visitors are rewarded with stunning panoramic views of the island. This ascent not only offers a physical challenge but also a historical journey, as one witnesses the evolving landscape of Key West from above.

Adjacent to the lighthouse, the Keeper’s Quarters Museum offers a glimpse into the lives of those who maintained this crucial beacon. The museum’s collection includes fascinating artifacts and photos that tell the story of the lighthouse keepers’ daily challenges and their critical role in maritime safety.

The Key West Lighthouse and Keeper's Quarters Museum stand as a beacon, illuminating Key West's rich maritime history.
The Key West Lighthouse and Keeper’s Quarters Museum stand as a beacon, illuminating Key West’s rich maritime history.

Visiting this historic site is an educational adventure, highlighting Key West’s rich nautical history and its importance in maritime navigation. It’s a perfect spot for history enthusiasts and photographers alike, offering both educational insights and scenic beauty.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Best Hidden Gems in Key West

Are you searching for more information about where to go in Key West? Here are some common questions (and answers) I often receive about the most underrated places in Key West.

Is it safe to walk around Key West?

Yes, Key West is generally considered safe for walking. The island is pedestrian-friendly, especially in popular areas like Duval Street and the Historic Seaport. As with any travel destination, it’s advisable to stay aware of your surroundings and follow basic safety precautions, particularly at night.

Are there entrance fees for the Key West hidden gems mentioned in the article?

Most of the places listed, like Smathers Beach and the Key West Cemetery, are free to visit. However, some attractions like the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum and Fort Zachary Taylor State Park have entrance fees.

How much time should I allocate to visit Dry Tortugas National Park?

A trip to Dry Tortugas typically requires a full day, as it’s 70 miles from Key West and accessible only by boat or seaplane. It’s recommended to plan ahead for this excursion.

Exploring hidden gems provides an intimate glimpse into the heart of Key West, revealing its authentic charm.
Exploring hidden gems provides an intimate glimpse into the heart of Key West, revealing its authentic charm.

What’s the best way to travel between these hidden gems in Key West?

Key West is compact, and most sites are easily accessible by foot, bike, or a short drive. Renting a bicycle or a scooter can be a fun way to explore the island.

Are the Key West Botanical Gardens suitable for families with children?

Absolutely! The Key West Botanical Gardens are family-friendly and offer a great opportunity for children to learn about native plants and wildlife.

Can I visit the Key West Lighthouse and Museum year-round?

Yes, the Key West Lighthouse and Museum is open to visitors year-round, though it’s best to check their official website for any seasonal changes in operating hours.

What major airlines fly into Key West?

Several major airlines provide convenient flights to Key West International Airport (EYW), ensuring seamless access to this captivating destination. Among the major carriers, Delta Air Lines, American Airlines, United Airlines, and Southwest Airlines stand out as key airline players offering regular flight service to Key West.

Are there any budget-friendly accommodations in Key West?

Absolutely! Key West offers charming Key West vacation rentals that have inviting perks like outdoor pools, private balconies, and a central location near the lively Duval Street. Staying local is the best way to experience this colorful city as you’ll have easy access to the city’s top attractions and island activities.

Final Thoughts on Key West’s Hidden Gems

As our exploration of Key West’s hidden gems concludes, we are enriched by the island’s diverse allure. The Tennessee Williams Home and Smathers Beach have unveiled unique aspects of Key West. The Key West Cemetery and Blue Heaven Restaurant have added distinct flavors to our experience. The Key West Lighthouse and Dry Tortugas National Park further enrich the tapestry of our journey.

These hidden gems offer an intimate look into the heart of Key West. They beckon with a promise of discovery and immersion into the island’s essence. This journey is not just about visiting new places. It’s about unveiling stories and creating cherished memories. Key West, in its unassuming majesty, is more than a destination. It’s a narrative of hidden wonders, waiting for explorers and admirers.

Dive into this guide to discover the best hidden gems in Key West for all travelers
Enjoyed reading about these hidden gems in Key West? Pin it!

You may also like

Leave a Comment