13 Breathtaking Lake Houses You Can Rent in Indiana

2.7K

Indiana Lakes seriously surprised me, and I mean that in the best possible way. From watching the sunset over Lake Monroe to kayaking through the crystal waters of Lake Wawasee, I’ve discovered some of the best places in Indiana where you can escape the everyday and truly unwind. Trust me, these lakes offer something special that’ll make you rethink everything you thought you knew about the Midwest.

After comparing countless lakefront rentals and diving deep into reviews, I’ve found the absolute winners that’ll give you that perfect lake life experience. Picture waking up in a modern Lake Wawasee house where your deck hovers right over the water or spending evenings at a Lake Monroe cottage watching boats glide by as the sky turns golden. These rentals aren’t just places to stay; they’re your gateway to Indiana’s incredible lake scene.

Top Indiana Lake Cabin Rentals: The Best Lakeside Homes in 2025

Here are the best lake rentals in Indiana by category, considering factors including amenities, trip types, and budgets. The subsequent sections will cover each listing in more detail.

• Best Lake House for Sleek Design: The Heron House at Waldron Lake
• Top Lake House in Indiana for Seclusion: 2-Bedroom Lake View Cabin
• Best Rental for Space: Craftsman-Style Indiana Lake House with Space for 14
• Perfect Lake House in Indiana for Families: Modern Lake House with Hot Tub
• Top Lake House Rental for Private Lake Access: Two-Bedroom Rental
• Lake House on Lake Freeman: Waterfront Monticello Lake Rental
• Lake House with Best Water Vistas: Lake House Escape with Designer Finishes
• Most Elegant Lake House Rental in Indiana: Jimmerson Blue
• Best Lake House for New Remodels: 4-Bedroom Indiana Lake Cabin with a View
• Lake House with Cheery Open-Concept Space: 1-Bedroom Rental
• Top Lake House for Sunset Views: Cottage on Lake Tippecanoe
• Best Lake House for Rent in Indiana with Rustic Luxury: Lake Cabin in Indiana on Lake Freeman
• Lake House on the Lake James Chain: 6-Bedroom Jimmerson Lake Home with Hot Tub & Pool

Best Lake Houses to Rent in Indiana: The Top IN Rentals in 2025

Getting away to a luxury lake house has never felt so refreshing! With our list of the 13 best Indiana lake cabin rentals, you’ll be treated to gorgeous views of the water and seclusion from the world behind thick trees. Check out all 13 options below!

1. Luxury Lakefront Escape on Lake Freeman

• 📍 Location: Monticello, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $506/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 15 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private waterfront, boathouse with dock, wraparound deck, luxury chalet-style design
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family getaways 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, corporate retreats 🏡, lake lovers 🌊

Nestled in a peaceful cove on Lake Freeman, this stunning 3800 sq ft estate offers the perfect blend of relaxation and adventure. The spacious Great Room features a beamed cathedral ceiling, a Wisconsin River Rock fireplace, and a large flat-screen TV with seating for eight. 

The open-concept kitchen and dining area make entertaining effortless, while the 1,000 sq ft wraparound deck invites you to dine, unwind, and take in the scenic lake views.

Step outside to enjoy private waterfront access, a boathouse with a dock, and a gas BBQ for outdoor gatherings. Spend your days boating, fishing, or exploring nearby attractions like Whyte Horse Winery (16 min drive), Lake Shafer (22 min drive), and Indiana Beach Amusement Resort (24 min drive). 

Whether you’re looking for a fun-filled getaway or a peaceful retreat, this luxury lakefront home is the ultimate escape.

2. Lakefront Retreat on Jimmerson Lake

• 📍 Location: Fremont, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $574/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 18 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private dock, heated pool (May–Oct), hot tub, game room, fire pit
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family getaways 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, lake adventures 🚤, relaxation & fun 🎯

Welcome to this spacious 6-bedroom, 4-bathroom lakefront retreat on Jimmerson Lake, offering 4,600 sq ft of living space. Perfect for large groups or families, this home blends modern comfort with lakeside fun.

Inside, the newly remodeled kitchen features granite countertops and stunning lake views, while two separate living rooms with flat-screen TVs provide ample space to relax. The upper-level game area, complete with a pool table, hoop shoot game, and dartboard, offers entertainment for all ages.

Step outside, and you’re greeted by an expansive patio with a hot tub, fire pit, and dining areas—perfect for unwinding. The heated pool (open May–October, weather permitting) and private dock with kayak access make it easy to enjoy the water.

Nearby, you’ll find attractions like Pokagon State Park (10 minutes), Trine University (16 minutes), and plenty of shopping and dining options. Whether you’re seeking adventure or relaxation, this Jimmerson Lake retreat is the perfect place to create unforgettable memories. 

3. The Heron House at  Waldron Lake

• 📍 Location: Wawaka, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $502/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 16 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private sandy beach, lakefront views, fire pit, high-speed WiFi, pet-friendly
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family gatherings 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, lake getaways 🌊, outdoor relaxation 🌅

Welcome to The Heron House, a newly built lakefront retreat on Waldron Lake. This 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home offers stunning lake views and a private sandy beach, making it an ideal spot for group gatherings.

The main-floor master suite features a king bed and en suite bath, while two upstairs bedrooms offer beautiful views of the lake.

Step outside to enjoy the back porch, fire pit, and beachfront area—perfect for watching the sunset or letting the kids play in the shallow, clear water. You can also take advantage of on-site kayaks and canoes for lake adventures. 

Nearby attractions include Sylvan Lake (11 min drive), Gene Stratton-Porter State Historic Site (13 min drive), and Witmer Lake (17 min drive). With high-speed WiFi, Dish TV, and pet-friendly accommodations, The Heron House is the perfect place to relax, unwind, and create lasting memories by the lake.

4. Lake Cottage on Lake Tippecanoe

• 📍 Location: Leesburg, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $360/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private dock, wood-burning fireplace, lakefront views, sandy swim area, boating access
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family vacations 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, lake adventures 🚤, unplugged retreats 🌅

Nestled along the shores of Lake Tippecanoe, Indiana’s deepest natural lake, this cozy 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom cottage is perfect for all-season getaways. Nicknamed “The Leaning Oak,” the home features a spacious open-concept living area with a wood-burning fireplace, ideal for fall and winter stays.

In the summer, enjoy direct lake access, a private dock, and a sandy swimming area—perfect for families. Bring your boat or rent one, as three public boat launches are nearby. Spend your days boating, fishing, or swimming, then unwind on the patio while watching stunning sunsets over the water.

This peaceful retreat encourages you to unplug, with no WiFi available, allowing you to fully relax. Nearby attractions include Tippecanoe Lake (1-minute walk), Dewart Lake (7-minute drive), and Lake Wawasee (19-minute drive). Create lasting memories in this beautiful lakefront escape.

5. Poplar Ridge Hideaway

• 📍 Location: Jasonville, IN, near Shakamak State Park
• 💵 Price Per Night: $225/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private 6-acre lake, secluded 20-acre wooded retreat, stocked fishing lake, hiking trails, game room, pet-friendly
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family getaways 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, fishing trips 🎣, nature retreats 🌿, pet owners 🐾

Escape to Poplar Ridge Hideaway, a peaceful lakeside retreat nestled on 20 wooded acres in the heart of Southern Indiana. This charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom cabin comfortably accommodates up to 8 guests, offering a perfect blend of seclusion and convenience.

Located just 11 minutes from Shakamak State Park and 14 miles from Goose Pond Wildlife Refuge, this property provides easy access to hiking, birdwatching, and outdoor adventures. 

The cozy cabin features a fully stocked kitchen, a comfortable living area with a wood pellet stove, and a game room for indoor entertainment.

What makes it special?
✔️ Private 6-acre lake with great fishing
✔️ Hiking trails through beautiful hardwood forests
✔️ Pet-friendly with space for up to 2 dogs
✔️ Outdoor fire pit & Blackstone grill for cookouts

Poplar Ridge Hideaway offers the perfect balance of privacy and accessibility, with shopping and dining just 15 minutes away in Linton, IN. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat or an outdoor adventure, this lakefront cabin is the ideal destination for your next getaway.

6. Large Craftsman Style Lake House

• 📍 Location: Columbia City, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $541/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 10 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: 3300 sq ft Craftsman-style home, chef’s kitchen, two-way gas fireplace, walk-in rain showers, lake access with sandy beach
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, lake lovers 🛶, all-season getaways ❄️☀️

Welcome to your all-season lakefront escape on Big Cedar Lake. This spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bath Craftsman-style home offers stunning lake views, modern amenities, and cozy spaces for family and friends to gather.

Enjoy 3,300 sq ft of comfort, featuring a chef’s kitchen with a granite island and 6-burner stove, large bedrooms, and spa-like bathrooms with rain head showers and a soaking tub. The two-way gas fireplace connects the main living areas, perfect for relaxing after a day on the water.

Step outside to a shallow swimming area just off the shore, ideal for kids and floating, with 10 ft depth at the pier. Big Cedar Lake offers peaceful boating from 1–4 PM and calm, no-wake waters the rest of the day.

Nearby, explore trails at Chain O’ Lakes State Park or take a day trip to Webster Lake and Lake Wawasee. From lake days to winter retreats, this home is the perfect setting for memory-making in every season.

7. Tippy Cottage on the Lake

• 📍 Location: Tippecanoe Lake, Leesburg, IN
•  💵 Price Per Night: $420/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 12 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Lakefront views, private pier, newly renovated, efficiency kitchen, screened-in deck, access to marinas
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family vacations 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, water sports enthusiasts 🚤, relaxing getaways 🛶

If you’re looking for a family-friendly lakefront retreat, Tippy Cottage on the Lake is the perfect getaway. This bright, 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers stunning lakefront views, a private pier for your boat, and spacious living areas ideal for both relaxation and entertaining.

The main level features an open-concept living room, dining area, and kitchen, while the lower level offers a cozy family room and additional bedrooms. Relax on the screened-in deck or take a short walk down to the lake.

Located just 1 minute from Tippecanoe Lake, 6 minutes from Chapman Lakes, and 19 minutes from Lake Wawasee, this cottage provides easy access to boat rentals, marinas, and local dining. 

Explore the Tippy Winery, enjoy a scenic drive to Lake Wawasee, or visit Notre Dame University, all just a short drive away. Whether you’re spending your days on the water or exploring nearby attractions, this cottage is the perfect base for creating unforgettable memories.

8. Cozy Waterfront Lake House Home

• 📍 Location: Syracuse, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $227/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Step-free access, boat dock, fire pit, channel to Syracuse Lake
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 🏖️, water sports enthusiasts 🚤, those seeking relaxation by the lake 🌅

Welcome to this charming waterfront retreat, ideally located just steps from Syracuse Lake. This cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offers 672 sq ft of living space, perfect for small families or groups. 

Inside, you’ll find a cozy living room with a sleeper sofa, a smart TV, and a fully equipped kitchen for home-cooked meals. The two comfortable bedrooms feature a queen bed and two twin beds, accommodating up to 6 guests.

Step outside to enjoy the private patio, fire pit, and boat dock with easy access to the channel leading directly to Syracuse Lake. The lake is just a 1-minute walk away, and Lakeside Park (14-minute walk) and Lake Wawasee (15-minute walk) are nearby for additional outdoor fun.

Whether you’re boating, fishing, or simply unwinding by the fire, this home provides the perfect lakeside retreat.

9. Luxury Lakefront Retreat with Private Dock

• 📍 Location: Jimmerson Lake, Angola, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $645/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private dock for two boats, two full kitchens, butler’s pantry, upper and lower decks, fire table
• 🌟 Perfect For: Boating enthusiasts 🚤, lakefront relaxation 🌅, family vacations 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦

Welcome to this beautiful lakefront retreat on Jimmerson Lake, where relaxation and adventure meet. This spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect escape with stunning water views, a private dock, and multiple outdoor spaces for dining and lounging.

The main level features a gourmet kitchen with a wet bar, wine chiller, and butler’s pantry with a second stove and refrigerator, making meal prep a breeze.

The great room boasts cathedral ceilings and a dining area for 8, plus access to the full-width upper deck. The lakeside master suite offers private deck access and incredible sunset views.

Downstairs, you’ll find a second living room, additional dining space, a kitchenette, and two cozy bedrooms, all leading to the covered patio with a fire table, just steps from the dock..Located just minutes from Trine University, Pokagon State Park, and local dining, this retreat is the perfect lakeside getaway.

10. Lakefront Retreat with Hot Tub, Beach, and Firepit

• 📍 Location: Monticello, IN, near Lake Shafer
• 💵 Price Per Night: $481/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 15 guests 
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private beach, hot tub with lake views, swingset, outdoor games, firepit
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family reunions 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, large groups 👫, lakefront relaxation 🌊

Welcome to this brand-new, custom-designed lake house, perfect for large families or groups, accommodating up to 15 guests. The spacious home includes a main house and an attached in-law suite for added privacy. 

Inside, you’ll find luxurious touches like granite countertops, hardwood floors, and high-end furnishings from Restoration Hardware and Pottery Barn, creating a family-friendly atmosphere.

Enjoy 180-degree views of Lake Shafer, just a short walk to the water, with over 100 feet of private lakefront. You can dock your boat, relax on the private beach, or unwind on the large outdoor deck.

Nearby attractions like Lake Shafer, High-Speed Naskart Go-Kart Racing, and Indiana Beach Amusement Resort are just a short walk away, offering endless entertainment. Whether you’re enjoying lake activities or relaxing by the fire, this lake house is the perfect getaway.

11. Cozy Sunset Lake View Home

• 📍 Location: LaPorte, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $604/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 8 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Beach access, gas grill, outdoor spa tub, king beds in every bedroom, screened porch with sunset views
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 🏖️, beach lovers 🌊, relaxation seekers 🌅

Welcome to this charming 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom vacation home offering serene sunset lake views and an unbeatable location just minutes from the beach. Designed for comfort, the spacious home features king beds in every bedroom, making it ideal for families or groups of up to 8 guests.

Relax in the cozy living area or step outside to the screened porch, where you can enjoy stunning sunsets over the lake. For a truly relaxing experience, take a dip in the outdoor spa tub or gather around the gas grill for a cookout. 

The property also offers easy access to Pine Lake (5 minutes), Legacy Hills Golf Club (6 minutes), and the LaPorte Municipal Airport (6 minutes).

Whether you’re unwinding by the lake, exploring nearby attractions, or enjoying a sunset from the porch, this home is the perfect spot to relax and embrace the tranquility of nature.

12. Cozy Lake Retreat

• 📍 Location: Monticello, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $557/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 10 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: 4000 sq ft home, multi-level decks, panoramic lake views, gas grill, spacious layout for families
• 🌟 Perfect For: Large families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, lake lovers 🚤, Indiana Beach visitors 🎢

Welcome to your Lake Shafer retreat—an expansive 5-bedroom, 3-bath home with breathtaking water views and space to relax, recharge, and reconnect. With 4,000 square feet of living space, this lakefront getaway is ideal for groups and multi-family vacations.

Inside, enjoy a bright open layout with a fully equipped kitchen, multiple lounging areas, and large windows that showcase the lake.

Step outside to relax on the spacious decks, fire up the gas grill, or enjoy morning coffee with a view. Easy access to the lake makes it perfect for swimming, boating, or just soaking up the peaceful surroundings.

Nearby, enjoy rides and fun at Indiana Beach Amusement Resort, or tee off at Tippecanoe Country Club. Explore Lake Shafer by boat, or spend a day fishing and sunbathing. From thrill-seekers to those who just want to unwind, this home offers the perfect setting for lakefront memories.

13. Lakefront Cottage

• 📍 Location: Columbia City, IN
• 💵 Price Per Night: $190/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 7 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private lake access, screened porch, vaulted ceilings, 55-acre private lake
• 🌟 Perfect For: Family getaways 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, fishing trips 🎣, lake lovers 🌅

Welcome to this charming lakeside cottage on the shores of Big Barbee Lake, offering a peaceful retreat surrounded by nature. Perfect for families or groups, this fully remodeled two-bedroom home blends modern comforts with a serene lakeside setting.

Inside, the vaulted ceilings and spacious living areas provide plenty of room to relax and unwind. The main bedroom features a king bed, while the second bedroom offers a double and queen bed, comfortably sleeping up to 6 guests.

Step outside and you’ll find direct access to Big Barbee Lake, with opportunities for fishing and relaxing by the water. Explore nearby lakes like Webster Lake (20 minutes) and Lake Wawasee (27 minutes), or simply enjoy the natural beauty of this tranquil location. 

Whether you’re fishing, hiking, or soaking in the surroundings, this lakeside cottage offers the perfect getaway for making lasting memories.