Coziest Cottage Rentals in Cape Cod, Massachusetts You’ll Never Want to Leave

I’ll never forget my first Cape Cod cottage rental—one of those adorable gray-shingled houses in Chatham that made me feel like I’d stepped into a coastal movie set. After spending countless weekends exploring the Cape (and trust me, sampling every lobster roll I could find), I’m officially converted to the cottage life. Hotels just can’t compare.

Listen, some of the best places in Cape Cod are these charming little homes that put you right by the water. After staying at rentals all over the peninsula, from historic captains’ houses in Orleans to modern spots steps from the beach, I’ve found the absolute gems that’ll make your New England dreams come true. And yes, your morning coffee really does taste better when you’re watching the waves from your own porch.

The Best Rental Homes in Cape Cod: Lakefront Cottages to Rent in 2025

Here are the best Cape Cod rentals by category, considering factors including amenities, trip types, and budgets. The subsequent sections will cover each listing in more detail.

• Most Affordable Cape Cod Rental: Keyes Memorial Beach Vacation House
• Best Beachfront Cottage for Kayaking: Swan Pond Vacation Rental
• Most Spacious Cape Cod Getaway: Pond-Front Beach Glass Cottage
• Best Lazy Day Relaxation Spot: Long Pond VRBO with BBQ & Hammock
• Picture-Picture Prime Location: Quintessential P’town Getaway
• Top Cape Cod Rental for Wine Lovers: Bass River Rental Near Martha’s Vineyard
• Shortest House-to-Water Journey: New Seabury Rental Steps Away from Beach
• Top Spot in Cape Cod for Animal Lovers: Dog-Friendly Rental Getaway
• Most Funny for Ferry Riders: Cozy Cape Cod Cottage Near Nantucket
• Most Must-See Scenic Views: Two-Bedroom Beach House in Eastham
• Best Place to Enjoy the Ocean Breeze: Rental Getaway with Comfy Outdoor Patio
• Most Unique Cape Cod Rental: Cottage Condo with Stylish Brick Walkways
• Shopaholic’s Delight: Beach House in Walking Distance of Stores & Restaurant

13 Best Vacation Homes for Rent in Cape Cod: VRBO Cottages & Cabins

If swimming, boating, fishing, or just relaxing on the beach sound like fun things to do in Cape Cod, you’re in for a treat! Here are some of the most unique stays in Massachusetts:

1. Charming Home Close to Everything

• 📍 Location: Eastham, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $475/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Close to the beach, outdoor fire pit, patio area with propane fire pit/table
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 🏖️, beach lovers 🌊, relaxation seekers 🌞

Welcome to this charming home, ideally located just a short drive from Nauset Lighthouse and Nauset Beach. This peaceful retreat is perfect for families or small groups looking to unwind and explore everything Eastham has to offer.

The home features three cozy bedrooms, two bathrooms, including a master suite with a jetted tub. The fully equipped kitchen and open living area are perfect for relaxation.

Step outside and enjoy the outdoor shower, or relax in the garden and play area. Just minutes from the beach, you’ll have access to water activities like sailing, boating, and surfing.

Nearby, explore Nauset Lighthouse or take a short drive to Provincetown for more dining, shopping, and sightseeing options. Whether you’re relaxing by the fire or enjoying the beach, this home offers the perfect base for your getaway! 

2. Charming Cottage in the Woods

• 📍 Location: Wellfleet, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $225/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 4 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Secluded woodland setting, close to beaches, bird-watching, outdoor dining
• 🌟 Perfect For: Couples 👫, small families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, beach lovers 🏖️, nature enthusiasts 🌲

Tucked away in the woods, this charming cottage offers peaceful seclusion with easy access to nearby beaches and the town. Perfect for small families or couples, it’s just a short walk to Indian Neck Beach and a quick drive to Cahoon Hollow and Marconi Beaches.

Inside, the cottage features a cozy living area, a fully equipped kitchen, and two comfortable bedrooms. The front and side decks are perfect for outdoor dining, featuring a grill, dining table with an umbrella, and Adirondack chairs for relaxing.

Enjoy the tranquil views of Fox Island Marsh and bird-watching right from the deck. The garden and outdoor space provide plenty of room to relax and enjoy nature.

Close by, explore beautiful beaches like Indian Neck, go boating, surfing, or paddle boating, and enjoy the serene environment of Wellfleet. With its ideal location, this home offers a peaceful base for your adventure!

3. Steps to the Ocean Home

• 📍 Location: Barnstable, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $172/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: In-ground heated pool (seasonal), air conditioning, ocean view, private patio
• 🌟 Perfect For: Beach lovers 🏖️, families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, relaxation seekers 🌅

Escape to this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage just steps from Keyes Memorial Beach. Tucked in a quiet cul-de-sac, it offers a king bed, two twin beds, and a queen pull-out sofa, perfect for families or small groups.

The bright and airy living room, with cathedral ceilings, enhances the relaxed Cape Cod feel. The fully equipped kitchen ensures you can prepare meals easily or enjoy BBQing on your private patio. 

The cottage is also a short distance from historic downtown Hyannis, offering dining, shopping, and ferry access to Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket.

Outdoor enthusiasts will love the nearby beach, whale watching, fishing, and boating. Enjoy the seasonal in-ground pool, or explore Hyannis Harbor and the Cape Cod Melody Tent. Centrally located, it’s ideal for day trips to Provincetown and beyond.

4. Queen Anne Style Home

• 📍 Location: Provincetown, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $200/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 4 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private entrance, 3000 sq ft space, steps from Commercial Street, historic charm
• 🌟 Perfect For: Couples 👫, history buffs 📚, beach lovers 🏖️

Begin your stay at the Queen Anne-style Home, a charming 1B/1B unit with a private entrance in the heart of historic Provincetown. Perfect for couples or small groups, this beautifully preserved property blends modern comfort with classic New England charm.

Within, the living room features a double sofa bed, and the bedroom offers a queen bed, comfortably sleeping up to 4 guests. The bathroom includes a shower, offering a relaxing retreat after a day of exploring.

Step out and you’re just steps from Provincetown’s best spots. Stroll Commercial Street for shops, galleries, and cafes, climb the Pilgrim Monument for panoramic views, or check out local events at Town Hall.

Nearby, relax on the beach, take a scenic walk along the waterfront, or enjoy the town’s vibrant dining and nightlife. Provincetown Municipal Airport is just 8 minutes away, making your getaway easy and stress-free.

5. Charming Stand-Alone 1940s Cottage

• 📍 Location: Eastham, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $277/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 3 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: 1940s charm, loft-style studio, dog-friendly, private outdoor dining area
• 🌟 Perfect For: Solo travelers 🌅, couples 👫, pet owners 🐾

Welcome to this 1940s cottage stunner – a spacious studio with a cozy loft feel, nestled in the heart of Eastham. Perfect for a peaceful Cape Cod escape, this charming retreat blends vintage character with modern touches.

On the inside, you’ll find an open living space with a queen bed, double futon, and a fireplace to warm your evenings. The well-equipped kitchen and private patio with outdoor dining make it easy to relax and unwind.

Outside,  enjoy the quiet surroundings or explore nearby gems. The Salt Pond Visitor Center is just a 2-minute drive, while Nauset Light Beach and Nauset Beach are both within 10 minutes.

Whether you’re walking the dog, watching the sunset, or hitting the beach, this cozy hideaway offers the perfect balance of comfort, charm, and coastal adventure.

6. Beach Home with Stunning Ocean Views

• 📍 Location: Mashpee, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $438/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 5 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Ocean view, private beach access, cathedral ceilings, large brick patio
• 🌟 Perfect For: Beach lovers 🏖️, families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, relaxation seekers 🌅

Relax in this two-bedroom beach cottage in Maushop Village (New Seabury), located just steps from your private saltwater ocean beach! 

Enjoy stunning ocean views, cathedral ceilings, and modern furnishings throughout the cottage. The fully equipped kitchen allows for easy meal preparation, or you can unwind on the large brick patio.

Walk to Maushop’s private beach or explore Popponesset Marketplace with its shops, mini golf, restaurants, and the famous Raw Bar. The nearby Mashpee Commons offers more shopping, dining, and entertainment. 

New Seabury features scenic walking paths, biking trails, and miles of beaches. Day trips to Nantucket are easily accessible from nearby ferries, making this cottage the perfect spot for both relaxation and adventure! 

7. Beach Glass Cottage

• 📍 Location: Barnstable, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $350/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 7 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Pond-front view, fire pit, large deck, game area, renovated kitchen
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, nature lovers 🌳, relaxation seekers 🌅

Enjoy a relaxing stay at the Beach Glass Cottage, a beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom property located in the heart of Hyannis. 

Enjoy pond views, a large backyard with a fire pit, horseshoe pit, and bocce court—just a short walk to Main Street Hyannis for shops, dining, and live shows at the Cape Cod Melody Tent.

Nearby attractions include Craigville Beach and Keyes Memorial Beach, with a beach sticker included for free parking. Hop on a ferry to Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard, or take a whale-watching excursion from Barnstable Harbor. 

From exploring to unwinding, this charming cottage is the perfect base for your Cape Cod getaway.

8. Cozy Beachfront Cottage

• 📍 Location: Mashpee, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $299/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 4 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private beach access, ocean views, balcony
• 🌟 Perfect For: Beach lovers 🏖️, small families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, Cape Cod explorers 🌊

Step into this bright and breezy beachfront cottage with stunning ocean views in Mashpee’s Maushop Village. Just steps from the private beach, this coastal gem offers the perfect setting for a relaxing Cape Cod escape.

Indoor, the thoughtfully designed space features two comfortable bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, and an open kitchen and dining area. Enjoy the modern conveniences of AC, in-unit laundry, and a private balcony.

Head outside and walk straight onto the sand, or unwind in the sun with beach chairs provided. Grill up a seaside dinner al fresco, or wander the charming village paths and coastal gardens nearby.

Close by, spend the day at Popponesset Beach or explore hands-on exhibits at the Cape Cod Children’s Museum. Head to Mashpee Commons for shopping or take a scenic drive along the Cape’s coastline. From beachcombing to boutique browsing, this spot offers endless coastal charm.

9. Swan Pond Cottage

• 📍 Location: South Dennis, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $258/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 4 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Waterfront view, pet-friendly, open floor plan, kayaks & paddleboards
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, outdoor enthusiasts 🛶, relaxation seekers 🌅

Unwind at Swan Pond Cottage, a newly renovated 2-bedroom waterfront retreat with stunning views. Bring your kayaks or paddleboards to explore Swan Pond River, leading to Nantucket Sound, or visit Great Island for more outdoor fun.

Relax on the spacious deck, enjoy a meal on the paved patio, or simply unwind in the peaceful surroundings. The cottage is located near the Cape Cod Rail Trail, Sea Street Beach, and West Dennis Beach, providing easy access to biking, hiking, and beach activities.

From kayaking and biking to relaxing by the pond, this charming cottage is the perfect base for your Cape Cod getaway.

10. Gray Piper Cottage B

• 📍 Location: Bass River, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $200 avg/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 4 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Private shaded patio, semi-private backyard, central A/C with HEPA filters
• 🌟 Perfect For: Beach lovers 🏖️, relaxation seekers 🌞, nature enthusiasts 🌳

Gray Piper Cottage B is a renovated 1940s Cape Cod-style retreat, just 0.5 miles from Nantucket Sound beaches. This cozy cottage offers a modern living area with a queen bedroom and a slipcovered sofa bed, perfect for small groups or couples.

Updated with granite countertops, an electric range, and fresh bathroom features, the cottage combines vintage charm with modern amenities. Samsung Smart TVs are provided for streaming your favorite shows.

Relax on the private shaded patio or explore nearby Bass River Beaches and Parker’s River Beach, perfect for swimming, sailing, or water activities.

Explore the Whydah Pirate Museum for a glimpse of Cape Cod’s pirate history, or have fun at the Cape Cod Inflatable Park. For shopping, head to Hyannis Mall. From beach lovers to nature enthusiasts, Gray Piper Cottage B offers easy access to trails and golf courses.

11. Cozy House near The Beach

• 📍 Location: Yarmouth, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $317/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Newly renovated, pet-friendly, beach chairs, walking distance to ferries
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 🏖️, beach lovers 🌊, outdoor enthusiasts 🚤

Welcome to this Cape Cod-style beach getaway, nestled on a quiet dead-end street just 6 minutes from the beach. Newly renovated in 2020, it features modern amenities, stainless steel appliances, updated countertops, and fresh flooring throughout.

The spacious kitchen and dining area provide a perfect place to gather. With 3 bedrooms, including a king, queen, and two twin beds, this home comfortably sleeps up to 6 guests.

Head outside to the deck or patio and enjoy the peaceful surroundings. A short walk takes you to the beach, where you can relax in provided beach chairs, swim, or watch boats.

Nearby, explore Hyannis Harbor for boating, visit the John F. Kennedy Hyannis Museum, or catch a show at the Cape Cod Melody Tent. Take a short drive to enjoy sailing, jet skiing, and more. From relaxing to thrilling water activities, this location offers endless adventures. 

12. Steps to the Beach with an Ocean View

• 📍 Location: Barnstable, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $225/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Ocean view, pool access, fully equipped kitchen
• 🌟 Perfect For: Beach lovers 🏖️, families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, relaxation seekers 🌅

This charming 2-bedroom cottage is just 120 steps from Keyes Beach. Ideal for families, this cozy home sleeps up to 6 guests with a king bed, 2 twin beds, and a pull-out sofa. Enjoy spectacular ocean views and breathtaking sunsets right from your deck.

Perfectly located for beach lovers, you’re just a short walk to Sea St. Beach and Keyes Beach, with Hyannis Harbor and Cape Cod Melody Tent only a few minutes away by car. 

The cottage features air conditioning, a fully equipped kitchen, strong Wi-Fi, and a pool that’s open from Memorial Day to Labor Day. 

Explore the nearby shops and restaurants, or take a day trip to Martha’s Vineyard or Nantucket via the nearby ferry. This property is perfect for a relaxing beach vacation with plenty of nearby attractions. 

13. Cozy Beach Home Getaway

• 📍 Location: Yarmouth, MA
• 💵 Price Per Night: $280/night
• 🛏️ Sleeps: 6 guests
• 🔥 Unique Features: Kayaks, outdoor shower, spacious yard
• 🌟 Perfect For: Families 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦, nature lovers 🌳, relaxation seekers 🌅

Unwind at this relaxing Cape Cod getaway! This charming 3-bedroom home is ideal for families or groups seeking a peaceful retreat. With flexible sleeping arrangements for up to 6 guests, it features two queen beds, one twin bed with trundle, and a futon. 

Enjoy a spacious kitchen, a cozy living room, and a breakfast area that overlooks the deck and backyard. The property also boasts beautiful hydrangea gardens, a large deck for relaxation, and an oversized hammock.

Just a block away, Long Pond offers swimming, kayaking, fishing, and a playground. Walk to Route 28 for dining and shopping, or visit nearby West Dennis Beach. Explore Cape Cod Inflatable Park and Cape Cod Rail Trail, or take a short drive to Hyannis. 

This home offers the perfect blend of relaxation, adventure, and convenience.