13 Lake House Rentals in Indiana: Top Lakefront Homes in IN

by clients@lseo.com
the elegant bathroom of one of the Indiana lake house rentals

Dreaming of visiting Indiana in the near future? Looking to stay in a lake house rental in Indiana with gorgeous waterfront views? Experience the best that the Midwest has to offer from one of these Indiana lakefront rentals on Vrbo.

Indiana is full of natural wonders, including beautiful lakes where you can enjoy activities year-round. Outdoor lovers can pack their itinerary with boating, fishing, and swimming adventures, then retreat to one of these top-rated rentals for a memorable getaway.

Just like many of the Vrbo cabins for rent in Indiana, these rental homes offer prime waterfront access, family-friendly perks, and luxury amenities, including private hot tubs and outdoor pools. With fire pits, game rooms, and beach areas, these lake-view homes, cabins, and cottages have everything you need to reconnect with nature in Indiana.

an evening shot of one of the homes
Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links, where I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Top Indiana Lake Cabin Rentals: The Best Lakeside Homes in 2022

Here are the best lake rentals in Indiana by category, considering factors including amenities, trip types, and budgets. The subsequent sections will cover each listing in more detail.

Best Lake House for Sleek Design: The Heron House at Waldron Lake

Top Lake House in Indiana for Seclusion: 2-Bedroom Lake View Cabin

Best Rental for Space: Craftsman-Style Indiana Lake House with Space for 14

Perfect Lake House in Indiana for Families: Modern Lake House with Hot Tub

Top Lake House Rental for Private Lake Access: Two-Bedroom Rental

Lake House on Lake Freeman: Waterfront Monticello Lake Rental

Lake House with Best Water Vistas: Lake House Escape with Designer Finishes

Most Elegant Lake House Rental in Indiana: Jimmerson Blue

Best Lake House for New Remodels: 4-Bedroom Indiana Lake Cabin with a View

Lake House with Cheery Open-Concept Space: 1-Bedroom Rental

Top Lake House for Sunset Views: Cottage on Lake Tippecanoe

Best Lake House for Rent in Indiana with Rustic Luxury: Lake Cabin in Indiana on Lake Freeman

Lake House on the Lake James Chain: 6-Bedroom Jimmerson Lake Home with Hot Tub & Pool

Best Lake Houses to Rent in Indiana: The Top IN Rentals in 2022

Getting away to a luxury lake house has never felt so refreshing! With our list of the 13 best Indiana lake cabin rentals, you’ll be treated to gorgeous views of the water and seclusion from the world behind thick trees. Check out all 13 options below!

1. Rustic Luxury Lake House Rental in Indiana – Estate on Lake Freeman

Location: Carroll County, Indiana

Rates from: $499 per night

Accommodates: 15 guests

a sunny view of the lake house rental in Indiana
The lake house from the back | Credit: VRBO
the living area of the house, showing the couch and TV
The home’s living area | Credit: VRBO

Offering enough space for a large group of up to 15 guests, this large five-bedroom lake house rental in Indiana sits right on the waterfront. Nestled in a quiet cove on Lake Freeman, you can enjoy luxury indoor and outdoor spaces as well as enticing amenities, such as a 1,000 square foot wrap-around deck, gas BBQ grill, private waterfront access, and a boathouse.

Rent a pontoon boat for the day, or stay indoors to enjoy the home’s open floor plan that includes a floor-to-ceiling fireplace, large flat-screen TV, and a gourmet kitchen.

2. Indiana Lake House on Jimmerson Lake – Hot Tub, Pool & Game Room

Location: Jamestown, Indiana

Rates from: $432 per night

Accommodates: 18 guests

the lake rental in Indiana with the pool and private dock nearby
The lake house with the dock nearby | Credit: VRBO
the lake house's cozy living area
The relaxing interior of the house | Credit: VRBO

One of the most popular lake house rentals in Indiana, this six-bedroom retreat is popular for many reasons. The lakefront home sits on Jimmerson Lake on the Lake James chain and has tons of indoor living space, including two separate living rooms and an upper-level entertainment area with a pool table, hoop shoot game, and dartboard.

However, it’s the outdoor area that sets this rental apart from others, as it includes a spacious patio with ample seating, umbrellas, and a minibar, as well as a tree swing and fire pit area. There’s even a seasonal outdoor pool and year-round hot tub available. 

3. Lake Rental in Indiana – The Heron House at Waldron Lake

Location: Wawaka, Indiana

Rates from: $599 per night

Accommodates: 16 guests

the fire pit outside the lake house rental in Indiana
The fire pit outside the house | Credit: VRBO
the rental home's dining room table
The house’s dining room | Credit: VRBO

With an ultra-sleek interior design, this five-bedroom lake rental in Indiana also offers incredible lake views. You can sit on the back porch and watch the sunset and let the kids play in the sand at the private beach area.

Sit around the campfire and roast s’mores, then head inside to enjoy the open concept interior that includes a modern kitchen and dining area. Its comfy living room features a flat-screen TV and lake views, and a handful of the rooms also look out onto the water.

4. Lake Cottage with Amazing Sunset View on Lake Tippecanoe

Location: Leesburg, Indiana

Rates from: $298 per night

Accommodates: 8 guests

a view of the lake house rental in Indiana sitting among trees
The rental house among trees | Credit: VRBO
the cheery kitchen of the home
The inviting kitchen of the rental | Credit: VRBO

Set on the shores of beautiful Lake Tippecanoe, this Indiana lake house offers access to the deepest natural lake in Indiana. Nicknamed the ‘Leaning Oak’, the three-bedroom property features an open concept kitchen, family, and dining area with a large wood-burning fireplace on the main floor.

In the summer months, you’ll have access to a private dock where you can keep a rental boat or bring your own watercraft, as the lake has three public boat launches. The house also offers access to a shallow, sandy swim area for little ones.

5. Lake View Cabin – Secluded Indiana Lake House

Location: Sullivan County, Indiana

Rates from: $295 per night

Accommodates: 8 guests

a sunny view of the Indiana lake house among trees
Sunny view of the lake house | Credit: VRBO
the cozy and rustic living room of the lake house
The rental’s rustic interior | Credit: VRBO

Those looking for a secluded lake house to rent in Indiana can’t go wrong here. Get off the grid at this two-bedroom retreat, which sits on 20 wooded acres and includes a six-acre lake. Set in the heart of Southern Indiana’s outdoor recreation region, this secluded getaway is a dream for nature lovers.

The lake is known for its great fishing opportunities, while hiking trails lead to scenic forest landscapes and wildlife viewing. The cabin itself has everything you need for a nature escape, including an outdoor deck, fully stocked kitchen, coffee maker, BBQ grill, and fire pit.

6. Fully Remodeled Lake House Rental in Indiana with a View

Location: Columbia City, Indiana

Rates from: $340 per night

Accommodates: 8 guests

the dark blue Indiana lake house from the front
The cozy lake house | Credit: VRBO
the lake house's modern kitchen, showing the appliances
The modern kitchen of the lake house | Credit: VRBO

Enjoy lakeside living from this four-bedroom lake rental in Indiana, which can accommodate up to eight guests in its four-bedroom layout. The charming house is located on Big Cedar Lake, an all-sport lake where you can enjoy hours of water activities.

The pet-friendly space boasts a spacious wrap-around deck and 120 feet of private lake frontage, with wooden piers and a furnished deck near the water. You’ll also find family-friendly perks such as a modern kitchen, family room with an electric fireplace, a fenced-in yard, washer/dryer, and master suite with a clawfoot tub.

7. Cheery Lake House Rental in Indiana – Tippy Cottage on the Lake

Location: Leesburg, Indiana

Rates from: $285 per night

Accommodates: 12 guests

the lake rental in Indiana, showing the driveway
The red lake house | Credit: VRBO
the interior of the lake house rental
The inside of the lake rental | Credit: VRBO

Tippy Cottage is a four-bedroom Indiana lake house retreat on the all-sport Tippecanoe Lake, accommodating up to 12 guests in its cozy interior. The bright and cheery space has an open-concept layout with a living room, dining area, and kitchen, as well as a private deck for taking in the picture-perfect lake views.

The sliding doors in the kitchen lead to an outdoor dining area, while the lower level features a family room that offers access to a grassy front yard and fire pit area. The cottage even has its own private pier to secure your boat.

8. Large Craftsman-Style Indiana Lake House for All Seasons, Sleeps 14

Location: Columbia City, Indiana

Rates from: $470 per night

Accommodates: 14 guests

the lake rental in Indiana near a green lawn and outside chairs
A view of the lake house | Credit: VRBO
the kitchen and eating areas of the property
The open floor plan of the house | Credit: VRBO

For a modern lakeside escape to a lake house rental in Indiana, book a stay at this large craftsman-style retreat that has space for 14. Chic and sophisticated, the four-bedroom home has a stylish interior with modern touches, including a luxurious soaker tub, large 65” TV, crackling fireplace, and fully-equipped chef’s kitchen.

The hosts claim it offers some of the best lake views the Tri-Lakes has to offer, with the inviting rental the perfect home for those looking for a vacation itinerary filled with adventurous outdoor activities like hiking, kayaking, swimming, trail riding, or simply watching the sunset.

9. Jimmerson Blue: Luxury and Comfortable Lake Rental in Indiana, Dock Access

Location: Lake James, Steuben County, Indiana

Rates from: $499 per night

Accommodates: 8 guests

the Indiana lake house with extensive landscaping in front
The lake house with landscaping in front | Credit: VRBO
the lake rental's living room
Living room of the rental house | Credit: VRBO

This elegant four-bedroom lake rental in Indiana has all the essentials, including an outdoor deck, dock access, and a cozy interior. Built for entertaining, the open-concept home has a spacious living room, kitchen, and dining area that comfortably fits up to eight guests, with enticing perks such as a wine chiller, breakfast bar, and butler’s pantry.

The lakeside upper deck is a highlight, offering space to relax and an outdoor dining area. If you want to get out on the lake, pontoons, fishing boats, and jet skies are available to rent.

10. Modern Lake House with Hot Tub, Beach, Fire Pit & Playground

Location: Monticello, Indiana

Rates from: $499 per night

Accommodates: 15 guests

the lake house rental in Indiana from the front
The front of the rental house | Credit: VRBO
the house's dining room table and living room area
The dining and living rooms | Credit: VRBO

Custom-designed for large families and groups on vacation, this five-bedroom lake rental in Indiana accommodates 15 guests and includes the main house plus an attached in-law suite apartment. Some of its family-friendly highlights include a professionally designed, high-end interior, central heat and AC, a 60” flat-screen TV, fast Wi-Fi, and amazing views of the lake.

Spent time outside firing up the BBQ grill, napping in a hammock, or relaxing on the outdoor furniture. At night, the family can share memories around the campfire by the water. Kids will also love the swing set and beach/sand area.

11. Indiana Lake House Escape with Designer Finishes

Location: Pleasant Township, Indiana

Rates from: $249 per night

Accommodates: 12 guests

a frontal view of the lake house rental in Indiana
The lake house from the front | Credit: VRBO
the bright living area of the house rental
The bright living room of the house | Credit: VRBO

Book a stay at this beautiful lake house rental in Indiana for incredible water vistas from its many windows and outdoor deck. Set on Crooked Lake, it allows access to a dock right off the patio and features a sandy swim beach area.

Perfect for sunny days, you can kick back on the patio furniture and watch the sunset, swim off the pier, or plan a cookout and dine alfresco. Afterward, head inside and watch TV while lounging on the sectional sofa and recharge in the comfy bedrooms.

12. Waterfront Monticello Lake Rental in Indiana with Deck & Boat Dock

Location: Carroll County, Indiana

Rates from: $273 per night

Accommodates: 10 guests

the lake house rental in Indiana among greenery
A sunny view of the lake rental | Credit: VRBO
the living room of the lake rental
The rental’s living room | Credit: VRBO

You can temporarily live next to Lake Freeman from this beautiful three-bedroom lake house to rent in Indiana. Featuring a boat slip and dock, the family-friendly space offers lake access, fishing on-site, and plenty of inviting outdoor living space.

You can sway in the hammock on the porch or barbecue on the wrap-around deck, then curl up by one of the two fireplaces. It has everything you need, including a dartboard, Smart TV, and speakers outside, as well as a fully equipped kitchen and farmhouse dining table indoors.

13. Two-Bedroom Lake House Rental in Indiana

Location: Columbia City, Indiana

Rates from: $183 per night

Accommodates: 7 guests

view of the lake rental in Indiana from across the lake
The lake house from across the water | Credit: VRBO
the kitchen of the lake house, showing the island and appliances
Modern kitchen inside the rental | Credit: VRBO

Plan an escape to this two-bedroom Indiana lake house for a serene vacation getaway. Sitting on a 55-acre quiet private lake with no public access, it has a private boat ramp for your use. Completely remodeled, the home has a gourmet-like kitchen, a screened-in porch, and lots of windows for gazing out and enjoying the tranquil lakeside views.

Outside, there’s a 30-foot fishing pier with plenty of fishing and bird-watching opportunities, with fishing poles and kayaks included with your stay.

You may also like

Leave a Comment