11 INSANE Things to Do in Key West at Night (Don’t Sleep On #7!)

219

Key West after dark is where the real party starts, folks. Once the sunset chasers clear out of Mallory Square, this tiny island cranks up the volume with a nightlife that would make pirates proud. No joke, even Hemingway might raise an eyebrow at some of these shenanigans!

Want to know the best things to do in Key West at night? From drag shows that’ll have you spitting out your rum runner to bar hopping down Duval Street where the party never stops (seriously, never), this is Florida’s wildest after-hours scene. Whether you’re crushing fresh oysters at 2am or joining a ghost tour where the stories are actually true, Key West proves the best stories always start after sunset.

• 👉 Pro Tip: I HIGHLY recommend this luxury sunset sail in Key West! They take you cruising on a 70-foot catamaran with unlimited drinks and fresh seafood apps, plus live local music while the sun sets over the Gulf. You also get the perfect mix of party vibes and paradise views without the packed tourist boats. This sunset cruise is a must-do on a Key West itinerary in my opinion.

Best Things to Do in Key West at Night (Updated 2025)

Are you ready to explore the most unique things to do in Key West in the nighttime? As mentioned earlier, there’s a wide range of exciting activities in Key West after dark. Keep reading to find where to go in Key West at night, uncovering beautiful spots in the Florida Keys.

1. Bar hop down Duval Street for live music and dancing

Duval Street is where the real party happens in Key West, and it’s a ton of fun. This mile-long stretch has 43 bars (yes, someone actually counted), and each one has its own vibe. Sloppy Joe’s is the obvious tourist stop, but don’t skip it – their live bands are actually pretty solid, and the drinks are generous. I spent way too much time there last visit.

The Green Parrot Bar is where you’ll find the locals mixed with travelers, and it’s been around forever for good reason. Their live music ranges from jazz to rock, and honestly, you never know who might show up to jam. Grab one of their local craft beers and settle in. Rick’s is the massive eight-bars-in-one complex that gets wild after 9pm – it’s got everything from a piano bar to a full dance club upstairs.

Most bars stay open until 2am or later, and many have happy hour specials from 4-7pm. Don’t try to hit all 43 in one night (trust me on this), but bar hopping between 3-4 spots makes for a perfect evening. The whole strip transforms after sunset into this buzzing party zone that somehow manages to feel both touristy and authentic at the same time.

• Read next: Epic Places in South Florida

2. Take a ghost tour through Key West’s haunted spots

Key West ghost tours run every single night, and honestly, they’re way better than I expected. The main Ghosts & Gravestones tour runs about $30-35 per person and takes you around town on their “Trolley of the Doomed” – yes, that’s really what they call it. Tours typically start at 7:30pm or 8pm from the Conch Tour Train Depot at 501 Front Street.

You’ll hit all the spooky spots like Captain Tony’s Saloon (built around an actual hanging tree), the Ernest Hemingway House, and the Key West Cemetery where the tombstones have some seriously dark humor. The guides really get into character and know how to tell a story that’ll give you chills. I actually jumped during one of the tales about Robert the Doll – that thing is legitimately creepy.

The tours last about 60-90 minutes and they do get pretty popular, especially around Halloween, so book ahead. Some companies offer walking tours instead of trolley rides, which I’d recommend if you want to actually walk through the supposedly haunted spots instead of just driving by. They’re not suitable for kids under 13, and honestly, some of the stories are intense enough that I wouldn’t bring younger ones anyway.

3. Grab dinner and drinks at Sunset Pier

Sunset Pier at Ocean Key Resort is one of those places that actually lives up to the hype. You’re literally dining over the water with unobstructed Gulf views, and when the sun starts setting, it’s pretty magical. The tables are first-come, first-served, so get there about 90 minutes before sunset if you want a good spot.

The food is solid island fare – their fish tacos are really good, and the conch fritters are a must-try Key West classic. Drinks are pricey (welcome to waterfront dining), but their Sunset Margarita and Key Lime Martini are both worth it. I love that they have local Sunset Pier Amber Ale brewed specifically for them by Florida Keys Brewing Co.

Live music happens every evening, usually local island musicians who know how to set the right tropical vibe. The whole pier gets packed during sunset celebration, but it’s the kind of busy that feels festive rather than overwhelming. Open daily from noon to sunset, and honestly, even if you just grab a drink and watch the sunset, it’s one of those Key West experiences you can’t skip.

4. Go night kayaking with Ibis Bay Paddle Sports

Ibis Bay Paddle Sports offers the coolest nighttime activity in Key West, hands down. Their LED night kayaking tours launch at sunset (times vary seasonally, so call 305-296-0616 for exact times) and cost around $60-70 per person. The clear-bottom kayaks are fitted with bright underwater LED lights that literally turn the water into an aquarium beneath you.

I was skeptical about how much marine life we’d actually see, but within minutes of paddling out, we spotted stingrays, tropical fish, and even some small sharks gliding right under our kayaks. The guides are super knowledgeable about the local ecosystem and point out creatures you’d never notice on your own. The whole experience takes about 1.5 hours and happens in the protected waters of Ibis Bay, so it’s calm and suitable for beginners.

The only downside is that tours can get canceled for weather, and they don’t always call ahead (learned this the hard way). Double-check your booking the day of. But when it works out, paddling through that glowing water while watching nocturnal sea life is one of those memories you’ll never forget. It’s definitely more magical than any of the regular day tours.

5. Book a sunset sailing cruise with Fury Water Adventures

Fury Water Adventures has been Key West’s go-to water sports company for almost 30 years, and their sunset cruises are consistently solid. Their Champagne Sunset Cruise runs about $65-80 per person and departs from the Historic Seaport at 241 Front Street. You’ll sail on their spacious 45-foot power catamaran with complimentary beer, wine, champagne, and soda.

What I like about Fury is they don’t oversell their boats, so you’re not packed in like sardines. The Commotion on the Ocean sunset sail includes live music from local Key West musicians, which adds to the whole experience. Both cruises last about 2-3 hours and time the sailing perfectly so you’re in the ideal spot when the sun hits the horizon.

I’ve done sunset cruises in lots of places, but Key West’s are special because you’re sailing into the Gulf of Mexico with nothing but open water and sky. The crew knows exactly where to position the boat for the best views and photos. Book online with promo code 2025 to save up to $15 per person. They guarantee the lowest prices when you book direct, and honestly, the sunset views from the water beat watching from land every single time.

6. Try night snorkeling at Key West Dive Center

Night snorkeling in Key West is completely different from daytime trips, and way more exciting than I thought it would be. Key West Dive Center and several other operators run evening snorkel tours that typically cost $45-65 per person. The underwater world totally transforms after dark – you’ll see octopus, lobsters, crabs, and fish that only come out at night.

The guides provide underwater lights that illuminate everything around you, creating this almost otherworldly experience. I saw my first Caribbean reef octopus on a night snorkel, and it was incredible watching it change colors and textures. The water is usually calmer at night too, so visibility is often better than during busy daytime hours.

Most tours last 2-3 hours and include all snorkel gear. Some companies use LED-lit boats or underwater lights to attract marine life. You don’t need to be an experienced snorkeler, but you should be comfortable in the water since you’ll be out after dark. Sunset Watersports also offers night snorkel trips that combine sunset viewing with the underwater adventure, which is a pretty cool way to transition from day to night activities.

7. Eat upscale dinner at Louie’s Backyard restaurant

Louie’s Backyard is hands-down one of Key West’s most romantic restaurants, and I finally understand why everyone raves about it. This Victorian house right on the Atlantic serves creative Caribbean-American cuisine that’s actually worth the splurge. Reservations are essential – call ahead or book online for lunch (11:30am-2:30pm) or dinner (5pm-9pm).

The Bahamian Conch Chowder with bird pepper hot sauce is phenomenal, and their daily fresh catch is always perfectly prepared. I had the Root Beer Glazed Pork Chop with bourbon sweet potato mash, and it was one of those dishes that makes you understand why people become food obsessed. The Key Lime Pie is mandatory – it’s the real deal, not the green stuff you find at tourist traps.

What makes this place special is the setting. You can dine in the elegant indoor rooms, but the outdoor Afterdeck Bar literally hangs over the ocean. The sunset views are incredible, and the sound of waves hitting the rocks below creates this perfect tropical ambiance. Entrees run $28-42, but for a special night out, it’s worth every penny. The Café upstairs offers smaller plates and tapas if you want the atmosphere without the full fine-dining commitment.

8. Drink craft beer and hear live music at Green Parrot Bar

The Green Parrot Bar has been Key West’s beloved dive bar since 1890, and it’s still the best place to experience authentic local nightlife. Located just off Duval Street at the corner of Southard and Whitehead, this place attracts everyone from shrimp boat captains to famous musicians who drop in for impromptu sessions.

The bar serves excellent local craft beers alongside classic cocktails, and their live music lineup is legitimately impressive. You might catch anything from blues to reggae to rock, and the acoustics in the old wooden building are surprisingly good. I love that it feels like a neighborhood bar that happens to be in a tourist town, rather than a tourist bar pretending to be local.

Green Parrot opens daily around 10am and stays lively until 2am. Happy hour runs 4-7pm with drink specials. The crowd is this perfect mix of locals who’ve been coming for decades and travelers who stumbled upon something authentic. Don’t expect anything fancy – the charm is in the weathered wood, the stories from regulars, and the fact that you never know who might walk through the door. It’s Key West nightlife at its most genuine.

9. Walk the boardwalk at Key West Historic Seaport

Key West Historic Seaport is where you go when you want to wander without a plan and discover cool stuff. This 20-acre waterfront area has everything from restaurants to museums to charter fishing boats, and it’s especially nice in the evening when the crowds thin out and the lights reflect on the water.

Schooner Wharf Bar anchors the whole scene with live music every night and that quintessential Key West dive bar atmosphere. Half Shell Raw Bar serves up fresh local seafood with harbor views, and their happy hour (4:30-6:30pm daily) has great deals on oysters and shrimp. I always end up at Conch Republic Seafood Company for their frozen drinks and waterfront patio.

The boardwalk itself is perfect for evening strolls, and you’ll often catch street performers or live music drifting from the various bars. The Waterfront Brewery is huge with multiple levels and a game room if you want something more upscale. What I love about the Historic Seaport is that it feels like a real working waterfront that happens to have great bars and restaurants, not a manufactured tourist attraction. Park for free after 6pm at most lots, making it perfect for evening exploration.

• Read next: Best Airlines to Fly to Florida

10. Order decadent desserts at Better Than Sex restaurant

Better Than Sex is Key West’s adults-only dessert restaurant, and it’s exactly as indulgent as the name suggests. Open Wednesday-Sunday from 6pm-11pm (until midnight on Saturdays), this intimate spot serves only desserts, wines, and specialty cocktails in a dimly-lit, sensual atmosphere designed for couples or close friends.

Every dessert has a cheeky name, but the food is seriously impressive. The “Between My Red Velvet Sheets Cheesecake” and “Cookie Nookie Pie” are both incredible, and their signature chocolate-rimmed wine glasses are a nice touch. I tried the “Tall, Dark, and Handsome” chocolate cake with chocolate stout beer, and it was rich enough to share (which is the point).

Tables are semi-private with curtains or walls between them, creating an intimate vibe that’s perfect for date night. They limit parties to four people maximum and definitely cater to adult tastes and conversations. Desserts run $12-18 each, which is pricey but reasonable for the quality and experience. Make reservations online – they’re often booked solid, especially on weekends. It’s a unique Key West experience that you’ll either love or find too over-the-top, but it’s definitely memorable.

11. Relax under the stars at Higgs Beach

Higgs Beach is perfect for ending your Key West adventure with a relaxing under the stars. This 17-acre public beach on the Atlantic side is less crowded than Smathers Beach and has a more local feel. The white sand is imported from the Caribbean, and there’s plenty of room to spread out.

Locals often gather here in the evenings to watch sunsets and enjoy the beach atmosphere. There are picnic tables, barbecue grills you can use, and the White Street Pier extending far into the water creates a dramatic backdrop. The beach is also home to the only shore-accessible underwater marine park in the U.S., so snorkeling here is pretty incredible.

Higgs Beach has free parking, restrooms, and is open 24/7. The Salute! on the Beach restaurant is right there if you want drinks or food. What makes this beach special is that it combines relaxation with history – you’ll find the West Martello Tower (a Civil War fort), the African Refugee Memorial, and Key West Garden Club all within the park grounds. It’s the perfect place to decompress after all the nightlife and reflect on your Key West adventure with the sound of waves and stars overhead.

• Read next: Beautiful Spots in Florida