12 Amazing Things to Do in Islamorada, FL: Top Attractions to Visit

by Jen
Amazing Things to Do in Islamorada, FL
This post may have affiliate links, where I may receive a commission if you purchase through them. Here's our Disclosure and Privacy Policy for more info.

Are you planning to visit Islamorada, FL in the near future? Here are some of the most fun and unique things to do in Islamorada. These breathtaking sights, activities, and attractions are sure to make for an unforgettable vacation experience.

Welcome to Islamorada, a tropical paradise in the heart of the Florida Keys, where the sun’s embrace meets the ocean’s horizon, and palm trees sway in the balmy breeze. Known as the ‘Sportfishing Capital of the World,’ Islamorada beckons anglers, divers, and those seeking authentic Florida charm. In this idyllic destination, you’ll discover a myriad of things to do in Islamorada, from world-class fishing to exploring vibrant marine life and indulging in delicious seafood cuisine.

But don’t be fooled by the laid-back vibes; there’s an undercurrent of adventure that pulses through the veins of this island cluster. From the moment you cross the iconic bridges connecting this “Village of Islands,” you’ll feel a magnetic pull toward the azure waters, beckoning you to explore the untamed beauty beneath the surface. Whether you’re an adrenaline junkie looking to wrestle with a marlin or a culture vulture keen on soaking up local art, Islamorada offers a kaleidoscope of experiences that promise to captivate your senses.

So, grab your flip-flops, slather on some sunscreen, and get ready to uncover the myriad amazing things to do in Islamorada. Trust me, this is one tropical escapade you won’t want to miss! Here’s everything you need to know about these fun things to do in Islamorada, FL.

The top restaurants to visit in Islamorada, FL right now
This article on the unique restaurants in Islamorada, FL contains affiliate links where I may earn a small commission at no cost to you.

Best Places to Visit in Islamorada

Ready to jump into all the coolest things to do in Islamorada, FL? As noted above, there’s something for everyone at this exquisite vacation spot. So keep reading to discover all these unique Islamorada places to visit.

Are you looking to go snorkeling, kayaking, and fishing in the crystal-clear waters? Or would you prefer exploring local art galleries and savoring fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants? Whatever you’re planning, these must-sees in Islamorada can accommodate your needs. Here’s all the best attractions in Islamorada that you should know about.

1. Alligator Reef

If you’re on the hunt for the best things to do in Islamorada that’ll leave you breathless, look no further than a visit to the Alligator Reef. This underwater sanctuary is a diver’s dream come true. Home to a stunning array of marine life, from vibrant coral formations to elusive moray eels, this reef is a treasure trove of natural wonders.

What sets Alligator Reef apart? Well, it’s not just a dive site; it’s a living, breathing underwater museum. The reef got its name from the USS Alligator, a Navy schooner that ran aground in the 1800s. Today, the remnants of the ship serve as a hauntingly beautiful backdrop to the bustling aquatic life.

Whether you’re a seasoned diver or a newbie eager to explore the deep blue, this reef offers a range of diving experiences that cater to all skill levels. And let’s not forget the snorkeling! The shallow areas are perfect for those who prefer to stay closer to the surface but still want a taste of the underwater magic.

So, if you’re crafting that ultimate Islamorada itinerary, make sure to pencil in a visit to Alligator Reef. It’s a must-see, not just for the diving aficionados but for anyone looking to experience the awe-inspiring beauty of the ocean depths.

Exploring Alligator Reef is one of the amazing things to do in Islamorada, Florida.
Discover breathtaking underwater beauty at Alligator Reef, where vibrant coral formations and diverse marine life await divers.

2. Garfield Bight

Ever wondered what to do in Islamorada that’s both serene and adventurous? Kayaking through the mangrove tunnels at Garfield Bight is your answer. Picture this: you’re gliding through narrow waterways, surrounded by lush greenery, as the sun casts dappled light through the canopy of leaves above. It’s like paddling through a natural cathedral, where every twist and turn reveals a new, hidden sanctuary.

Garfield Bight isn’t just another kayaking spot; it’s an ecological marvel. These mangrove forests serve as nurseries for a variety of marine life, from baby fish to crabs. As you paddle, keep your eyes peeled for the occasional manatee or dolphin making a guest appearance.

Islamorada places to visit often focus on the ocean, but Garfield Bight offers a different kind of water experience. It’s a place where you can connect with nature on a deeper level, away from the hustle and bustle of touristy spots.

If you’re sketching out your dream vacation, jot down Garfield Bight as one of the best places to go in Islamorada for a tranquil yet thrilling adventure. It’s an experience that captures the essence of Florida’s unique ecosystems, making it a must-visit for eco-travelers and adventure seekers alike.

3. Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Ah, the golden hour! There’s nothing like watching the sun dip below the horizon, and one of the coolest things to do in Islamorada is to catch this magical moment at Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar. This isn’t just a place to eat; it’s an experience that captures the laid-back, tropical vibe of the Florida Keys.

Imagine sipping on a signature cocktail, your feet in the sand, as the sky turns into a canvas of oranges, pinks, and purples. Live music fills the air, and you can’t help but feel grateful for the beauty surrounding you.

Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar is more than a dining establishment; it’s an Islamorada spot in its own right. The venue hosts various events throughout the year, from fishing tournaments to full moon parties. So, whether you’re a foodie, a sunset chaser, or someone who loves a good party, this spot has something for everyone.

Is it a must-see in Islamorada, FL? Absolutely! The sunsets here are legendary, and the atmosphere is so inviting that you’ll want to come back again and again. It’s the epitome of what makes the Florida Keys special: natural beauty, good vibes, and a sense of community that makes you feel right at home.

Capture the golden hour's magic at Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, where the sunset complements the laid-back Florida Keys vibe.
Capture the golden hour’s magic at Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, where the sunset complements the laid-back Florida Keys vibe.

4. Islamorada’s Famed Waters   

Ready for an adventure in Islamorada, Florida? Known as the “Sportfishing Capital of the World,” this is the place to set sail for an unforgettable fishing expedition. Whether you’re a novice or a seasoned angler, local charters like Robbie’s and Bud N’ Mary’s have you covered. They’ll equip you with everything from bait to tackle and guide you to the best fishing spots.

The variety of fish here is astounding, from vibrant mahi-mahi to majestic sailfish. You’re not just fishing in any part of the Atlantic; you’re in the crystal-clear waters off the Florida Keys, surrounded by stunning coral reefs and occasional dolphin pods. The thrill is palpable the moment you feel that tug on your line. It’s a battle of wits and strength, and reeling in your catch offers an exhilarating sense of accomplishment.

Looking for an unforgettable experience in Islamorada, FL? Look no further. A fishing expedition here is not just about the catch; it’s an immersive adventure in an exceptionally beautiful and exciting environment.

Embark on the ultimate fishing adventure, the "Sportfishing Capital of the World," with expert charters like Robbie's and Bud N' Mary's.
Embark on the ultimate fishing adventure, the “Sportfishing Capital of the World,” with expert charters like Robbie’s and Bud N’ Mary’s.

5. Morada Bay Beach Café

The flavors of the Keys! If you’re a foodie wondering about the Islamorada things to do, then you’re in for a treat. Situated on the sandy shores, Morada Bay Beach Café is more than just a dining spot; it’s an experience. Imagine you’re sitting at a table with your toes in the sand, the ocean breeze gently tousling your hair, and a plate of the freshest seafood in front of you.

But wait, there’s more. As the sun dips below the horizon, the café transforms. Tiki torches light up, casting a warm glow on the sand, and live music fills the air. It’s a magical setting that turns a simple meal into a memorable event.

Why is this one of the unique places in Islamorada, FL? Because it’s not just about the food, which is divine, by the way. It’s about the atmosphere, the views, and that indescribable feeling of pure contentment. Whether you opt for their signature coconut shrimp or go all out with a lobster feast, your taste buds and your soul will thank you.

Savor the taste of the Keys at Morada Bay Beach Café, where dining with your toes in the sand and fresh seafood by the ocean creates a memorable experience for foodies.
Savor the taste of the Keys at Morada Bay Beach Café, where dining with your toes in the sand and fresh seafood by the ocean creates a memorable experience for foodies.

6. The Theater of the Sea

You’ve got to admit, The Theater of the Sea is one of those Islamorada attractions that you just can’t ignore. A place where you can not only witness the majesty of marine life but also interact with it. Yes, you read that right. From swimming with dolphins to painting with sea lions, this place offers a smorgasbord of oceanic adventures.

Now, let’s talk about the shows. The Theater of the Sea showcases some of the most jaw-dropping performances by dolphins, sea lions, and even parrots! It’s like Broadway, but with fins and feathers. And the best part? The theater is committed to animal welfare and conservation, so you can enjoy the spectacle guilt-free.

This is one of those Islamorada things to do that you have to experience to truly appreciate. Whether you’re traveling with kids or just a kid at heart, the Theater of the Sea offers something for everyone. It’s not just an attraction; it’s a celebration of the ocean and all its incredible inhabitants.

Experiencing The Theater of the Sea is one of the amazing things to do in Islamorada, Florida.
The Theater of the Sea is an unmissable attraction, allowing you to not only witness marine life’s majesty but also interact with it.

7. Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park

Hey, history aficionado and nature lovers, this one’s for you! Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park is not just a mouthful to say; it’s a feast for the senses. This place is a living museum, a testament to the Earth’s ancient past.

You’re probably wondering, “What’s so special about a bunch of rocks?” Well, these aren’t just any rocks. They’re fossilized coral reefs, dating back to a time when Florida was underwater. It’s like stepping into a time machine, only instead of buttons and levers, you’ve got hiking trails and interpretive centers.

Thinking of where to go in Islamorada for a mix of education and outdoor fun? Search no more. The park offers guided tours that delve into the geological history of the area, but if you’re more of a lone explorer, you can venture out on your own. Either way, don’t forget to bring your camera; the natural beauty here is Instagram-worthy.

And if you’re thinking this is just for the science geeks among us, think again. The park is also home to a variety of wildlife, from colorful birds to curious raccoons. It’s among the cool destinations in Islamorada, offering a distinctive blend of natural beauty and educational enrichment.

Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park offers a living museum and a testament to Earth's ancient past.
Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park offers a living museum and a testament to Earth’s ancient past.

8. Islander Watersports

Ready to kick your vacation up a notch? Islander Watersports is the place to be. Envision this: the sun is shining, the water is sparkling, and you’re gliding across the ocean on a jet ski. Sounds like a dream, right? Well, it’s time to turn that dream into reality.

Wondering about the coolest things to do in Islamorada, you ask? You don’t have to search anywhere else. From paddleboarding to parasailing, this place has it all. And don’t worry if you’re a newbie; the friendly staff will make sure you’re comfortable and safe, so you can focus on having the time of your life.

If you’re a fan of sailing, you can even rent a boat for the day. Picture yourself as the captain, steering through the turquoise waters, exploring hidden coves and secluded beaches. It’s an experience you won’t soon forget.

So, why settle for the ordinary when you can have the extraordinary? Islander Watersports is more than just a destination; it’s an adventure waiting to happen.

Elevate your vacation at Islander Watersports, where you can turn the dream of gliding across the ocean on a jet ski under the shining sun into a thrilling reality.
Elevate your vacation at Islander Watersports, where you can turn the dream of gliding across the ocean on a jet ski under the shining sun into a thrilling reality.

9. Islamorada Farmers Market

Ah, the Islamorada Farmers Market—a feast for the senses and a must-see in Islamorada, FL. You know that moment when you stumble upon something so authentic, so purely local, that you can’t help but feel like you’ve discovered a hidden gem? That’s the vibe here.

From the moment you step in, the air fills with the aroma of freshly baked bread, tropical fruits, and local spices. Your eyes dart from one colorful stall to another, each offering a unique slice of Florida Keys culture. It’s not just a market; it’s a microcosm of the community’s soul.

Thinking of a thing to do in Islamorada on a lazy Sunday? This is your answer. Whether you’re a foodie in search of the perfect organic avocado or a traveler looking for handcrafted souvenirs, this market has something for everyone. And let’s not forget the live music that adds a rhythmic backdrop to your shopping experience.

Go ahead, indulge in some retail therapy, the Islamorada way. The Farmers Market isn’t just a place to buy things; it’s a place to feel, to experience, and most importantly, to enjoy.

Discover a hidden gem at the Islamorada Farmers Market, a must-see where authentic and purely local experiences delight the senses.
Discover a hidden gem at the Islamorada Farmers Market, a must-see where authentic and purely local experiences delight the senses.

10. Keys History & Discovery Center

Ever wondered about the rich tapestry of history and culture that makes Islamorada so captivating? Well, the Keys History & Discovery Center is your gateway to unraveling these mysteries. This isn’t just a museum; it’s a time capsule that takes you on a journey through the Keys’ storied past.

Many of the attractions in Islamorada frequently center around the ocean, but here, you’ll find a balanced narrative that includes everything from the indigenous peoples to the pirates who once roamed these waters. You’ll even get a glimpse into the area’s ecological wonders.

The center’s interactive exhibits make it even more exciting for families and history enthusiasts alike. Imagine touching a 16th-century cannon or listening to the haunting tales of shipwrecks. It’s like stepping into a different era, yet feeling strangely at home.

If you’re the kind of traveler who loves to dig deep and get the full story, this is where to go in Islamorada, FL. And hey, don’t forget to check out their celestial events. Ever watched the stars from the middle of an island? It’s magical, to say the least.

Unlock the captivating history and culture of Islamorada at the Keys History & Discovery Center, a time capsule museum that immerses you in the storied past.
Unlock the captivating history and culture of Islamorada at the Keys History & Discovery Center, a time capsule museum that immerses you in the storied past.

11. Anne’s Beach

You’re walking barefoot on soft, white sand, the sun casting its golden glow on your skin. Welcome to Anne’s Beach, a slice of paradise that offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle. This isn’t just a beach; it’s a sanctuary for your soul.

What sets Anne’s Beach apart from other best places in Islamorada is its untouched beauty. No high-rises, no noisy crowds, just you and the rhythmic sound of the waves. It’s the perfect backdrop for a romantic picnic or a solitary moment of reflection.

The shallow waters make it an ideal spot for paddleboarding or simply wading with the little ones. And if you’re into photography, the sunsets here are nothing short of spectacular.

Those unique things to do in Islamorada often involve water, but Anne’s Beach offers a different kind of aquatic experience. It’s less about the adrenaline and more about the zen. So, if you’re looking to recharge your batteries, both physically and spiritually, this is your haven.

Anne's Beach is a tranquil, soul-soothing paradise offering a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of life.
Anne’s Beach is a tranquil, soul-soothing paradise offering a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of life.

The Rain Barrel Sculpture Gallery—it’s not just a gallery, it’s an experience. A place where art and nature collide, creating a vibrant tapestry of colors, textures, and forms. This is where to visit in Islamorada if you’re an art enthusiast or simply someone who appreciates the finer things in life.

You’ll be greeted by “Betsy,” the colossal spiny lobster sculpture that’s become an iconic Islamorada destination. But don’t just stop at the entrance; the real magic lies within. Wander through the labyrinth of local art, handcrafted jewelry, and one-of-a-kind sculptures that tell the story of the Keys in the most artistic way possible.

Thinking of what to do if you’re not into art? Don’t fret. The lush gardens surrounding the gallery are a spectacle in themselves. It’s like walking through a living canvas, where every plant, every stone has been placed with intention.

Most of the coolest activities in Islamorada often involve the sea, but here, it’s all about celebrating the land and the people who make it extraordinary. So, whether you’re an art aficionado or a casual observer, the Rain Barrel Sculpture Gallery offers a feast for your eyes and soul. Is this gallery among the top things to do in Islamorada, Florida? You bet!

The Rain Barrel Sculpture Gallery is one of the amazing things to do in Islamorada, Florida.
The Rain Barrel Sculpture Gallery is not just a gallery but a vibrant collision of art and nature.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about the Amazing Things to Do in Islamorada

Looking for more content on the top things to do in Islamorada, FL? Here are some popular questions (and answers) I get that will help you plan your trip to Islamorada:

What’s the best time to visit Islamorada?

The best time to visit Islamorada, FL, is during the winter months, from November to April. This period offers pleasant weather with lower humidity and fewer chances of rain, making it ideal for outdoor activities and enjoying the beautiful Florida Keys. Avoiding hurricane season (June to November) is advisable.

How do you spend an amazing day in Islamorada Florida?

Islamorada, often referred to as the “Village of Islands,” is a beautiful destination in the Florida Keys known for its stunning beaches, clear waters, and a laid-back tropical vibe. Here’s how you can spend an amazing day in Islamorada:

Morning:

  • Sunrise: Start your day early by heading to Anne’s Beach to catch a breathtaking sunrise. The beach is lined with boardwalks, and the shallow waters make it a peaceful spot to relax.
  • Breakfast: After the sunrise, head to Mangrove Mike’s Cafe for a hearty breakfast. They offer a variety of breakfast options, from omelets to pancakes.
  • Robbie’s of Islamorada: Visit Robbie’s to feed the tarpons, a popular activity in Islamorada. For a few dollars, you can buy a bucket of fish and feed these massive creatures from the dock.

Afternoon:

  • Sportfishing or Snorkeling: Islamorada is known as the “Sportfishing Capital of the World.” Book a half-day fishing charter to experience deep-sea fishing. Alternatively, opt for a snorkeling trip to explore the vibrant marine life of the Florida Keys.
  • Lunch: Enjoy a beachside lunch at Morada Bay Beach Café. The café offers a mix of seafood and other dishes, and the view is unbeatable.
  • Visit the History of Diving Museum: Learn about the history of diving, from ancient times to modern-day scuba diving. The museum has an impressive collection of artifacts and exhibits.
  • Relax: Spend some time at Founders Park, a 40-acre park with a beach, pool, sports facilities, and more. It’s a great spot to relax and soak in the sun.

Evening:

  • Dinner: Treat yourself to a delicious dinner at Chef Michael’s. Their seafood, especially the hogfish, is a must-try.
  • Sunset: End your day with a stunning sunset view at the Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar. They often have live music in the evenings, adding to the ambiance.

How many days is enough in Islamorada?

The ideal length of stay in Islamorada, Florida, really depends on what you want to experience and how leisurely you’d like your pace to be. However, for most visitors, 2 to 4 days is a good amount of time to spend in Islamorada to enjoy its main attractions and activities without feeling rushed.

Here’s a breakdown of what you can do based on the number of days:

1 Day:

  • Morning sunrise at Anne’s Beach.
  • Visit Robbie’s of Islamorada to feed the tarpons.
  • Lunch at a local eatery like Morada Bay Beach Café.
  • Afternoon at Founders Park or a snorkeling trip.
  • Dinner and sunset at Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar.

2 Days:

  • All of the above, plus:
  • A half-day fishing charter or a visit to the Theater of the Sea.
  • Explore the History of Diving Museum.
  • Kayaking or paddleboarding in the calm waters.

3-4 Days:

  • All of the above, plus:
  • Take a day trip to nearby keys, such as Key Largo or Marathon.
  • Spend more time on water activities, like jet skiing, parasailing, or diving.
  • Explore art galleries and shops in the area.
  • Relax and enjoy more beach time or pool time at your resort/hotel.
  • Try more local restaurants and cuisines.

How do I get around Islamorada?

To get around Islamorada, the most convenient option is to rent a car, allowing you flexibility to explore the Florida Keys. Alternatively, you can use taxis or ride-sharing services. Bicycles and golf carts are popular for short trips within the town, and many accommodations offer shuttle services.

Is Islamorada family-friendly?

Yes, Islamorada is a family-friendly destination. It offers a range of activities suitable for families, including water sports, nature exploration, and wildlife encounters. The relaxed atmosphere, beautiful beaches, and family-oriented attractions like animal encounters and museums make it a great choice for a family vacation.

Islander Resort in Islamorada, Florida, features a beachfront resort with palm trees and stunning ocean views
Islander Resort in Islamorada, Florida, features a beachfront resort with palm trees and stunning ocean views

What are the must-see attractions in Islamorada?

Must-see attractions in Islamorada include Theater of the Sea, where you can swim with dolphins, the History of Diving Museum, offering a fascinating glimpse into underwater exploration, and Robbie’s of Islamorada for tarpon feeding. Also, don’t miss exploring the pristine beaches, snorkeling at Alligator Reef, and indulging in fresh seafood at local eateries.

What is Islamorada known for?

Islamorada, often dubbed the “Sportfishing Capital of the World,” is renowned for its stunning coral reefs, exceptional fishing opportunities, and laid-back island lifestyle. Located in the Florida Keys, it’s a paradise for water sports enthusiasts, offering activities like snorkeling, kayaking, and boating amidst breathtaking natural beauty.

Is there a lot to do in Islamorada?

Yes, Islamorada offers a variety of activities and attractions for visitors. While it’s known for its laid-back atmosphere, there’s plenty to see and do in this part of the Florida Keys. Here are some of the top activities and attractions in Islamorada:

  1. Water Activities: Being an island, water-based activities are a major draw. This includes:
    • Sportfishing: Islamorada is often referred to as the “Sportfishing Capital of the World.”
    • Snorkeling and Diving: The clear waters around Islamorada are home to beautiful coral reefs and marine life.
    • Kayaking and Paddleboarding: Explore the calm waters and mangrove tunnels.
  2. Robbie’s of Islamorada: A popular spot where you can feed tarpons, shop at the open-air market, and dine by the water.
  3. Theater of the Sea: An interactive marine park where you can watch dolphin and sea lion shows, swim with dolphins, sea lions, and stingrays, and take a bottomless boat ride.
  4. History of Diving Museum: Learn about the evolution of diving, from ancient times to the modern era.
  5. Indian Key Historic State Park: Accessible only by boat, this island was once the county seat for Dade County. It’s a great place for history buffs and those looking to hike and explore.
  6. Anne’s Beach: A beautiful beach with shallow waters, perfect for relaxation and picnicking.
  7. Founders Park: A community park with a beach, pool, sports facilities, and a marina.
  8. Breweries and Distilleries: Places like the Islamorada Beer Company and the Florida Keys Distillery offer tours and tastings.
  9. Art Galleries: Islamorada has a vibrant arts scene with several galleries showcasing local artists.
  10. Dining: Enjoy fresh seafood at various restaurants, from casual eateries to upscale dining. Popular spots include Morada Bay Beach Café, Chef Michael’s, and the Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar.

Is Islamorada worth visiting?

Absolutely, Islamorada is a must-visit for anyone seeking a blend of adventure and relaxation. With its world-class fishing, crystal-clear waters for snorkeling and diving, and a variety of unique local eateries, it offers a quintessential Florida Keys experience. It’s a slice of paradise that’s definitely worth the trip.

Final Thoughts on Visiting Islamorada

So, there you have it, my wanderlust warriors—a comprehensive guide to the coolest things to do in Islamorada, FL. Whether you’re an adrenaline junkie, a nature lover, or a laid-back lounger, this Floridian paradise has something for you. From the moment you step foot on this island, you’ll feel like you’ve entered a different world—one where the worries of everyday life simply drift away with the tide.

Islamorada isn’t just a destination; it’s a state of mind. It’s where you go to escape the ordinary and embrace the extraordinary. So, pack your bags, grab your sunscreen, and get ready to dive into an unforgettable adventure. Islamorada is calling, and trust me, you’ll want to answer.

The top restaurants in Islamorada, FL for all types of travelers
Enjoyed reading about the unique restaurants in Islamorada, FL? Pin it!

You may also like

Leave a Comment