Key West blew my mind in ways I never expected. Everyone knows Duval Street and sunset celebrations, but this tiny island packs in experiences most tourists completely miss. I spent ten days exploring every corner of this quirky paradise, constantly finding spots that made me wonder how they weren’t overrun with visitors.
Stock Island won me over with its local vibe and working marina where fishermen bring in your dinner right before your eyes. The quiet streets between Whitehead and Simonton hide century-old houses and secret gardens where locals actually hang out. The best places in Key West mix island weirdness with surprising pockets of calm away from the cruise ship crowds. These 12 spots showed me exactly why people visit for a weekend and mysteriously never leave.
Best Must-Visit Spots in Key West
Looking to uncover Key West’s hidden gems? Beyond the famous spots, the island offers plenty of lesser-known treasures waiting to be explored. Wander through the Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory, a serene oasis. Marvel at the Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park, offering history and beautiful beaches.
Stroll the charming streets of Bahama Village, rich with culture and character. Whether you’re into nature, history, or local charm, here are 12 of Key West’s most underrated destinations!
1. Garbo’s Grill
- 📍 Location: Greene Street, behind Hanks Saloon
- 🏆 Best For: 🌮 Foodies, 🎶 casual hangouts, 🚚 street food lovers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Trying the Korean BBQ tacos, people-watching at lunch, hanging out under the shade trees
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: January to April for comfortable temps and outdoor seating 🍽️
- 🏨 Where to Stay: The Marker Key West Harbor Resort – Bright, modern hotel just a short stroll from the food truck
Garbo’s Grill is proof that some of Key West’s best food doesn’t come with white tablecloths. Parked on Greene Street and operating out of a food truck, this local favorite dishes up Korean BBQ tacos, fish burritos, and other handhelds that punch far above their weight. The atmosphere is relaxed, with shaded picnic tables and live music adding to the charm.
This isn’t the kind of place you stumble on unless you know what you’re looking for. Hidden just behind a small bar, it stays under the radar of most tourists. But locals line up early, especially during peak lunch hours, so timing is everything.
For shorter waits and the best seating, swing by just before noon or closer to 3 PM. It’s a great place to recharge without leaving Old Town, and the food makes it one of those rare places that lives up to the hype.
2. Smathers Beach
- 📍 Location: South Roosevelt Boulevard
- 🏆 Best For: 🏖️ Beachgoers, 🛶 paddleboarders, ☀️ sunrise chasers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Morning swims, paddleboarding the calm shoreline, picnicking under the palms
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: March to May for clear skies and lighter crowds 🌊
- 🏨 Where to Stay: Hyatt Vacation Club at Windward Pointe – Laid-back resort with beach views just steps away
Smathers Beach often gets overlooked in favor of smaller, more central beaches, but that’s part of the appeal. Stretching over half a mile along the Atlantic, it’s one of the longest beaches in Key West, with soft sand and plenty of space to spread out. The beach has calm, shallow waters that are ideal for swimming, paddleboarding, or just cooling off under the sun.
You’ll find restrooms, volleyball nets, food vendors, and gear rentals lining the path, making it easy to spend an entire day without needing to leave. Parking is usually available, and the beach rarely feels overcrowded.
If you can make it early, sunrise here is stunning. The eastern exposure lights up the water in soft pastels, and it’s one of the quietest times to enjoy the shoreline. It’s a peaceful contrast to the bustle of Duval and one of the most relaxing ways to start the day.
- Read next: Most Beautiful Places in Florida
3. The Seamonkey Sandbar Charter
- 📍 Location: Historic Seaport Marina
- 🏆 Best For: 🛥️ Private getaways, 🐠 snorkelers, 🏝️ chill nature lovers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Visiting remote sandbars, snorkeling in clear water, wildlife watching near mangroves
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: April to June for calm seas and good visibility 🌞
- 🏨 Where to Stay: NYAH Key West – Casual and social hotel a short walk from the marina
The Seamonkey Sandbar Charter offers a chance to escape the usual tourist crowds and spend a day on remote, pristine sandbars. These small islands appear during low tide and create shallow pools perfect for relaxing, swimming, or spotting fish just beneath the surface. It feels like you’ve found your own little slice of the Caribbean.
Trips leave from the Historic Seaport and include snorkeling gear, paddleboards, and chilled drinks. The captains are locals who know exactly when and where to go based on the tides. Group sizes are small, which keeps things comfortable and personal.
Booking a full-day charter gives you time to explore more than one sandbar and even cruise by hidden mangroves. It’s one of the most peaceful ways to experience the Florida Keys’ marine beauty without sharing the moment with a hundred other tourists.
4. Key West’s Shipwreck Museum
- 📍 Location: Corner of Whitehead and Front Streets, Old Town
- 🏆 Best For: ⚓ History buffs, 🧭 treasure hunters, 🎭 interactive museum fans
- 📸 Top Experiences: Climbing the tower, seeing shipwreck artifacts, watching live reenactments
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: January to March for smaller crowds and cooler afternoons 🏛️
- 🏨 Where to Stay: Simonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages – Cozy, adults-only escape just blocks away
Key West’s Shipwreck Museum brings Key West’s wrecking era to life through artifacts, storytelling, and panoramic views. Located at Whitehead and Front Streets, it’s easy to find, but surprisingly under-visited compared to more famous attractions nearby. The highlight is the 65-foot lookout tower where wreckers once watched for ships crashing into the reef.
Inside, you’ll find silver bars, recovered tools, and exhibits that show how locals became wealthy salvaging cargo from sunken ships. Actors in period dress bring it all to life with engaging presentations that explain the island’s rise as one of America’s richest cities in the 1800s.
Climbing the tower is worth the effort, especially for sunset views over the harbor. If you enjoy hands-on history and want something beyond the usual beach stops, this museum delivers a unique experience that’s both educational and fun without ever feeling stuffy or slow.
5. Dry Tortugas National Park
- 📍 Location: 70 miles west of Key West, via ferry or seaplane
- 🏆 Best For: 🏝️ Adventure seekers, 🐠 snorkelers, 🏰 history lovers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Exploring Fort Jefferson, snorkeling reefs, flying in by seaplane
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: March to May for great snorkeling visibility and birdwatching 🐦
- 🏨 Where to Stay: Pier House Resort & Spa – Waterfront resort near the ferry departure point
Dry Tortugas National Park feels like an entirely different world, even though it’s technically part of Key West. Accessible only by ferry or seaplane, this remote island chain features one of the largest 19th-century forts in the U.S., surrounded by crystal-clear waters and vibrant coral reefs.
Most people come to snorkel right off the beach, where tropical fish and coral are easy to spot without a boat. The park is also known for bird migrations, especially in spring when thousands nest on nearby islands. It’s an incredible mix of nature and history you won’t find elsewhere.
Plan your trip well in advance, since ferries and flights fill up quickly. Facilities are minimal, so bring everything you need for the day. It’s a full-day commitment, but once you’re floating in the clear blue water, you’ll realize it’s more than worth the effort.
- Read next: Mesmerizing Spots in the Florida Keys
6. Key West Botanical Gardens
- 📍 Location: College Road, Stock Island (east of downtown)
- 🏆 Best For: 🌿 Nature lovers, 🦋 butterfly spotters, 📚 eco-educators
- 📸 Top Experiences: Walking forest trails, visiting the butterfly garden, spotting native wildlife
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: December to March for breezy weather and active wildlife 🐢
- 🏨 Where to Stay: El Patio Motel – Retro tropical hotel just a quick drive away
Key West Botanical Gardens feels more like a jungle preserve than a manicured park. It’s the only frost-free botanical garden in the continental U.S., which means rare tropical species thrive here year-round. It’s especially peaceful compared to the chaos of downtown.
You’ll walk through hardwood hammocks, butterfly gardens, and even freshwater ponds where turtles and wading birds gather. The native plant nursery is worth checking out, especially for travelers interested in sustainability or gardening back home. Everything is clearly labeled and easy to explore at your own pace.
The gardens are on Stock Island, just a short ride from Old Town. Early mornings are best for spotting wildlife and avoiding the heat. If you’re looking for a low-key, nature-rich alternative to bars and beaches, this place offers quiet beauty and a strong local connection to Florida’s native environment.
7. Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park
- 📍 Location: Western tip of Key West, off Truman Waterfront
- 🏆 Best For: 🏖️ Snorkelers, 🏰 history fans, 🌇 sunset seekers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Snorkeling from shore, touring the Civil War fort, watching the sunset
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: February to April for clear skies and warm ocean temps 🐚
- 🏨 Where to Stay: The Paradise Inn – Quiet hideaway less than 10 minutes from the park
Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park is where beach lovers and history fans can both win. Unlike many beaches in Key West, this one is natural, with coral sand and clear waters that are ideal for snorkeling. Colorful fish gather near the rocks just steps from the shore.
The pre-Civil War fort on site is open for tours, offering a fascinating look at how Key West played a role in American military strategy. It also holds the country’s largest collection of Civil War cannons, making it a unique stop for history buffs.
You’ll find shaded picnic areas, bike trails, and plenty of space to relax. Sunset from the west-facing beach is stunning and far more peaceful than the crowded scene at Mallory Square. Bring water shoes, as the coral sand can be rough on bare feet, and plan to stay a while.
8. Blue Heaven Restaurant
- 📍 Location: Thomas Street, Bahama Village
- 🏆 Best For: 🍳 Brunch lovers, 🐓 quirky vibes, 🍰 dessert seekers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Eating Key lime pie, enjoying brunch under trees, listening to live music
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: January to March for breezy mornings and shorter waits 🎶
- 🏨 Where to Stay: Amsterdam’s Curry Mansion Inn – Historic bed and breakfast just two blocks away
Blue Heaven is more than a restaurant. It’s a full sensory experience wrapped in tropical trees, live music, and the occasional wandering rooster. This laid-back favorite in Bahama Village serves up island-inspired dishes with personality, like lobster Benedict and towering Key lime pie.
Its roots run deep in Key West culture. The outdoor patio once hosted boxing matches refereed by Hemingway himself. Now, it’s filled with mismatched chairs, colorful art, and a fun, come-as-you-are atmosphere that makes you want to linger long after your meal.
To beat the brunch rush, arrive before 9 AM or make dinner reservations in advance. The vibe is relaxed but always buzzing, especially on weekends. For anyone looking to taste the creative and casual side of Key West, this is the kind of place you’ll think about long after the trip is over.
9. The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum
- 📍 Location: Whitehead Street, Old Town
- 🏆 Best For: 🖋️ Lit lovers, 🐈 cat enthusiasts, 🏡 architecture fans
- 📸 Top Experiences: Touring Hemingway’s studio, spotting six-toed cats, strolling through the gardens
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: December to February for cooler temps and fewer tour groups 📖
- 🏨 Where to Stay: Almond Tree Inn – Stylish boutique stay just steps from the museum
The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum gives visitors a rare peek into the life of one of America’s literary greats. Ernest Hemingway lived and wrote here in the 1930s, and many of his personal belongings, including his writing studio, remain exactly where he left them.
One of the home’s biggest draws today is the colony of six-toed cats, descendants of Hemingway’s original feline companion. Around 40 to 50 cats roam the lush property, each named after celebrities and historical figures. The gardens themselves are worth a visit, with palms, flowering plants, and tranquil corners.
Plan to arrive before 10 AM to beat the larger guided groups. The museum offers both self-guided tours and informative sessions led by passionate staff. For those interested in writing, history, or just cool island stories, this is one of the most enriching places to visit in Key West.
10. Key West Lighthouse and Keeper’s Quarters Museum
- 📍 Location: Whitehead Street
- 🏆 Best For: 🗼 View seekers, 📚 history fans, 📷 photography buffs
- 📸 Top Experiences: Climbing the lighthouse, touring the Keeper’s Quarters, taking panoramic photos
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: February to April for great weather and fewer crowds 🌇
- 🏨 Where to Stay: Lighthouse Court Hotel – Charming boutique stay just a 3‑minute walk away
The Key West Lighthouse stands about 88 steps above sea level and offers one of the best views on the island. Originally built in the 1840s, the lighthouse served as a critical navigational aid and now functions as a museum that honors the keepers who once lived and worked here.
Unlike many modern towers, this one lets visitors access the original viewing platform. The nearby Keeper’s Quarters offers insight into life in the 1800s, including rare artifacts and stories of female lighthouse keepers who made history.
Late afternoons are a great time to visit. The lighting is perfect for photos, and the grounds become quieter as most tourists head elsewhere. The museum is located across from the Hemingway House, so it’s easy to pair the two for a half-day of exploring Old Town’s cultural side.
11. The Unmarked Home of Tennessee Williams
- 📍 Location: Old Town
- 🏆 Best For: 📚 Literary fans, 🏡 history lovers, 📸 peaceful wanderers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Viewing the unmarked facade, exploring the quiet neighborhood, snapping mid-century architecture
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: November to March for cooler mornings and quieter streets 🌤️
- 🏨 Where to Stay: Opal Key Resort – Stylish waterfront boutique hotel
You won’t find plaques or crowds outside 1431 Duncan Street, and that’s exactly what makes it memorable. This quiet residence was home to Tennessee Williams for over 30 years and still blends seamlessly with the neighborhood’s historic charm. The home isn’t open to the public, but standing outside offers a rare glimpse into the private life of one of America’s great literary figures.
Unlike the more tourist-heavy Hemingway House, this place is unmarked, peaceful, and free to visit. The surrounding streets are lined with tropical trees and old conch-style homes that carry the same timeless feel as Williams’ era.
Take a slow walk through the area between Whitehead and Simonton. Locals sip coffee on their porches, and the quiet atmosphere makes it feel more like a neighborhood than a destination. It’s an underrated place for thoughtful travelers who appreciate history without the spotlight.
12. Key West Cemetery
- 📍 Location: Margaret Street, central Old Town
- 🏆 Best For: ⚰️ History lovers
- 📸 Top Experiences: Reading funny epitaphs, exploring historic grave sites, photographing ornate tombs
- 📅 Best Time to Visit: December to February for cooler, dry mornings 🌤️
- 🏨 Where to Stay: The Gardens Hotel – Quiet, upscale boutique stay within walking distance
Right in the heart of Old Town, the Key West Cemetery offers a unique way to experience the island’s eccentric side. Established in 1847, it holds around 100,000 graves, many of which feature famously witty epitaphs like “I Told You I Was Sick.” The mix of humor and history gives the place a character you won’t find in typical cemeteries.
Sections are divided by culture and religion, reflecting Key West’s diverse roots. You’ll find everything from a memorial to Cuban freedom fighters to plots honoring Civil War veterans. A self-guided map is available at the sexton’s office for those who want to dig deeper.
It’s a calm and reflective space, especially in the early morning light when temperatures are cooler. Photographers will appreciate the weathered headstones and elaborate sculptures, while curious visitors will walk away with stories they didn’t expect to find in a cemetery.
- Read Next: 13 Bucket List Vacation Rentals in Key West
