The 12 Best Areas to Stay in St. Thomas for a Caribbean Getaway

1.1K

St. Thomas knocked me sideways from day one. Those turquoise waters and green mountains aren’t just pretty—they’re downright jaw-dropping. But where you stay makes or breaks your whole island experience.

I’ve checked out lots of the best places in St. Thomas over my visits. One trip I crashed at this beachfront spot in East End, where I literally rolled out of bed onto sand. Another time, I snagged a villa in Charlotte Amalie with killer harbor views—perfect for sunset cocktails watching cruise ships sail away. Whether you want to shop and party or just plant yourself on a perfect beach all day, this island delivers. Here are 12 neighborhoods that’ll give you exactly the Caribbean vacation you’re dreaming about, from luxury resorts to local vibes.

Best Places to Stay in St. Thomas

Looking to discover the best places to stay in St. Thomas? Beyond the typical accommodations, the island offers plenty of distinctive options waiting to be explored. Relax in Charlotte Amalie, known for its luxury resorts and vibrant shopping. Experience the charm of Magens Bay, offering beachfront stays and stunning views. Unwind in Red Hook, featuring cozy inns and a lively marina scene.

Neighborhood/Town	Best For	Hotel Prices	Walkability	Vibe
Downtown Charlotte Amalie	History Lovers, Shoppers	$$$	High	Historic, Lively
East End & Red Hook	Island Hoppers, Nightlife	$$$	Moderate	Vibrant, Marina Setting
Southside	Luxury Travelers	$$$$	Low	Upscale, Panoramic Views
Charlotte Amalie West	Budget Travelers, Families	$$	Moderate	Local, Practical
Northside	Nature Lovers	$$$	Low	Tranquil, Wild Beauty
Water Island	Off-the-Grid Travelers	$$	High	Unspoiled, Car-Free Paradise
Nazareth	Independent Travelers	$$	Moderate	Authentic, Residential
Frenchtown	Foodies, Culture Seekers	$$$	Moderate	Culinary Scene, French Heritage
West End	Adventure Seekers	$$	Low	Untamed, Undiscovered
Peterborg Peninsula	Luxury Travelers	$$$$	Low	Prestigious, Dramatic Views
Smith Bay	Balance Seekers	$$$	Moderate	Relaxed, Residential
Compass Point	Upscale Travelers	$$$$	Low	Sophisticated, Nautical

Whether you’re into luxury, beach vibes, or local culture, here are 12 of St. Thomas’s most exceptional places to stay!

1. Downtown Charlotte Amalie

Craving that perfect blend of tropical paradise and fascinating history where pirate legends come alive? Downtown Charlotte Amalie delivers colonial charm with a splash of Caribbean color.

Wake up to the rhythm of cruise ships and colorful architecture in the island’s historic capital. Shop duty-free at Havensight Mall or hunt for treasures along Main Street. When hunger strikes, Gladys’ Café serves up authentic West Indian cuisine that will have you planning your next meal before finishing your first.

The downtown area sits on the south-central coast, making it an ideal base for island exploration. Staying at the boutique Windward Passage Hotel puts you within walking distance of the harbor and historic sites like Fort Christian and 99 Steps. I’ve never seen sunsets quite like those from the downtown waterfront.

Perfect for travelers who want to be in the heart of the action without sacrificing authentic island vibes.

🏨 Best Hotels in Downtown Charlotte Amalie

• Budget: Bunker Hill Hotel ($$) – Charming historic property with a local atmosphere, just steps from shopping and dining.
• Mid-Range: Windward Passage Hotel ($$$) – Convenient harborfront location with comfortable rooms and an outdoor pool.
• Luxury: The Green Iguana Hotel ($$$$) – Boutique hillside property offering stunning harbor views and upscale amenities.

2. East End & Red Hook

Want island-hopping adventures by day and fresh seafood with ocean breezes by night? East End & Red Hook combines the best of accessibility and escape in one vibrant marina setting.

This eastern peninsula buzzes with energy around the American Yacht Harbor, where ferry service to St. John and the BVIs departs throughout the day. Wake to spectacular sunrise views over neighboring islands before spending the day at Sapphire Beach or Secret Harbor. Both offer powder-soft sand and crystal-clear waters.

When evening arrives, the area transforms into the island’s premier nightlife district. Island Time Pub and Caribbean Fish Market serve up fresh catches and tropical cocktails. Accommodations range from luxury villas to beachfront resorts like Margaritaville Vacation Club and Point Pleasant Resort.

Ideal for water lovers who want easy access to island hopping and vibrant evening entertainment.

🏨 Best Hotels in East End & Red Hook

• Budget: Crystal Cove Beach Resort ($$) – Beachfront condos with kitchenettes and relaxed atmosphere, near the Red Hook ferry terminal.
• Mid-Range: Elysian Beach Resort ($$$) – Well-appointed rooms with balconies, nestled in a scenic cove with private beach access.
• Luxury: The Ritz-Carlton, St. Thomas ($$$$) – Exceptional luxury resort with world-class amenities, spectacular views, and impeccable service.

3. Southside

Dreaming of waking up to panoramic ocean views from your private balcony with a mimosa in hand? Southside delivers dramatic hillside luxury with some of the island’s most Instagram-worthy vistas.

This southern coast offers postcard-perfect scenery with the advantage of being just 15 minutes from the airport. Base yourself near Bolongo Bay to enjoy watersports and beachfront dining at your doorstep. The Bolongo Bay Beach Resort offers an all-inclusive option rare for the island.

Nearby, Frenchman’s Reef is reclaiming its status as the island’s premier luxury destination. Don’t miss Morningstar Beach and Limetree Beach, both offering excellent snorkeling just offshore. At sunset, grab a table at Sunset Grille, where fiery Caribbean skies put on a nightly show.

Perfect for travelers seeking upscale accommodations with spectacular views and convenient location.

🏨 Best Hotels in Southside

• Budget: Bolongo Bay Beach Resort ($$) – Casual beachfront resort with all-inclusive options and water activities.
• Mid-Range: Marriott’s Frenchman’s Cove ($$$) – Spacious villa-style accommodations with stunning views and a picturesque beach.
• Luxury: Frenchman’s Reef Marriott Resort ($$$$) – Recently renovated luxury property with multiple pools, private beach, and panoramic harbor views.

4. Charlotte Amalie West

Looking for that sweet spot where you can experience authentic island life without sacrificing your beach time or breaking the bank? Charlotte Amalie West delivers local vibes with practical perks.

This western extension of the capital offers a more relaxed pace while maintaining easy access to downtown attractions just 10 minutes away. The area centers around the University of the Virgin Islands and the Windward Passage, creating a vibrant community feel.

Budget-conscious travelers will appreciate options like Emerald Beach Resort and Lindbergh Bay Hotel. Both offer direct beach access without premium prices. Lindbergh Bay provides a peaceful beach experience with gentle waters perfect for families. When hunger strikes, Beachside Café serves up fresh seafood with your toes literally in the sand.

Ideal for travelers seeking value accommodations with authentic local atmosphere and convenient access to both the airport and downtown.

🏨 Best Hotels in Charlotte Amalie West

• Budget: Emerald Beach Resort ($$) – Beachfront property with simple, comfortable rooms and easy airport access.
• Mid-Range: Lindbergh Bay Hotel and Villas ($$$) – Relaxed atmosphere with renovated rooms, pool, and beachfront dining just minutes from the airport.
• Luxury: Point Pleasant Resort ($$$$) – Hillside villas with stunning views, three pools, and nearby beach access in a lush, tropical setting.

5. Northside

Tired of cookie-cutter resort experiences where you could be anywhere with a beach? Northside’s wild beauty and local charm will remind you why you chose the Caribbean in the first place.

This northern coast offers a dramatic contrast to the more developed south, with winding roads revealing breathtaking vistas around each bend. Magens Bay anchors the area with its mile-long crescent of white sand and calm, turquoise waters. It consistently ranks among the world’s most beautiful beaches.

Nearby, Hull Bay attracts surfers during winter swells and offers a glimpse into local fishing culture. The hills above host charming accommodations like Flamboyan on the Bay and numerous vacation villas. I’ve spent evenings at local favorites Hull Bay Hideaway among locals and visitors alike, all drawn by the unspoiled beauty.

Perfect for nature lovers seeking tranquility without complete isolation.

🏨 Best Hotels in Northside

• Budget: Flamboyan on the Bay Resort & Villas ($$) – Hillside property with spacious rooms, kitchenettes, and scenic harbor views.
• Mid-Range: Magens Point Resort ($$$) – Comfortable suites with tropical decor, tennis courts, and easy access to Magens Bay.
• Luxury: Villa Marbella Suites ($$$$) – Exclusive boutique property with elegant suites, panoramic ocean views, and personalized service in a peaceful setting.

6. Water Island

Want to experience the Virgin Islands as they were before mega-resorts and cruise ships? Just a 10-minute ferry ride reveals a car-free paradise that time delightfully forgot.

This car-free paradise of just one square mile offers an escape from the main island’s pace. A tight-knit community of only 200 residents calls it home. Honeymoon Beach serves as the island’s social hub, where beach chairs, water toys, and refreshments from Dinghy’s Beach Bar create a laid-back atmosphere.

The abandoned Fort Segarra, a WWII relic, provides fascinating exploration and spectacular island views. The Monday night beach movie at Honeymoon Beach has become a cherished tradition. Accommodations are limited to vacation rentals and small guesthouses, making advance planning essential.

Perfect for travelers seeking an authentic island experience with minimal commercialization and maximum Caribbean tranquility.

🏨 Best Hotels in Water Island

• Budget: Dinghy’s Beach Cottages ($$) – Simple beachside cottages with basic amenities, a convenient location near the ferry dock, and easy walking distance to Honeymoon Beach.
• Mid-Range: Water Island Vacation Homes ($$$) – Privately owned rental homes and villas with full kitchens, living areas, and outdoor spaces offering views of the harbor and surrounding islands.
• Luxury: Virgin Islands Campground ($$$$) – Eco-friendly luxury cabins with private terraces, upscale amenities, and personalized concierge service.

7. Nazareth

Seeking that off-the-brochure experience where you might be the only tourist in a local hangout? Nazareth offers a genuine slice of island life away from the resort bubble.

This primarily residential area on St. Thomas’ eastern shores provides a genuine glimpse into island life. It offers excellent access to eastern beaches and attractions. The area centers around Vessup Bay and extends north toward Smith Bay, creating a convenient base for exploring the island’s eastern half.

Secret Harbor Beach sits at its southern edge, offering excellent snorkeling and the upscale Secret Harbor Beach Resort. Nearby, Coral World Ocean Park provides educational underwater encounters without getting wet. Local eateries like Easterly serve Caribbean classics without tourist pricing.

Ideal for independent travelers seeking authentic experiences and local connections with excellent eastern island access.

🏨 Best Hotels in Nazareth

• Budget: Island View Guest House ($$) – Cozy accommodations with tropical gardens and partial ocean views, just a short drive to beaches.
• Mid-Range: Secret Harbour Beach Resort ($$$) – Beachfront condos with full kitchens, private balconies, and excellent snorkeling right offshore.
• Luxury: Pavilions and Pools Villa Hotel ($$$$) – Private villa accommodations with individual pools, luxurious amenities, and secluded atmosphere in a tranquil setting.

8. Frenchtown

Curious about where locals go for the island’s best seafood when they’re celebrating something special? Frenchtown’s culinary scene is the worst-kept secret among St. Thomas foodies.

This small peninsula west of downtown Charlotte Amalie has preserved its unique Frenchie atmosphere through generations of fishing families. The neighborhood revolves around its working fishing harbor. Colorful boats bring in the day’s catch to supply the area’s renowned restaurants.

Frenchtown Brewing Company offers craft beers with Caribbean flair. Culinary institutions like Oceana and Frenchie’s Bistro showcase the freshest seafood in elegant settings. Accommodations include charming small inns and vacation rentals with authentic character, just a 5-minute drive west of downtown.

Perfect for food enthusiasts seeking an authentic cultural experience within easy reach of downtown attractions.

🏨 Best Hotels in Frenchtown

• Budget: The Island View Guest House ($$) – Quaint inn with local character, harbor views, and walking distance to authentic French Creole restaurants.
• Mid-Range: Frenchman’s Reef Villas ($$$) – Comfortable accommodations with marina views, private balconies, and access to nearby dining and shopping.
• Luxury: Mafolie Hotel ($$$$) – Boutique hilltop property with panoramic views of Charlotte Amalie Harbor, elegant rooms, anda renowned restaurant.

9. West End

Bored with beaches that look straight out of a tourism brochure? The West End’s untamed shores and local hangouts offer something increasingly rare in the Caribbean: discovery.

This western region beyond Charlotte Amalie West offers a glimpse of the island as it once was. Fewer resorts mean more opportunities to carve your own experience. Brewers Bay provides excellent snorkeling with frequent turtle encounters in an uncrowded setting.

Nearby, the University of the Virgin Islands’ MacLean Marine Science Center offers fascinating educational exhibits. Stumpy Bay rewards adventurous travelers with pristine sands often enjoyed in solitude. Accommodations tend toward vacation rentals and small local properties rather than large resorts.

Perfect for return visitors to St. Thomas seeking new experiences and travelers who prefer authentic island atmosphere over tourist concentrations.

🏨 Best Hotels in West End

• Budget: Island View Guest House ($$) – Affordable hillside accommodation with harbor views, simple rooms, and a convenient location near Frenchtown and downtown Charlotte Amalie.
• Mid-Range: Sand Castle on the Beach ($$$) – Boutique beachfront hotel with spacious suites, pool, and on-site restaurant serving Caribbean cuisine.
• Luxury: Ritz-Carlton St. Thomas ($$$$) – Prestigious oceanfront resort featuring elegant rooms and suites, multiple dining options, infinity pool, spa services, private beach, and water sports in a picturesque setting overlooking Great Bay.

• Read Next: 7 Amazing Resorts in the Caribbean

10. Peterborg Peninsula

Fantasizing about that envy-inducing social media post featuring your infinity pool seemingly spilling into the Caribbean? Peterborg Peninsula’s luxury villas deliver your glamour shot with privacy included.

This prestigious neighborhood occupies some of St. Thomas’ most prime real estate. Homes and villas perch dramatically above the Caribbean. The peninsula’s location provides dual-bay views and cooling trade winds year-round. Platform Beach, a small hidden gem accessible via steep steps, rewards visitors with exceptional snorkeling and often complete privacy.

The neighborhood’s elevated location delivers some of the island’s most spectacular panoramas. Enjoy sunrise-to-sunset views over Magens Bay and the British Virgin Islands. Accommodations consist almost exclusively of luxury villas available for rent, many with infinity pools seemingly extending into the Caribbean below.

Perfect for travelers seeking luxury, privacy, and some of the most dramatic coastal views in the Caribbean.

🏨 Best Hotels in Peterborg Peninsula

• Budget: Flamboyan on the Bay Resort & Villas ($$) – Hillside property with studio and villa accommodations, ocean views, and convenient location near Magens Bay.
• Mid-Range: Villa Eau Claire ($$$) – Waterfront property with apartment-style accommodations, private decks, and direct ocean access.
• Luxury: Villa Marbella ($$$$) – Exquisite private estate with Mediterranean architecture, expansive outdoor living spaces, an infinity pool overlooking Magens Bay, a chef’s kitchen, and premium amenities in a secluded setting with breathtaking views.

11. Smith Bay

Want that goldilocks zone where authentic local experiences meet resort conveniences? Smith Bay hits the sweet spot between “too touristy” and “too remote” on St. Thomas’ northeastern shore.

This primarily residential area offers a more authentic island experience while providing easy access to popular attractions. The neighborhood centers around Smith Bay Park and Lindquist Beach, a stunning stretch of white sand and crystal waters that locals treasure.

Nearby, Coral World Ocean Park offers amazing marine encounters from underwater observatories to sea lion interactions. The Margaritaville Vacation Club anchors the area’s limited resort options. Vacation rentals in the hills above provide spectacular down-island views. The eastern location means easy access to St. John and BVI day trips.

Ideal for travelers seeking a relaxed residential atmosphere with excellent beach access and proximity to eastern attractions.

🏨 Best Hotels in Smith Bay

• Budget: Crystal Cove Villas ($$) – Comfortable apartments with kitchenettes, tropical gardens, and a short walk to Sapphire Beach.
• Mid-Range: Sapphire Beach Resort & Marina ($$$) – Oceanfront condos with stunning views, direct beach access, and excellent snorkeling.
• Luxury: Margaritaville Vacation Club by Wyndham ($$$$) – Upscale resort with elegant suites, multiple pools, and luxurious amenities in a relaxed Caribbean atmosphere.

12. Compass Point

Imagine yourself with a morning coffee on your terrace as the sun rises over distant islands.   Compass Point’s elevated position delivers the million-dollar views that vacation daydreams are made of.

This prestigious enclave rises above the eastern end of the island. It commands sweeping views from St. John across to the British Virgin Islands. The area centers around the Compass Point Marina and Yacht Club, creating a sophisticated atmosphere where island luxury meets nautical lifestyle.

Private villas with infinity pools cascade down the hillside. The Point Pleasant Resort offers similar views with hotel amenities. Three beaches lie within easy reach: Sugar Bay, Pineapple Beach, and Coki Beach.

The latter is famous for fish that eat directly from snorkelers’ hands. The eastward orientation delivers spectacular sunrises and constant cooling breezes.

Perfect for travelers seeking upscale accommodations with dramatic views and a sophisticated atmosphere.

🏨 Best Hotels in Compass Point

• Budget: Emerald Beach Resort ($$) – Beachfront property with comfortable rooms, a pool, and convenient location near the airport and Charlotte Amalie.
• Mid-Range: Secret Harbour Beach Resort ($$$) – Condo-style accommodations with full kitchens, private balconies, and direct access to a beautiful snorkeling beach on the east end.
• Luxury: Blue Horizons Villa ($$$$) – Exclusive clifftop property with infinity pool, panoramic ocean vistas, and luxurious amenities in a serene, private setting.

• Read Next: 12 Must-Visit Places in the Caribbean in 2025