Unique Restaurants in Cape Cod: 12 Coolest Cape Cod Places to Eat

by Jen
Unique Restaurants in Cape Cod
This post may have affiliate links, where I may receive a commission if you purchase through them. Here's our Disclosure and Privacy Policy for more info.

Are you looking for the most unique restaurants in Cape Cod, MA? Here’s your ultimate guide to the best places to eat in Cape Cod.

In the northeastern corner of the United States, Cape Cod is a destination that evokes images of sun-kissed beaches, quaint lighthouses, and serene landscapes. But beyond its natural beauty and historic charm, the Cape holds a secret that’s waiting to be savored – its unparalleled culinary scene.

For those who venture to this coastal gem, the gastronomic delights are endless. From freshly caught seafood to the bustling local markets offering organic produce, Cape Cod is a food lover’s paradise. It’s not just about the traditional clam chowder or the iconic lobster rolls. The Cape’s dining scene is a mosaic of flavors, influenced by its rich maritime history and the diverse cultures that have called it home.

From the spicy allure of authentic Thai dishes to the nostalgic flavors of a classic ’50s diner breakfast, there are unique restaurants in Cape Cod that cater to every culinary whim. And for those with an inclination for elegance, the region’s French-inspired bistros offer a taste of sophistication. What truly elevates each meal is the backdrop: dine with views of tranquil harbors, amidst historic villages, or under the glow of a mesmerizing sunset.

In this guide, we’ll take you on a culinary journey through Cape Cod, exploring the unique places to eat that make this destination a must-visit for food enthusiasts. From hidden gems to popular hotspots, get ready to discover the flavors that define Cape Cod. Here’s all you need to know about the most unique restaurants in Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

The top restaurants to visit in Cape Cod right now
This article on the unique restaurants in Cape Cod contains affiliate links where I may earn a small commission at no cost to you.

Unique Restaurants in Cape Cod, MA: 12 Memorable Eateries in Cape Cod

Are you ready to discover the most unique restaurants in Cape Cod? As previously noted, there’s a wide range of places to eat in Cape Cod for all tastes and budgets. Keep reading to find out where to eat in Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

Are you looking for a seafood feast, fresh from the Atlantic? Or would you prefer a cozy bistro serving international flavors? Whatever your palate desires, Cape Cod can accommodate your needs. Here’s your in-depth guide to the most unique restaurants in Cape Cod.

1. Betsy’s Diner in Falmouth

Betsy’s Diner in Falmouth is a blast from the past with a sprinkle of modern-day culinary magic. The moment you walk in, the vibrant 1950s ambiance, complete with checkered floor tiles and retro decor, sets the stage for a delightful dining experience.

Kickstart your day with their breakfast menu that’s a delightful mix of the familiar and the unexpected. Sure, they’ve got all-time favorites like pancakes and French toast. But have you ever tried a breakfast burrito with a Cape Cod twist? It’s a fusion of flavors that’ll leave you craving for more. And if you think breakfast is a treat, wait till you explore their lunch offerings. It’s a playful dance of flavors, from hearty burgers to dishes that showcase a touch of culinary innovation.

In the heart of Cape Cod, Betsy’s Diner stands out as one of the best restaurants where every meal feels like a mini celebration. It’s a spot that combines the comfort of classic diner food with little surprises that make any meal memorable. As such, if you’re on the hunt for unique places to eat in Cape Cod, make sure Betsy’s is on your list.

Betsy’s Diner is one of the most unique restaurants in Cape Cod.
Betsy’s Diner in Falmouth combines 1950s charm and modern culinary magic for a delightful dining journey.

2. Bangkok Kitchen in Hyannis

Craving a taste of Thailand while in Cape Cod? Look no further than Bangkok Kitchen in Hyannis. This place is a genuine slice of Bangkok, right in the heart of the Cape. Dive into aromatic dishes like Tom Yum soup that awakens your senses or the flavorful Pad Thai that dances on your palate. For those who love a little spice, their curries offer a delightful kick.

The ambiance is a blend of traditional Thai aesthetics with a touch of modern comfort. Warm lighting, intricate decor, and the soft hum of conversations create an atmosphere that’s both inviting and intimate. The staff, passionate about their culinary heritage, are always on hand to guide diners through the menu, ensuring everyone finds their perfect dish.

Amid Cape Cod’s seafood-dominated dining landscape, Bangkok Kitchen emerges as a refreshing culinary destination. For those with an adventurous palate, this place is a must-visit. It solidifies its reputation as one of the most unique restaurants in Cape Cod.

Indulge in an authentic taste of Thailand at Bangkok Kitchen in Hyannis, Cape Cod, featuring aromatic dishes like Tom Yum soup and flavorful Pad Thai.
Indulge in an authentic taste of Thailand at Bangkok Kitchen in Hyannis, Cape Cod, featuring aromatic dishes like Tom Yum soup and flavorful Pad Thai.

3. Keltic Kitchen in West Yarmouth

When you think of Cape Cod, Irish fare might not be the first thing that comes to mind. Yet, Keltic Kitchen in West Yarmouth is changing that narrative, one delicious dish at a time. This eatery is a delightful nod to the Emerald Isle, offering a menu that’s as hearty as it is flavorful.

Start your day with their signature Irish breakfast, a generous plate loaded with sausages, black and white pudding, and all the trimmings. If you’re in the mood for something lighter, their scones, fresh from the oven, paired with a hot cup of tea, are pure bliss. Lunchtime brings a spread of traditional dishes. This includes everything from shepherd’s pie to corned beef and cabbage, each prepared with love and a touch of Irish magic.

The ambiance is cozy and unpretentious, with Celtic motifs adorning the walls and soft Irish melodies playing in the background. It’s the kind of place where every meal feels like a warm hug, making it one of the coolest places to eat in Cape Cod, MA. So, if you’re looking to venture beyond seafood and explore global flavors, Keltic Kitchen is a delightful pit stop on your Cape Cod culinary journey.

Keltic Kitchen in West Yarmouth redefines Cape Cod with hearty and flavorful Irish fare, embracing the spirit of the Emerald Isle.
Keltic Kitchen in West Yarmouth redefines Cape Cod with hearty and flavorful Irish fare, embracing the spirit of the Emerald Isle.

4. Route 28 Diner in South Yarmouth

Route 28 Diner in South Yarmouth is where classic American diner vibes meet Cape Cod charm. It’s the kind of place where every visit feels like a mini vacation, with a menu that promises comfort and satisfaction with every bite.

Morning visitors are in for a treat with a breakfast menu that boasts everything from fluffy pancakes drizzled in maple syrup to savory omelets packed with fresh ingredients. And if you’re a fan of all-day breakfasts, you’re in luck! Their breakfast delights are available to satisfy your cravings, no matter the hour.

Lunch at Route 28 is a hearty affair. Think juicy burgers, crispy fries, and sandwiches stacked high with fillings. Each dish is a nod to classic American diner fare, prepared with a touch of Cape Cod flair. And let’s not forget the milkshakes – thick, creamy, and the perfect end to any meal.

With its retro decor, friendly staff, and a menu bursting with flavors, Route 28 Diner has carved a special place in the hearts of both locals and visitors. It’s a delightful blend of nostalgia and modern culinary delights. Without a doubt, it’s a top pick for those seeking the best food in Cape Cod. Every visit promises not just a meal, but an experience to remember.

At Route 28 Diner in South Yarmouth, experience classic American diner meets Cape Cod charm with a comforting menu.
At Route 28 Diner in South Yarmouth, experience classic American diner meets Cape Cod charm with a comforting menu.

5. The Lanyard Bar and Grill in Harwich

Tucked away in Harwich, The Lanyard Bar and Grill is a culinary gem that perfectly captures the essence of Cape Cod dining. With a menu that’s as diverse as the Cape’s landscapes, this eatery promises a gastronomic adventure with every visit.

Seafood lovers will be in heaven with dishes like smoked barbecue shrimp or fresh oysters from the raw bar. The Lanyard also offers a range of mouthwatering options for meat enthusiasts, vegetarians, and even those with a sweet tooth. Their smoked barbecue ribs are a popular choice, tender and dripping with flavor. On the other hand, the vegetarian options are crafted with the same care and creativity.

The ambiance is laid-back and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for both casual lunches and special dinners. Large windows offer diners a glimpse of the beautiful Cape Cod surroundings, adding to the overall dining experience.

For those on the hunt for unique Cape Cod restaurants that offer a mix of local flavors and global inspirations, The Lanyard Bar and Grill is a destination worth adding to your list.

Harwich's Lanyard Bar and Grill
Harwich’s Lanyard Bar and Grill embodies Cape Cod dining, offering a diverse menu for a culinary adventure.

6. Red Barn Pizza & More in Eastham

Pizza in Cape Cod? Absolutely! Red Barn Pizza & More in Eastham is proof that the Cape’s culinary scene is as varied as its beautiful beaches. This isn’t your average pizza joint, though. It’s a dream for those seeking comfort food with a Cape Cod twist.

Their pizzas are legendary, with crusts that strike the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, topped with a medley of fresh ingredients. From classic margheritas to inventive toppings that showcase local produce, there’s a pizza for every palate. For a lighter option, dive into their range of salads, soups, and other delightful dishes that promise to satiate every craving.

The rustic charm of the barn setting, combined with the aroma of freshly baked pizzas, creates an ambiance that’s both cozy and inviting. It’s a place where families gather, friends catch up, and memories are made over slices of deliciousness.

If you’re scouting for scenic places in Cape Cod to eat and enjoy a laid-back meal, Red Barn Pizza & More is a top contender. It’s a clear indication that the Cape’s dining scene is as varied as its beautiful shores.

Experience Cape Cod's diverse culinary scene at Red Barn Pizza & More in Eastham, where comfort food gets a Cape Cod twist.
Experience Cape Cod’s diverse culinary scene at Red Barn Pizza & More in Eastham.

7. C Salt Wine Bar & Grille in Falmouth

Elegance meets culinary expertise at C Salt Wine Bar & Grille in Falmouth. This trendy restaurant offers a harmonious blend of American fare infused with subtle Asian and French influences. As such, it stands out in Cape Cod’s vibrant dining scene.

Begin your gastronomic journey with their curated selection of wines, each handpicked to complement the menu’s flavors. Delve into starters like tuna tartare or duck confit, each dish showcasing the chef’s creativity and passion. The main courses don’t disappoint either, with options ranging from seared scallops to succulent steaks, all prepared with finesse.

The ambiance is chic yet intimate, with soft lighting and contemporary decor creating a setting perfect for romantic dinners or celebratory gatherings. The attentive staff ensures every detail is taken care of, from wine pairings to dessert recommendations.

Seeking fine dining in Cape Cod, Massachusetts? C Salt Wine Bar & Grille is an experience not to be missed. Culinary artistry and impeccable service come together here, promising an unforgettable dining adventure.

C Salt Wine Bar & Grille is one of the unique restaurants in Cape Cod.
C Salt Wine Bar & Grille offers a unique fusion of American, Asian, and French influences in Cape Cod’s vibrant dining landscape.

8. The Beachcomber in Wellfleet

Perched right on the edge of Cahoon Hollow Beach, The Beachcomber in Wellfleet is the epitome of scenic restaurants in Cape Cod. With panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean, this spot is a favorite for both locals and tourists looking to savor a meal with a side of nature’s beauty.

The menu is a delightful mix of seafood staples and classic American dishes. From fresh oysters and clams to juicy burgers, there’s something for everyone. And what’s better than enjoying a lobster roll while listening to the rhythmic sound of waves crashing onto the shore?

The Beachcomber’s laid-back vibe is further enhanced by its beach shack ambiance, complete with rustic wooden interiors and nautical decor. And it’s not just the food and views that draw people in. The Beachcomber is also known for its vibrant live music scene. This makes it a hub of entertainment during the summer months.

If you’re on the lookout for scenic places in Cape Cod to eat, The Beachcomber should be at the top of your list. It’s a place where simple, delicious food meets unparalleled ocean views, offering a dining experience that’s pure Cape Cod magic.

The Beachcomber in Wellfleet offers scenic dining with Atlantic Ocean views, a favorite for locals and tourists alike.
The Beachcomber in Wellfleet offers scenic dining with Atlantic Ocean views, a favorite for locals and tourists alike.

9. Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar in Eastham

When it comes to affordable, mouth-watering seafood in Cape Cod, Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar in Eastham is hard to beat. This iconic eatery has been serving locals and visitors alike for decades, earning a reputation for its fresh catches and wallet-friendly prices.

At Arnold’s, the menu is straightforward but packed with flavor. Enjoy their famous lobster rolls, generously filled with succulent lobster meat and lightly dressed, or try their crispy fried clams, a favorite among regulars. For those looking to venture beyond seafood, the eatery also offers juicy burgers and hot dogs, all prepared to perfection.

What truly sets Arnold’s apart is its unique setting. With picnic tables set amidst beautiful gardens and a mini-golf course on the side, it’s more than just a dining spot; it’s a fun-filled destination. And don’t forget to leave room for dessert! Their homemade ice creams are a must-try, with flavors that change regularly but always impress.

Searching for unique restaurants in Cape Cod, MA that don’t compromise on taste? Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar is a testament to the fact that delicious food doesn’t always come with a hefty price tag.

 Arnold's Lobster & Clam Bar in Eastham is an iconic choice known for fresh catches and budget-friendly options.
Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar in Eastham is an iconic choice known for fresh catches and budget-friendly options.

10. The Underground Bakery in Dennis

Tucked away beneath the bustling streets of Dennis, The Underground Bakery offers a dining experience like no other. This isn’t your typical bakery – it’s a culinary adventure waiting to be discovered.

Venture down the steps, and you’ll find a world of flavors that defy expectations. The menu is a playful blend of classic bakery items with a twist. Ever tried a seaweed and sesame bagel? Or how about a beetroot and chocolate muffin? The Underground Bakery takes familiar favorites and turns them on their head, resulting in creations that surprise and delight with every bite.

The real star of the show is their range of artisanal breads. From sourdough infused with local herbs to loaves baked with unconventional ingredients like squid ink or turmeric, each bread is a masterpiece in its own right.

For those seeking unique eateries in Cape Cod, The Underground Bakery is a must-visit. It’s a place where culinary boundaries are pushed, and every dish is a testament to the chef’s creativity and passion for baking.

The Underground Bakery offers a unique culinary adventure beyond the ordinary bakery.
The Underground Bakery offers a unique culinary adventure beyond the ordinary bakery. | Source: https://theundergroundbakery.com/

11. Bleu in Mashpee

For moments that call for something extra special, Bleu in Mashpee stands out as Cape Cod’s premier destination. This French-inspired bistro offers an intimate setting that’s perfect for couples celebrating anniversaries, engagements, or simply a romantic evening out.

The menu at Bleu reflects classic French cuisine with a Cape Cod touch. Indulge in dishes like duck confit with berry reduction or seared scallops drizzled in a delicate truffle sauce. Each plate is meticulously crafted, ensuring a dining experience that’s both visually stunning and gastronomically satisfying.

While Bleu offers an exquisite dining experience, it’s worth noting that it leans towards the pricier side. However, for many, the impeccable quality of the food, combined with the restaurant’s elegant atmosphere, justifies the splurge. After all, special occasions deserve nothing but the best.

If you’re planning a memorable evening and seeking one of Cape Cod’s best restaurants, Bleu is a choice that promises to make your special occasion even more unforgettable.

Bleu in Mashpee: Cape Cod's top spot for special occasions. An intimate French-inspired bistro perfect for romantic evenings.
Bleu in Mashpee: Cape Cod’s top spot for special occasions. An intimate French-inspired bistro perfect for romantic evenings.

12. Mac’s Shack in Wellfleet

Nestled in the heart of Wellfleet, Mac’s Shack is where modern culinary artistry meets the timeless allure of the sea. It’s the ideal spot for anyone searching for the best restaurants in Cape Cod, especially for special occasions or intimate dinners.

The menu is a seafood lover’s dream. Freshly caught oysters, clams, and other shellfish are the stars of the show, presented in innovative ways that highlight their natural flavors. Dive into dishes like tuna tartare with avocado and crispy shallots or indulge in the rich lobster bisque, infused with a hint of brandy.

While seafood dominates the menu, Mac’s Shack also offers a selection of meat and vegetarian dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. For the perfect pairing, their extensive wine list boasts selections from around the world, curated to complement the flavors of the sea.

Given its reputation and the quality of its offerings, Mac’s Shack is on the higher end of the price spectrum. Yet, for those seeking unique restaurants in Cape Cod, the splurge is well worth it.

Mac's Shack in Wellfleet: Where culinary artistry meets the sea for exceptional Cape Cod dining.
Mac’s Shack in Wellfleet: Where culinary artistry meets the sea for exceptional Cape Cod dining.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about the Most Unique Restaurants in Cape Cod

Do you have further questions about the most unique places to eat in Cape Cod? Here are some common questions (and answers) I get asked a lot about the best restaurants in Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

What food is Cape Cod known for?

Cape Cod is renowned for its fresh seafood, especially lobster, clams, and cod. The region boasts a rich maritime heritage, which is reflected in its culinary offerings. From clam chowder and lobster rolls to fried clams and fresh oysters, the Cape offers a seafood feast that’s hard to match. Additionally, with its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean, the seafood is often caught the same day it’s served. This ensures maximum freshness and flavor.

Where can I find unique restaurants in Cape Cod?

Cape Cod is renowned for its fresh seafood, especially lobster, clams, and cod. The region boasts a rich maritime heritage, which is reflected in its culinary offerings. From clam chowder and lobster rolls to fried clams and fresh oysters, the Cape offers a seafood feast that’s hard to match. Additionally, with its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean, the seafood is often caught the same day it’s served, ensuring maximum freshness and flavor.

Are there affordable yet unique places to eat in Cape Cod?

Absolutely! While Cape Cod has its share of upscale dining establishments, there are plenty of budget-friendly options that don’t skimp on uniqueness or taste. Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar in Eastham, for instance, offers delicious seafood at wallet-friendly prices in a fun setting with a mini-golf course.

How much does food cost in Cape Cod?

The cost of food in Cape Cod can vary widely based on the type of dining experience you’re seeking, the specific town you’re in, and the season. Here’s a general breakdown:

  1. Casual Dining and Seafood Shacks in Cape Cod:
    • Sandwiches and burgers: $10 – $15
    • Lobster rolls: $20 – $30 (depending on market price and size)
    • Fried seafood platters: $15 – $25
    • Clam chowder: $5 – $10 per bowl
  2. Mid-Range Restaurants:
    • Appetizers: $10 – $15
    • Main courses: $20 – $40
    • Desserts: $7 – $12
  3. Upscale Dining in Cape Cod:
    • Appetizers: $15 – $25
    • Main courses: $30 – $60 (or more for specialty items or large seafood dishes)
    • Desserts: $10 – $15
  4. Beverages:
    • Soft drinks: $2 – $4
    • Beers: $5 – $10
    • Wines: $8 – $15 per glass (with bottles ranging from $30 to several hundred dollars)
  5. Coffee Shops and Bakeries:
    • Coffee: $2 – $5
    • Pastries: $3 – $6
Luxurious beachside seating on Cape Cod.
Luxurious beachside seating on Cape Cod.

What are some hidden gem restaurants in Cape Cod?

Cape Cod is filled with lesser-known spots that locals love. Bangkok Kitchen in Hyannis serves authentic Thai cuisine, while Keltic Kitchen in West Yarmouth offers a taste of Ireland. Exploring off the beaten path can lead to delightful discoveries like these, making your Cape Cod dining experience even more memorable.

Does Cape Cod have good food?

Absolutely! Cape Cod is renowned for its culinary delights, particularly when it comes to seafood. Here’s a taste of what Cape Cod has to offer:

  1. Seafood: Given its coastal location, Cape Cod is a haven for seafood lovers. Fresh catches like lobster, clams, scallops, and cod are staples on local menus. The Cape’s clam chowder, in particular, is legendary and a must-try for visitors.
  2. Lobster Rolls: A quintessential Cape Cod treat. Lobster rolls are served in many local eateries, ranging from upscale restaurants to roadside shacks. They typically consist of chunks of fresh lobster meat, lightly dressed, and served in a toasted bun.
  3. Fried Clams: Another local favorite, fried clams are often served with a side of tartar sauce and are a popular choice at many seafood shacks.
  4. Oysters: The Cape is home to several oyster farms. They produce some of the freshest and most flavorful oysters you can find. Many restaurants offer raw bars where you can sample these briny delicacies.
  5. Cranberries: Beyond seafood, Cape Cod is one of the country’s leading cranberry-growing regions. You’ll find cranberry-based products, from juices to sauces, throughout the Cape.
  6. Bakeries and Sweets: Cape Cod has a rich tradition of homemade baked goods. From Portuguese sweet bread to classic New England pies, there’s no shortage of sweet treats to indulge in.
  7. Local Brews and Wines: The Cape has seen a rise in local breweries and wineries. Sampling local brews or a glass of Cape Cod wine can be a delightful way to wind down after a day of exploring.

Is there a Cape Cod restaurant guide to help me explore?

While this article provides insights into some of the best and most unique restaurants in Cape Cod, there are several local websites, blogs, and publications that offer comprehensive restaurant guides. These resources often include reviews, ratings, and other helpful information to assist you in finding the perfect dining spot.

Can I find fine dining in Cape Cod, Massachusetts?

Yes, Cape Cod boasts several fine dining establishments that cater to those looking for an upscale and memorable dining experience. Restaurants like Bleu in Mashpee and Mac’s Shack in Wellfleet offer gourmet dishes in elegant settings, making them ideal for special occasions or romantic evenings.

Are there scenic places in Cape Cod to eat with ocean views?

Definitely! Cape Cod’s coastline is dotted with restaurants that offer breathtaking ocean views. The Beachcomber in Wellfleet is a prime example, located right on the edge of Cahoon Hollow Beach, providing panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean as you dine.

What seafood is Cape Cod known for?

Cape Cod is renowned for its abundant and fresh seafood, thanks to its prime location along the Atlantic Ocean. Here are some of the seafood staples that Cape Cod is particularly known for:

  1. Lobster: Whether it’s a whole boiled lobster, lobster bisque, or the iconic lobster roll, lobster is a quintessential Cape Cod delicacy.
  2. Clams: Clams are a staple in Cape Cod. They are served in various forms, from fried clam strips to steamers (soft-shell clams) and the famous New England clam chowder. Clam bakes, which often include lobster, potatoes, and corn, are also a popular Cape Cod tradition.
  3. Cod: As the namesake of the region, cod has historically been a significant fish in Cape Cod. It’s often served baked, broiled, or fried.
  4. Oysters: The Cape is home to several oyster farms, especially in areas like Wellfleet. Wellfleet oysters are renowned for their briny flavor and are a favorite in raw bars and restaurants throughout the region.
  5. Scallops: Particularly bay scallops, which are smaller and sweeter than sea scallops, are a sought-after treat when in season.
  6. Mussels: Often steamed in white wine and garlic, mussels are another shellfish commonly found on Cape Cod menus.
  7. Blue Crabs: While not as famous as their Maryland counterparts, blue crabs are still a delightful catch in Cape Cod, often used in crab cakes or enjoyed straight from the shell.
  8. Striped Bass: This fish is popular among anglers and diners alike, known for its firm texture and mild flavor.
  9. Shrimp: While not native to the colder waters of Cape Cod, shrimp is still a popular offering in many seafood restaurants in the area.
  10. Quahogs (Hard-Shell Clams): These are larger clams often used in stuffies (stuffed clams) or chowders.

Concluding Thoughts on Cape Cod’s Unique Restaurants

Cape Cod is a culinary paradise, blending traditional seafood delights with innovative dining experiences. From the freshest seafood at unique restaurants in Cape Cod to the global flavors at hidden spots, every meal here is an adventure.

As you explore, you’ll uncover the best places to eat in Cape Cod, each offering a taste of the region’s rich heritage and diverse culinary scene. So, on your next visit, let your taste buds lead the way and discover the Cape’s gastronomic treasures!

The top restaurants in Cape Cod for all types of travelers
Enjoyed reading about the unique restaurants in Cape Cod? Pin it!

You may also like

Leave a Comment